Chris at ReeferMadness sold it to me as that a few years back, but I tend to agree with you. As far as an IDing by species, I gave up on that game awhile back. I find there's too much variability among the species to know simply by examination of a colony.
I just got this deepwater on a trade nearly 3 weeks ago...it has colored up a good bit since then. Can anybody give me an ID on it? I am leaning toware A. suharsonoi...