SPS dominant tanks - What Reef Salt for 2022?

What Salt do you use for SPS dominant tanks in 2022?


  • Total voters
    199

i_am_mclovin

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 18, 2018
Messages
417
Reaction score
593
What state or country do you live in
Wisconsin
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I saw this poll in the general forum, but thought it would be very interesting to see the answers by people who are running SPS dominant systems only. So, please only answer if you are running an SPS dominant system or have in the past and what salt you are using.

And if you don't mind posting please provide:

* explanations why you chose that salt for your SPS system
* anything else you do when you mix salt (such as Muriatic Acid to bring Alk down etc).
 
I/O purple box.

-Mixes clean without any residue (ppl always say there's a residue bc they think purple box is the same as RC when it's not)

- Available on 12hrs notice from Amazon for $.14-$.2/gal.

-has had the most reliable mixing parameters of any salt I've looked at (very few threads on I/O purple box issues)


AFAIKT a lot of ppl associate some of the negatives of Reef crystals (high alk, brown residue) to purple box. Mostly bc they haven't tried purple box.

A lot of ppl also don't seem to know how laughable the pricing chart BRS published is.


Salt has become like everything else in the hobby (premium offering oriented) so purple box is a step child. But you'll never hear about bad batches of purple box, or have to check the label to see if your batch was made in Turkey or not.

Pick a premium salt and while it may be good today, with the exception of Red Sea (maybe) it's not really guaranteed to be good tomorrow.like I/O purple box will be......
 
I like instant ocean just fine. I can see the attraction of Red Sea and Tropic Marin. I have read about over the top acropora dominant systems and people use virtually every salt imaginable and get stellar results. The moral seems to be that it is the reefer and their husbandry that is the recipe for success and not what salt mix they are using.
 
Dear colleagues,
Tropic Marin Pro, no extra additives and normally mixed after 6h.
Mostly due to the low Alk and clean after mixing.
Cheers!

4C64F971-8678-479D-BA59-F62E41B75FCD.jpeg
 
95% SPS system
IO purple. Switched back during covid as ESV was out.

I get residue but just run a small amount of carbon in a bag and it does not leave the brown residue in my brute.

IO has a high alk so I reduce it using sodium bisulfate to 8.
Ca and Mag are right where I run my systems.

I only do 10% WC once a month.
Plus you can get 320g's of IO for the price of 100g's of Esv.
20211231_145043.jpg
 
Loving the replies, really great details in responses. I myself have certainly gone from salt to salt in the past, mostly based upon stability and availability. But really enjoy seeing what people are doing these days with SPS dominant tanks and why.
 
I have used IO for many years. I have a 400 gallon system all SPS. I do 50 gallons a week water change. If I had a small system I might try the more expensive salts. I'll take the extra savings and buy more coral. Take care
 
Blue bucket here on a 75g SPS tank. 10% WC weekly. Moderate success and I use it because it matches my tank params so it’s easy. If IO had lower alk I would use that but I’m all about stability.
 
I was doing some pricing out as I was considering trying Tropic Marin but the cost per gallon for 35ppt salinity is crazy! It ends up at 67 cents per gallon compared to everything else which is around 29 cents to 48 cents.
 
IO purple box, been in this hobby for a while and can say that salt is salt and it’s not the reason your stuff isn’t growing. Don’t spend more than you need to and always make sure it’s available. When I was a newbie I felt I had to always get the Red Sea blue bucket but it was $75 and not always easy to find.

I can get IO at petsmart if I had to. A clear winner. As others say I can get an entire box next day via Amazon (not that I like giving that short bald creep my money) but @45 bucks a box it’s not a money sink.
 
Red Sea blue bucket. Easier to get than TMPro and has lower alkalinity than most so no burnt tips on my sticks.
 
Red Sea Blue because it is the closest alk I can get locally to where I run my tank, although it is still a bit high. If I wanted to doctor salt I would probably just use IO. I wish IO would come out with a NSW level formula, something like 420/7/1300 would be nice.
 
IO on AWC = no alk spikes. I love standard IO.
 
There is no difference between salts IMO, besides parameters of course but that’s easily adjusted. I stick with the cheapest available , usually purple box or reef crystals
 
I have used IO and reef crystals with success, however TM pro is the best salt that I have used and still use it today. The parameters best match my reef target and it mixes really clean. BRS did a bunch of tests with most of the salt brands and generally TM pro was the best in almost every category. It is more expensive though and that could really matter in a large system.

Darren
 
Seems to be a pattern here.....

Most of us that have been in the hobby for a while, and maintain SPS dominate tanks(natural progression of the hobby), all have gone with cost being the biggest reason for the salt we choose.

With that said, I have always used regular old purple box IO. Easy to find in just about any LFS, and big box store, cheap, and very consistent batch to batch. The brown crud is easy to mitigate too. I run my water through an RO/DI sediment filter as I mix it. My barrels are just as grey as the day I bought them about 20 years ago.

Like @jda said in the other thread, I have used IO for so long, I have my recipe down to a science.

Fill up brute
add measured amount of salt
Check salinity a few hours later
Dump in 20ml of muriatic acid
Dump in a couple ML of Calcium chloride

Always right around 7ALK, 420 CAL, and 1500 MAG(IO has always had high mag. I'm ok with that as I never have to supplement MAG to my tank).
 
I believe IO is only available in the US which would explain why it’s not dominating this poll.
 
I believe IO is only available in the US which would explain why it’s not dominating this poll.
It's actually available worldwide, but overseas TM is a local salt. TM is actually cheaper then IO overseas. Seen many from over the pond that have posted that in the last few weeks.

Honestly if TM was more in line with IO as far as price goes, I might switch to it. Just for the simple fact it mixes up closer to my desired levels(less tinkering with the salt mix). The $100 price tag kills me though. I can buy 2 if not 3 boxes of IO for the price of one bucket of TM.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top