Suggestions for better hard coral success

  • Thread starter Thread starter jtf74
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

jtf74

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
May 20, 2020
Messages
747
Reaction score
572
Location
Washougal,WA
What state or country do you live in
Washington
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have pretty much operated as fish only with a few anemones and soft corals with not too much trouble. Haven't had much luck though with anything else I think mostly because I haven't had very good lights. I just bought a 180 gallon that comes with much better lights so wanting to try some euphyllia again and maybe some acros. I know I need to lower my phosphates, but wondering what else I can do to have better success? I do not dose anything. My ph is perfect 8.3 from my water source and alk has been good, ph is always stable. I operate with a sump, skimmer, good flow, and a refugium. Calcium has been on the low end and magnesium fair. What would be some things to do first that will make the most difference other than the lights? Was thinking kalk drip or reactor might be a good start.
 
Stability.
Agree with this. Also If you want to keep LPS or SPS you'll need to dose calcium, alkalinity and occasionally trace elements. Also I wouldn't start with euphyllia or acros, maybe try duncans, blastos and favias
 
Not sure what is lacking there. My tank has been running for 10 years. I don't have any wild swings so I would consider that stable. Maybe not ideal but stable.
Thats a start once stable lights and flow come into play along with live stock. What's your fish list that may have something to do with you not being able to keep stony corals
 
I have pretty much operated as fish only with a few anemones and soft corals with not too much trouble. Haven't had much luck though with anything else I think mostly because I haven't had very good lights. I just bought a 180 gallon that comes with much better lights so wanting to try some euphyllia again and maybe some acros. I know I need to lower my phosphates, but wondering what else I can do to have better success? I do not dose anything. My ph is perfect 8.3 from my water source and alk has been good, ph is always stable. I operate with a sump, skimmer, good flow, and a refugium. Calcium has been on the low end and magnesium fair. What would be some things to do first that will make the most difference other than the lights? Was thinking kalk drip or reactor might be a good start.
Best I tell others is to take time to get the tank set and stabilized and use good quality salts and test kits and dont worry about fluctuations with numbers and then battle to get them to a certain level.
If changing water regularly, no need to add chemicals to attempt to stabilize the tank.
 
Agree with this. Also If you want to keep LPS or SPS you'll need to dose calcium, alkalinity and occasionally trace elements. Also I wouldn't start with euphyllia or acros, maybe try duncans, blastos and favias
I have drip dosed kalkwasser years ago. Wondering if a calcium reactor is a better?
 
I guess what I'm wondering is what do people consider essential to dose? I have stability. Also I look under other tanks online and see all kinds of equipment and I have no idea what half of it is or is it really necessary. I am getting a uv sterilizer w/ the new setup but wondering what else may be of benefit
Thats a start once stable lights and flow come into play along with live stock. What's your fish list that may have something to do with you not being able to keep stony corals
I have dwarf angels, copperband, yellow longnose, hippo tang, gramma, maroon clown pair, couple damsels. Never seen the angels or butterflies pick at anything although I didn't have the longnose when I tried frogspawn and hammers.
 
I guess what I'm wondering is what do people consider essential to dose? I have stability. Also I look under other tanks online and see all kinds of equipment and I have no idea what half of it is or is it really necessary. I am getting a uv sterilizer w/ the new setup.

I have dwarf angels, copperband, yellow longnose, hippo tang, gramma, maroon clown pair, couple damsels. Never seen the angels or butterflies pick at anything although I didn't have the longnose when I tried frogspawn and hammers.
Dawn angels long nose and thr copper band may be the issue.
 
Dawn angels long nose and thr copper band may be the issue.
well i know my lights were an issue for one . cheap black box led. The fish are well fed don't touch my zoas. Any hammer, frogspawn seems to do ok then all of a sudden sheds its tissue and gone completely in a few days.
 
I guess what I'm wondering is what do people consider essential to dose? I have stability. Also I look under other tanks online and see all kinds of equipment and I have no idea what half of it is or is it really necessary. I am getting a uv sterilizer w/ the new setup but wondering what else may be of benefit

I have dwarf angels, copperband, yellow longnose, hippo tang, gramma, maroon clown pair, couple damsels. Never seen the angels or butterflies pick at anything although I didn't have the longnose when I tried frogspawn and hammers.
Well first off, your look down style tank is super awesome. I love it.

Second, most of this stuff you see in peoples tanks is merely to modernize and automate things which can be done manually. Dosing calcium, alk and magnesium seems to be the ones that are most often being recommended.

A ton of it is monitors and testing equipment that keeps you from using your manual test kits. But you can even go so far as getting controllers that let you monitor and control lights and dosing quantities from your phone even if you are away.

Filter rollers just replace filter socks. Reactors for various chemicals just keep you from using the little mesh baggies.(and allow you to tune them for the specific media you are using). Algae scrubbers replace refugiums.

Anyways, all that being said, you should post your tanks parameters so people can better understand how to guide you where you want to go.

I would recommend posting a photo of your tank as well to make people see that this is not a brand new system you are looking to add corals too. That happens a lot here so people assume. I’d edit it into your first post.

