No, I have a Cadlights. They get a bad rap because they custom make all of their products, and some of the stuff they do is slightly unpolished. For example people complain about the cutout in the stand that leads down to the sump not being finished with the same quality as everything else, when honestly that part doesn't matter all that much.
They also get a hard way to go for the plumbing in their tank being garbage, and most people replace what it comes with with higher end stuff. Lastly when people complain about things that aren't really that big of a deal, they have a reputation for being difficult about it.
So... there are some issues. For the price and specifics of the tanks though they are pretty good. Every aquarium company will have tanks that burst at the seams. Most of the time it's from a larger tank being unlevel. At 125 gallons+ it needs to be less than an 1/8" level the entire way around to be sound from an engineering standpoint. Sometimes it's a manufacturing issue, but it's more often user error IMO. Floors drift and settle under 3,000 lbs of static pressure.
Anyways I'm no expert but I did my research on cadlights before I bought mine, and this has been my perception.