STN base up…any suggestions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cflow
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Cflow

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 9, 2016
Messages
570
Reaction score
208
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a 47 gallon sps dominant tank. Recently I decided to try a higher than normal alk to boost growth. My PO4 and NO3 have been stable at 0.05 and ~5-10. The tank looks healthy. No signs of cyano or dinos for months. I feed pretty heavily including oyster and phytofeast a couple times a week and acropower daily. I use all for reef for element replacement. My fish are fat and healthy. I slowly raised my dkh from 8.5 to 10 over the course of about a month. I didn’t notice anything negative, but now some of the corals have slight stn at their bases. No corals have died. No burned tips. I kept using Red Sea blue bucket which has dkh of about 8 with weekly 4 gallon water changes. I’ve slowly let the dkh come down to about 9.5. Basically I did this to myself. Is there anything I can do to to help the corals out? Cut the base off?
Maybe another imbalance from use an all in on product for alk? Most colors still look great. In most corals it is just slight necrosis with retracted polyps. Also, I use ati sunpower, small fuge with sea lettuce on reverse light cycle, co2 scrubber (ph 7.8-8.3), and mp40 .
 
I recentaly had an alk OD issue that set off stn and burnt tips in my tank. I think overcorrecting the alk swing too fast did it. Once I got things stable I used the witch hazel stn treatment and it saved my corals that were not too far gone. The ones with burnt tips and base recession made it but the ones that had tissue falling off did not.

If you decide to try the treatment I recommend you keep a close eye on NO3, PO4, and PH as the witch hazel used has alcohol in it which tanked nutrients the first dose (i did the 1st day double dose) this was easily fixed the next morning by dosing NO3 and PO4. I also recommend going heavy on the biodigest, I have used all the brightwell and dr Tim’s bacteria and am convinced biodigest is the best option of bottled bacteria for getting things stable. I did the full seven days and am impressed with the results, it was very gentle on the tank and i saw polyp extension after the first day whitch I had not seen since my OD issue.

https://www.reefmoonshiners.com/witchhazel-reeftank-treatment

 
The witch hazel treatment appears to be for bacterial infections. Would that be beneficial for following an alk swing? The corals are more susceptible to infection after alk burn?
 
The witch hazel treatment appears to be for bacterial infections. Would that be beneficial for following an alk swing? The corals are more susceptible to infection after alk burn?
So the theory is the alk swing or other similar swings weaken the coral and make it prone to infection which leads to stn/rtn. The witch hazel slows down the growth of bacteria or disease giving the coral more time to heal. Hence the importance of adding a bunch of good bacteria during treatment.
 
Got it. I’ll try a dip first since only a few corals are affected. Seems like the tank treatment requires an ati ICP and prodibio. That would put me several weeks out for test results. Maybe longer with covid and holidays. I happen to have that brand of witch hazel on hand already. Thanks for the info. Wish I would have known this sooner.
 
Got it. I’ll try a dip first since only a few corals are affected. Seems like the tank treatment requires an ati ICP and prodibio. That would put me several weeks out for test results. Maybe longer with covid and holidays. I happen to have that brand of witch hazel on hand already. Thanks for the info. Wish I would have known this sooner.
I think the ICP test is to make sure you have fixed any out of wack parameters that initially caused a problem, and the biodigest is to keep the good bacteria population up while you stall all the bacteria growth with witch hazel. So potentially you could do it without the ICP. The biodigest is available on amazon one-day (at least in Florida).

But since its just a few the dip sounds helpful, I just haven't tried the dip.

I hope you have the same experience I had. Good Luck!
 
I dipped one so far. I’m assuming I shouldn’t dose acro power it case it might be fueling pathogenic bacteria.
 
I dipped one so far. I’m assuming I shouldn’t dose acro power it case it might be fueling pathogenic bacteria.
I would not, from my understanding amino acids aren’t really helpful when things aren’t going well anyways and are not necessity to begin with. So a long break from them isn’t a big deal.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top