Starting new tank and need opinions

OceanDude

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
67
Reaction score
0
Location
Northern New York. NORTHERN New York. haha
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone. I am doing a new tank. Nano this time. I got out of the hobby last year due to some issues. I'm back now! Aha, anyway. I'm going to go over what I'm going to do to set it up and then you guys give me your opinion? I have dry rock. Lots of it. I'm using some of the porous pieces for this tank. Lighting will be a single PAR 38. The scape will be a single pillar in the center of the tank. The kind of... ''spotlight'' effect that will be given off by the par 38 will illuminate the center of the tank more than the corners. imo I think it will look cool. I have enough flow. A koralia powerhead will be used for main flow. However If it's not enough I will add an empty finter just for flow. I also have a prizm skimmer that I will use. Adding some more flow. I think that I'm mainly soft corals. A few lps. On the rocks there will be yellow polyps, zoa colonies, mushrooms, GSP, some palys, stuff like that. On the base of the rock and substrate I want some candy canes, rics, etc. Then for livestock. I'm just going to have a CUC. A few cerith, nass, margarita, etc. Then maybe some blue legged hermits. Then I want to add a yellow line anemone shrimp. :D I am going to use live sand for a substrate, starting the cycle.
 
There are many opinions on using live sand; I always start out with live sand. Maybe I've been lucky, but I always get lots of clams from it.

As far as getting a good cycle going to support fish bio load I wouldn't depend on it producing enough ammonia.
 
I know that everyone has different pinions on everything in reefing, I've been doing it for a few years. Got out of it in the summer for a break but I couldn't stay away. I want this tank to be the best. I heard from numerous people that once I get my first diatom bloom that I add a few snails? And then every week add some more snails until I either have enough snails or I have a complete cycle. However since I'm using dry rock, my cycle will obviously take longer because the rock needs to cure. So I really don't know what to do. I was just wondering if live sand would slowly add bacteria to sort of... assist the cycle.
 
Live Sand will help in seeding the rock yes, but in making for a quicker cycle, no. You'd be better off throwing a jumbo shrimp in a net, and laying the net in the tank water, this will get things rolling, and your ammonia will get up there. But after its finished cycling you will have a very healthy bacteria count for fish.
There are those that use bacteria in a bottle, thats supposed to kick start and virtually eliminate a cycle for you. There are a few out there that can attest to this product.
 
You said cure your rock, I'm assuming you meant cycle the tank and make your dry rock into live rock.

IMO, the live sand would only kick start the cycle but there will come a point at which an equilibrium is reached. Add more fish...that equilibrium gets unbalanced and would need to balance itself out again. This would happen until the system hits a point at which there's not enough area for beneficial bacteria to live and do their thing, thus creating an unbalanced system....I'm sure you know this but I'm explaining for those who may be reading and not know this. Now, there are two schools of thought with sand....and even more with dsb and so on...but I would say that it would start your cycle and you would need sand if you plan on having any sand dwellers...nasarius snails, gobies and certain anemones.

My opinion....you should leave your dry rock in the tank, add a raw shrimp that hasn't been sprayed with anything funky, a nice raw deli shrimp would do fine.....throw it in and let it do it's magic. It will take couple weeks or so but it will break down and start that cycle. No need to put any live critters in there to endure the high ammonia and nitrite that your tank will produce during this time period. Once your levels peak and come down then maybe add a small clean up crew and a fish. Feed those guys and continue down that road of stocking the tank. Just my two cents.
 
Live Sand will help in seeding the rock yes, but in making for a quicker cycle, no. You'd be better off throwing a jumbo shrimp in a net, and laying the net in the tank water, this will get things rolling, and your ammonia will get up there. But after its finished cycling you will have a very healthy bacteria count for fish.
There are those that use bacteria in a bottle, thats supposed to kick start and virtually eliminate a cycle for you. There are a few out there that can attest to this product.

You beat me! LOL
 
Okay, seeding is what I meant. Sorry, I'm not the best at explaining lol. So if I was to do the jumbo shrimp thing... would I not need live sand? I'm just curious as to what to do. Would live sand and shrimp be too much? I need to know the best way to do things so that this tank works out.
 
Live sand and a jumbo shrimp would not be to much. The bacteria will catch up. You do not need Live Sand if you do not want to use it.
 
Okay, it's just that there's so much contradicting information out there. Especially being a nano I didn't want to overkill. My friend tells me not to do live sand and a shrimp, or else I'll rush the cycle. Others say that it's okay. I'm just a tad bit confused. I used Dr. Tim's on my old tanks, and I guess it worked. But since I am not using a fish and want to do things right, might as well let nature do its thing, you know? This tank is mainly for coral. Only other stuff would be my CUC.
 
Sounds like an awesome tank!
Sand and shrimp sounds like a good method or sand and adding bacteria. Either way I think you will be fine.
Make sure to post pics when you get started.
I love the list of corals you picked.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top