I gave the two most notable LFS multiple tries and I'm sad to say that I highly distrust their livestock. One store seems to always have very sick fish and frags that are covered in god knows what. The other store has given me false info, mislabeled stock, and has even overcharged me before. They're also not very affordable, due to the nature of the area I live in. Needless to say, I get corals from individuals rather than local fish stores and for fish... I guess I'm going to have to depend on online orders for that too.
It's a shame, my LFS from where I used to live was great. They had great livestock, nice selection, excellent price, they knew me very well and we've even exchanged personal numbers. I believe in supporting local fish stores, but only if they meet a certain standard of quality.