Tap Water - What's the big deal??

  • Thread starter Thread starter JCOLE
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Just because this came up in a Facebook thread on Iowa freshwater keepers, the tap reading has been roughly 80ppm nitrate - they called the water works since the levels are 8x the epa limit and were told the WW was aware of the issue and didn’t know how long it would continue.

Not sure how they get by without a warning.
 
Couldn't there be a variety of detrimental compounds to our aquatic life that come through the tap? They don't seem to test all that many things. Our treatment plants add lime to "burn off some organics" but isn't it reasonable some organcis make it past along with other various agriculture compounds?

There could certainly be, and RO/Di will always be a good choice, but copper is a specific issue where it is a lot worse for reefs than for people. Many other chemicals are similarly bad for both, so the US EPA keeps them pretty low.
 
Copper. [emoji3]
That's what I hear also.

Far be it from me to advise.

(So these are just some thoughts)

It does seem to me that if one does not do water changes and only tops off, in a tank balanced and stabilized with algae, the phosphates and nitrates would be no problem.

Plus the algae would bio-accumulate the much lower levels of copper and other nasties.

By using tap from a frequently used cold faucet and letting the water run 30 seconds or so before collecting, you also lower the copper, iron and other gunk in the hot water heater. Plus the cold water pipes may be pvc not copper as well.

So the effects of those things could be reduced. Whether or not reduced sufficiently is another question.

But then back in the day (before ro water) there used to be guidance that one should run a tank for months before adding corals. Perhaps that was to reduce copper and stuff.

my .02
 
Our phosphates can be several PPM depending on time of year. My 100g evaporates between 3-5g/day, that is what, 0.05ppm extra phosphate added a day at 1ppm which it can be higher depending on year. That is a lot of extra phosphate to remove via whatever chosen method.

One lake near by that empties into the river for tap collection (according to DNR) total phosphorus is 231 ug/l and the highest value they observed for that water was 615 ug/l. It gets gross at the end of summer from the cyano and they have to close the lakes around here.
 
Tap water containing copper from plumbing? Or containing other metals and silica? Normally tap water contains a lot of calcium. This is to prevent the water will be contaminated by the plumbing ( copper and lead soldering) , pipelines, and visa versa.

In Germany and other European country's DiakatB is used to remove phosphate. It is an iron based absorber. It removes besides phosphate and silicate also metals as copper and lead. https://www.reefanalytics.com/dokumente/Datenblatt DIAKAT B englisch.pdf.

Our tap water contains 0.23ppm phosphate! Using one litre diakatB a minimum of 5000 litre of this tap water can be cleaned. This may go up depending of the other contaminants. If silicate free water this may go up till 40000 l. All this for less than 10$ ( 6€). No good drinking water is wasted!

There must be similar products on the market in the US !?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I used tap for 3 years prior to getting coral. Didnt test my tap, because the basic LEDs never even grew algae.

Upgraded my lights to grow coral and had an algae and cyano explosion due to high phosphates. Higher then my test could read. Have been using RO water with weekly water changes since early December and still have .3 to .4 phosphate.

Spent about 2 months picking algae out by hand and siphoning algae and cyano off my sand bed, using phosguard and nopox for a few weeks...

So my stance is, just use RO and save yourself the hassle... a lot changes in 8 years.
 
The real question is: why use DI? RO rejection rates are dependent on the size and charge of the ions. Nutrients like phosphate and nitrate are relatively large and are likely rejected at rates higher than the nominal rejection rate of the membrane. The relatively high redox potential of tap water generally keeps heavy metals in a multivalent state, so again the rejection rates will be greater than the nominal values (in addition to the removal afforded by the carbon prefilters).
 
Pipe scum is certainly a helpful insulator between pipe wall and water contaminants. Paul shows some posts in his threads of home pipes reduced flow to 10% original with scums taking up most of the space in pipes. Biocontamination becomes a fair risk to consider depending on location and variables, neat fact of tap use in aquaria...ironic bc tap is always seen as a sterilizer from aquarists point of view. It's a vector, due to pipe scum in everyone's home.

These don't have to be drain pipes either, inflows can build up easily especially in any setting or region like Harts where plant effluent has some colony forming units and then those travel and are housed in the scums leading all the way until output at the tap, even where full on hot water flows.



Homes absolutely cannot sterilize their pipes with heat via water heater, the insulation is too good afforded by bioslicks, earned by millennia of adaptation. If anything, occasional hot water probably -feeds- the bioslicks and allows them to build mass by killing topical bacteria and organisms but the unremoved slicks lock their masses in place, localized degradation always turns into bac feed, lower protected life is fed by the death of the outermost layer. Then some drano cuts most of it out, but never all of the scum, and pipe sclerosis is staved off again for a while.



