I am using 100% man made dry rock in my tank. I started up the tank once in January this year and ended up tearing it down in April due to an uncontrollable infestation of dinos. In that tank, SPS were not dying (until much later on when they got smothered by the dinos) and exhibited good colouration and polyp extension, but I experienced the same issue that they were simply not encrusting.
After bleaching the entire system to get rid of dinos, I restarted the tank again in May and started to stock SPS at the end of May/start of June. By August, all my SPS had shown obvious encrustation and they were all doing well. 80% of my SPS were wild colonies, 20% were frags purchased from a local reefer. I did lose a few wild colonies, as is usual, but not a significant amount (and a large majority of those I lost were those purchased from an importer with a track record of most of his shipments ending up dead - his holding tanks are bad). The tank is now slightly over 5 months old and the SPS are thriving.
The differences between the 2 attempts this year:
1. Massive bottled bacteria dosing during the start up of the 2nd successful attempt, well beyond the recommended amounts on the bottles
2. Purchased the 44,000+ order of mixed copepods from Algaebarn and dosed them in early in the 2nd successful attempt
3. Added a refugium in the sump for the 2nd successful attempt - obtained macroalgae from established reefers
4. Switched dosing systems from Fauna Marin Zeolight system (1st attempt) to Tropic Marin Reef Actif system(2nd attempt), which includes weekly dosing of a product called "Reef Mud Vital" - which is supposed to be mud harvested from Fiji containing microbes and other organisms
I think that the proactive addition of various micro organisms from bacteria to copepods to whatever the reef mud includes made a difference in my case.