SPS and nutrients

Jeremy Luke

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 17, 2017
Messages
547
Reaction score
358
Location
Northern VA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My current tank has been up and running for about 1.5 years. I have struggled with coloration with some of my SPS. In May, while I was on a business trip, my ATO failed and I came back to several pieces seemingly dead.

About a month ago I left for a week with no one to feed the fish. I set up my auto feeder and had it feed pellets and flakes 3 times a day while I was gone (I typically only feed frozen food). Upon my return, my tank was filled with a good bit of algae (glass covered thickly, sand greenish brown, big cyano spot) but the coral looked fantastic. The best it's been. A small colony that I was sure had died in the May debacle was colored up and happy. Polyp extension extreme. Alk uptake has doubled.

I have continued to feed the flake/pellet combo (along with frozen food) but have been slowly cutting back on the pellets/flake as my cyano problem is finally starting to recede. The sticks still have good color and I'm scared to lose it.

Before the trip last month I meticulously maintained my PO4 in a range of .05-.06ppm (Hanna ULR). I hadn't even measured it again since the trip last month until recently. It is currently at .13ppm.

I have only been using a skimmer. I previously tried running GFO in a reactor and found that no matter how little I ran it would strip out all PO4.

Should I try to continue to lower the PO4 slowly by less nutrient import with the system as is or would you recommend that I continue to feed heavy and export more? I was thinking about trying an algae reactor as a more docile way of exporting nutrients over the GFO. I have always thought that PO4 level is PO4 level.. but perhaps the magic is in mass import / export? Any suggestions are appreciated.
 
The magic is in throughput, not a number on a test kit.

Watch the BRS video on ZeoVit... while I do not use ZeoVit and probably never will, they sum it best by saying something like "this is one of the most nutrient rich tanks that we have ever seen with all that we add and feed, but the export is also good and the levels on a test kit stay really low."

Using GFO on a tank is not usually a good idea unless you are really high... and none of your P numbers are all that high. Your light colored issues might have been with the GFO which worked too hard on the removal side.

My tank has about .005 to .01 P (1 to 3 ppb on Hannah Ultra Low from day to day), but I feed about 6-12 cubes of mysis a day and have a Ehiem feeder dropping in pellets 4 other times. I am going to have more N, P, organic carbon, aminos, fatty acids, etc, than people with a high test kit number that feed 1 cube and a small pinch each day.

I would just try and level out your PO4 at a solid, low level and keep the equilibrium well fed... there is magic here, IMO. If you trend up, then maybe export more... if you are trending towards zero, then time to trim back some Chaeto.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top