What I would be doing is checking what temperature outside is and inside where tank is.as see you in florida so alot higher temps than me in sunny England lol.
Checking heater not stuck on.
Checking temperature with a second device to verify heat is 89 degrees.
If heat is still far to hot,what I had to do when England had heatwave other month is keep putting 2-3 frozen pop bottles in the sump and changing every few hours.
Also I shut my windows and curtains/blinds to keep the hot air outside.
Having fans blow across top off water like you doing is good way to aid in evaporation cooling,as is making more surface agitation if possible so aids in evaporation cooling.
Ovbiously having a chiller in higher temperature countries/areas is probably best idea either a branded one or a DIY one you make your self with tubing and a mini fridge and drill holes in sides off fridge, ( lots off yourube videos showing you how)
Also lights can raise temperature off water so whilst tank water is to hot,we can turn down lights or duration,if glass or plastic lids on tank ,we can remove them so heat doesn't get trapped in them,having a mesh lid would help help in stopping fish from jumping .
Good luck