Personally, I feel as though stronger lighting and flow, as recommended earlier, would definitely be the starting point. That is assuming your water parameters are solid for lps or sps. But take my opinion with a grain of salt because you are many years deeper into the hobby than I am.

You don’t need to start dosing the tank right away unless your tanks elements are low to start with. If so, you can start dosing, slowly. Slowly increasing until tank is back to basics and then keep it there as you add corals. You will then need to increase again, based on how many corals and how fast they grow.

An icp test will tell you a lot though there is much discussion regarding their accuracy.
 
Well first off, your look down style tank is super awesome. I love it.

Second, most of this stuff you see in peoples tanks is merely to modernize and automate things which can be done manually. Dosing calcium, alk and magnesium seems to be the ones that are most often being recommended.

A ton of it is monitors and testing equipment that keeps you from using your manual test kits. But you can even go so far as getting controllers that let you monitor and control lights and dosing quantities from your phone even if you are away.

Filter rollers just replace filter socks. Reactors for various chemicals just keep you from using the little mesh baggies.(and allow you to tune them for the specific media you are using). Algae scrubbers replace refugiums.

Anyways, all that being said, you should post your tanks parameters so people can better understand how to guide you where you want to go.

I would recommend posting a photo of your tank as well to make people see that this is not a brand new system you are looking to add corals too. That happens a lot here so people assume. I’d edit it into your first post.

Personally, I feel as though stronger lighting and flow, as recommended earlier, would definitely be the starting point. That is assuming your water parameters are solid for lps or sps. But take my opinion with a grain of salt because you are many years deeper into the hobby than I am.

You don’t need to start dosing the tank right away unless your tanks elements are low to start with. If so, you can start dosing, slowly. Slowly increasing until tank is back to basics and then keep it there as you add corals. You will then need to increase again, based on how many corals and how fast they grow.

An icp test will tell you a lot though there is much discussion regarding their accuracy.
Thanks. Alas, my lookdown is no more. I had to remove everything because of ich and somehow got a hole in the liner. It lasted for several years though. I just bought a 180 gallon acrylic to replace it. The lookdown was supposed to be temporary but I liked it so much I kept it. The fish also seem more content in there exploring everywhere instead of back and forth glass surfing. I will post up parameters when the acrylic is up and running as right now all my fish are in QT and the liverock is running fallow dispersed into a couple tanks. For some reason there is no edit icon on my first post.
 
No worries, I think I was misunderstanding anyways. I thought that was the tank you were running now.

I do love the idea of the look down. And like it even more if it makes the fish act more naturally. I’ve seen some commercial ones in the past that have windowed edge but it would not be as reflective glass. But I figured the wife would hate me if she walked into the garage and saw a 12x8 fish tank.

But the rest still hold true. You can keep doing things manually, or look at some cool new toys to automate the parts you dislike.

Also stability and patience is key, like they said. Corals are adaptive so just don’t make constant changes and instead change things slowly over time and give them the things they need and they will likely grow. Still working on following this advice myself haha. Resist urge to tinker…

Edit: Also, the edit button is on the bottom left of any post. Next to the report icon, there should be 3 dots with a small down arrow. Click it, and it should show the edit option.
 
Not sure what is lacking there. My tank has been running for 10 years. I don't have any wild swings so I would consider that stable. Maybe not ideal but stable.
I'm confused, twice you said you just bought a new tank and when told stability you say your tank has been running 10 years.
 
No worries, I think I was misunderstanding anyways. I thought that was the tank you were running now.

I do love the idea of the look down. And like it even more if it makes the fish act more naturally. I’ve seen some commercial ones in the past that have windowed edge but it would not be as reflective glass. But I figured the wife would hate me if she walked into the garage and saw a 12x8 fish tank.

But the rest still hold true. You can keep doing things manually, or look at some cool new toys to automate the parts you dislike.

Also stability and patience is key, like they said. Corals are adaptive so just don’t make constant changes and instead change things slowly over time and give them the things they need and they will likely grow. Still working on following this advice myself haha. Resist urge to tinker…

Edit: Also, the edit button is on the bottom left of any post. Next to the report icon, there should be 3 dots with a small down arrow. Click it, and it should show the edit option.
Thanks I use edit often but I only have the option on my latest post. It was a cheap way to build a very large system for sure, I should have used thicker liner in hindsight or doubled up. I've considered a porcelain tiled with epoxy grout wall but not sure how the epoxy effects fish without doing some research.
I'm confused, twice you said you just bought a new tank and when told stability you say your tank has been running 10 years.
Sorry I should have added more originally I guess. I have a tank that was running for 10 years - 280 gallons look down style. Soft corals doing great. Several fish no problems. No luck with hard corals. That tank was leaking and its contents are spread out into 4 smaller tanks at the moment. I have a 180 coming with much better lighting to replace the leaker. I will be putting all my liverock, corals, fish into the 180 after it has cycled. I want to up my game now that I have better lighting in the new 180.
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top