Soft coral IDs

[ChunkyMunky Pengopus]

Hello there, I am having a bit of trouble with some of these coral IDs, and would like to know what is in my tank. Here is my build thread for more info: ChunkyMunky Pengopus's 63 gallon reef

I'm pretty sure this is not frogspawn...

The orangish red corals in the back- they like lower light

The large flat coral behind the powerhead

 

[Bfragale]

Looks like photo 1,3,5 Yuma ricordia mushrooms.

photo 2 looks like some kind of paly’s

photo 4 - not really sure but maybe some kind of mushroom as well would be my guess.

 

[ChunkyMunky Pengopus]

Looks like photo 1,3,5 Yuma ricordia mushrooms.

photo 2 looks like some kind of paly’s

photo 4 - not really sure but maybe some kind of mushroom as well would be my guess.

Thanks! Looking at pictures I think you might be spot on, although I think 1 is something else, it really doesn't behave like the other ones.

 

[Soren]

Photo 1 could be a Caribbean umbrella mushroom Discosoma carlgreni.

 

[Bfragale]

Photo 4 may be a different species of mushroom. Maybe a discosoma?

 

[danieyella]

1 might be a st thomas?

 

[ChunkyMunky Pengopus]

Photo 4 may be a different species of mushroom. Maybe a discosoma?

1 might be a st thomas?

Thanks! 4 might be a discosoma

St. Thomas mushrooms do actually look a lot like 1