Tank Crashing--Need help reefers!!!!

CubanPete

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
242
Reaction score
2
Location
Miami, Fl
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
OK, so let me start with some history...

I have a 72 gallon bowfront alive with LPS...acans, three torches, 5 wall hammers, two branching hammers, three octospawn, two frogspawn, brain, welso, huge grape coral, smaller three headed grape, three separate duncans, feather duster and about 10 fish. Decent clean up crew. I switched to LEDs from T5s about 6 weeks ago. I didn't know what a huge difference they were. I started them with 2 hours blue, 5 white, then 2 blue after. I noticed a wall hammer receding as well as a torch. Did more research and found out I didn't acclimate well enough. I raised the lights to 12" above the water (approx 26" to bottom from top). Cut the lights to 4 hours of blue only, and ran that for four weeks. Increased to 6 hours a couple of weeks ago. Due to the light issue, I lost a few LPS.

After I thought the light stabilized out, and the tank looked good, I purchased two new wall hammers. One has since died, as has a huge wall hammer that was pretty much my show piece. I've also lost the branching hammer and a couple acans seem to be receding. My params all seem to be pretty good...

Salinity 1.026-7
Trate/trite 0
Amonia 0
PH was 7.8...working on buffering to 8.2
Calcium 420-460

I'm at a loss. I don't know what to do, and it feels like I'm losing a piece a week. Right now, a golden torch isn't opening all the way, and even though skeleton isn't showing, I am afraid of losing it...

Anyone have any ideas? Everything else is doing awesome. The LPS that was dying had the brown jelly. Super sad and need some help...

Pete

Oh...been dosing a little bit of iodine and melafix...been doing that for the last 7 days or so...
 
Last edited:
Sorry to hear that Pete,

Hopefully someone else with experience with brown jelly can chime in. All that I know is that is some nasty stuff and best thing to do is to dip with medication.
 
Thanks. Forgot to say that I dipped both hammers and still lost em. Someone told me to dip everything, but that's not really practical. I have a lot of stuff and its mostly all glued to rock work. If I have to, I will obviously, but I'm hoping some other options are out there.
 
When you say ph are you actually testing ph or dKH?? Because if its ph I'm gonna gues your dKH is through the roof. Been there done that.

Also I lost Lps when my mag was way low. You should be testing dKH, magnesium, and calcium as your big three alon with salinity.


-Alex-
 
Don't know what dkh is. I'm doing the standard lfs ph test. I have the drops at home to test, so I am going to assume not. I guess I'll be picking up mag and dkh this week.
 
ALK is the MOST important think to keep stable in your system...let us know what it is and I wouldn't let your salinity go to 1.027...shoot for .25-6.
 
Will do. I dose it once a week, capful in conjunction with calc twice a week. I don't test though, for alk, guess I need to. Thanks all, I'll update as soon as I see what it is at.
 
I'll chime in here even though you called me a communist one time.

I agree with the above posts about the alk. It is absolutely the most important parameter after your tank has cycled. If you are dosing to increase pH your alk is likely through the roof. It's known as "chasing pH". I would also stop dosing the iodine and melafix. Do some large water changes and don't add or dose anything until it is needed.
 
I'll chime in here even though you called me a communist one time.

I agree with the above posts about the alk. It is absolutely the most important parameter after your tank has cycled. If you are dosing to increase pH your alk is likely through the roof. It's known as "chasing pH". I would also stop dosing the iodine and melafix. Do some large water changes and don't add or dose anything until it is needed.

A communist? Lol. Hmmmm.

As far as alk, why didn't I know this?!? Lol. If this is the problem, I'm gonna hit myself seeing as how this is one if the most basic tests. Ugh!
 
If you're adding 2 part Calcium and Alkalinity and aren't testing for alkalinity, then yes this is a problem. You don't have to dose Alk everytime you dose Cal. Just curious, are you using Reef Code A & B?
 
It's a two bottle system. It says calc twice, and alk once a week, yet the bottles are the same size...smh
 
Few things from my side.Your Lighting is not an issue. It should be Water chemistry or predator. In these situations, drop all dosing and do series of water changes. What is your livestock...
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top