Stocking Ideas: Battle with My Fiance....

  • Thread starter Thread starter b_mac16
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

b_mac16

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 13, 2017
Messages
15
Reaction score
4
Location
Wyoming
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So my fiancé and I got into the hobby by accident. I have learned so much along the way about what to do and a lot of what NOT to do. Throughout this journey, however, I have developed a fascination and addiction to maintaining my 40g breeder and she sees me spending money like it's going out of style. She enjoys the fish and likes to feed our clowns by hand but other than that it has become my sole project.

Our current short stocking list for our40 g breeeder FOWLR tank is:
1 black/white misbar ocellaris
1 snowflake ocellaris
1 6 line wrasse
1 fire fish goby
4 very large thin tripe hermit crabs (from the coast of Florida brought to Wyoming by accident and the reason I have been thrown into the hobby)

I am currently Running a Fluval Tidal 75 power filter, Aqueon Quietflow 30, and a Aqueon Quietflow internal submersible filter, about 50 lbs of live rock, 40lbs of live sand and plenty of filter media.

I have added these 4 fish over the course of the last month and a half and have not had a spike in ammonia or nitrites. I currently have readings of 0 ammonia, 0 nitrite, 10 nitrate, salinity 1.025.

I am battling the fiancé because I would like to add more to the tank. She says we don't need any more fish but I would like to add more if possible. The only thing I can find that would be able to co-inhabit the tank with what is already in there is blue/green chromis or a royal gamma...

My concerns/questions would be what else would be available to stock my tank with that would be safe for all the other tankmates and roughly how many more additions could I make before I were to overload the bio filter? Also, I would like some ideas on a CUC that my large crabs wouldn't kill/eat or vice versa. I don't have the current means of adding a sump or anything like that... what I have is all that I can stick with until we move to a place where I have a better spot to place a larger tank. Any thoughts or concerns would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you!
 
With the size of your tank and your current stocking list I think you could easily add 1-3 more fish, depending on what size. I think I'd go for a Flame Hawk and call it a day (I know that wasn't on your list, I just love the fish). Also don't worry about the crabs, just make sure they've got food and algae to munch on and they won't hurt your CUC. How long has the tank been up and running? Also do you have any powerheads in the tank? Lastly, don't worry about not having a sump. Check out MASS Aquariums on YouTube, he's got a 40 breeder that's been up for a couple years with just a HOB filter.
 
I think some small gobies, like the Red Headed goby would be ideal. Lots of options I would think.

Tagging along.
 
Love my Gramma. Just got one and my wife loves it. Took him a couple days to get comfortable with my clowns but he has an awesome personality. Cave hopper.
 
I didn't have a specific list that I wanted persay. Just options that would work with what I have and the flame hawkfish is rather striking. Nice suggestion! The tank has been up and running for about 6 months. The crabs lived through the cycle, and 6 days in a seashell bag inside a suitcase... The ocellaris have been in for almost 2 months with the 6 line and firefish goby for about 3 weeks. I do not have a powerhead. The fluval provides a decent current and the submersible aqueon has a steady output as well. Not powerhead worthy strength but enough to where the flow causes frozen mysis to spread and swirl like snowflakes while the fish gobble em' up. Also, thanks for the YouTube channel suggestion. Headed there after I hit "post" to learn some more. Your help was much appreciated, especially about the CUC, I was worried they would kill off the small CUC members for sport lol.
 
IMG_1767.JPG Would they get along fine with my current firefish goby? I may have received some bad advice at my LFS. She said I should keep just the one goby or they could harass one another to death for territory.
 
Love my Gramma. Just got one and my wife loves it. Took him a couple days to get comfortable with my clowns but he has an awesome personality. Cave hopper.


They are definitely neat to look at. My clowns hover up top of the tank so if the gramma stays near the caves I think they'd all do fine. Thanks for the suggestion!
 
IMG_1767.JPG Would they get along fine with my current firefish goby? I may have received some bad advice at my LFS. She said I should keep just the one goby or they could harass one another to death for territory.
Every time I've started off with several firefish I end up with one; yes, the dominant one will eventually make life miserable for the others. Royal gramma, flame or long nosed hawkfish, watchman or yellow/green clown gobies would be good choices imho.
 
Every time I've started off with several firefish I end up with one; yes, the dominant one will eventually make life miserable for the others. Royal gramma, flame or long nosed hawkfish, watchman or yellow/green clown gobies would be good choices imho.

OK awesome. Great to know! The hawkfish are something I haven't really seen all that much and I'm intrigued now. I saw a yellow clown goby at the LFS the other day. May go that route as well. Thank you!
 
Based on your recommendations I think I may go with a yellow/green clown goby and a fire hawkfish. The fiancé like those the best and anything I can do to keep her enthusiasm with this hobby I may go with that. if the tank remains stable ill add a royal gramma and call it good. Thank you all for your help. Much appreciated.
 
Based on your recommendations I think I may go with a yellow/green clown goby and a fire hawkfish. The fiancé like those the best and anything I can do to keep her enthusiasm with this hobby I may go with that. if the tank remains stable ill add a royal gramma and call it good. Thank you all for your help. Much appreciated.
Good choices, and as old married folks know, "Happy wife, happy life." Just don't tell your fiancé about this males-only secret, lol.
 
Good choices, and as old married folks know, "Happy wife, happy life." Just don't tell your fiancé about this males-only secret, lol.

LOL, we have one month to go before we tie the knot but that secret has been crucial throughout the engagement as well, fiancé just doesn't rhyme well haha.
 
LOL, we have one month to go before we tie the knot but that secret has been crucial throughout the engagement as well, fiancé just doesn't rhyme well haha.
Sounds like you'll have many years of happiness; early congratulations
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top