The deposits from hard water years plus residing aerobes of various strains including nitrifiers in many cases increase the surface area within the pipes, and surface area was pretty much all bacteria and scum needs to set up shop. They get the rest of what they need if we will just provide some real estate, in my opinion all very neat characters of tap water.

Tap's most ironic character is the bacteria it pumps out into every lemonade we will make. What comes out of your pipes/grody seed water. That's why I'll wash filters and live sand with it, endlessly supply and poor sterilizer given working time frames.
 
Last edited:
Pipe scum is certainly a helpful insulator between pipe wall and water contaminants. Paul shows some posts in his threads of home pipes reduced flow to 10% original with scums taking up most of the space in pipes. Biocontamination becomes a fair risk to consider depending on location and variables, neat fact of tap use in aquaria...ironic bc tap is always seen as a sterilizer from aquarists point of view. It's a vector, due to pipe scum in everyone's home.

These don't have to be drain pipes either, inflows can build up easily especially in any setting or region like Harts where plant effluent has some colony forming units and then those travel and are housed in the scums leading all the way until output at the tap, even where full on hot water flows.



Homes absolutely cannot sterilize their pipes with heat via water heater, the insulation is too good afforded by bioslicks, earned by millennia of adaptation. If anything, occasional hot water probably -feeds- the bioslicks and allows them to build mass by killing topical bacteria and organisms but the unremoved slicks lock their masses in place, localized degradation always turns into bac feed, lower protected life is fed by the death of the outermost layer. Then some drano cuts most of it out, but never all of the scum, and pipe sclerosis is staved off again for a while.



The deposits from hard water years plus residing aerobes of various strains including nitrifiers in many cases increase the surface area within the pipes, and surface area was pretty much all bacteria and scum needs to set up shop. They get the rest of what they need if we will just provide some real estate, in my opinion all very neat characters of tap water.

Tap's most ironic character is the bacteria it pumps out into every lemonade we will make. What comes out of your pipes/grody seed water. That's why I'll wash filters and live sand with it, endlessly supply and poor sterilizer given working time frames.
This makes we want to put a whole house system for not just my tank but my family as well....that's nasty
 
Almost ll home plumbing goes through copper pipes. Even if your tapwater doesnt have detectable Cu (most tapwater does, from what I've read), it has more than zero copper. Over time, this will build up. Copper is horribly toxic.

I am a cheapskate and an obsessive DIYer but I cant see any good arguments for using tapwater.

Older homes would be copper or galvo, these days youre far more likely to see PVC piping which shouldnt be any issue.
 
The real question is: why use DI? RO rejection rates are dependent on the size and charge of the ions. Nutrients like phosphate and nitrate are relatively large and are likely rejected at rates higher than the nominal rejection rate of the membrane. The relatively high redox potential of tap water generally keeps heavy metals in a multivalent state, so again the rejection rates will be greater than the nominal values (in addition to the removal afforded by the carbon prefilters).

I agree that RO alone is much better than nothing in most cases. One issue with RO alone is that both ammonia and silicate get through the RO fairly readily. And I think that the low flow will allow substantial copper to dissolve (relative to a fast flowing tap water). Thus even if you have 97% rejection of copper, if it starts above 1 ppm, it may still be substantial in the effluent.
 
Last edited:
I agree that RO alone is much better than nothing in most cases. One issue with RO alone is that both ammonia and silicate get through the RO fairly readily. And I think that the low flow will allow substantial copper to dissolve (relative to a fast flowing tap water). Thus even if you have 97% rejection of copper, if it starts above 1 ppm, it may still be substantial in the effluent.

I think the issues with both ammonia and silica are often overstated. At pH7, ~0.5% of ammonia/ammonium exists as ammonia that will readily permeate. The rejection rate for ammonium is still pretty reasonable. For a TFC membrane, the silicate rejection rate is generally >92%.

Copper levels are also generally nowhere near the MCL. I used to work in a lab performing AA on municipal waters and never encountered a sample that exceeded (or got close to) the MCL. I would suspect some sort of electrochemistry going on within the pipes of a particular household if copper was approaching the MCL.

Unless there are specific known issues with the tap water, most people are paying for DI to mostly removed Na+ and Cl- which are them immediately added back when making up the saltwater.
 
I think the issues with both ammonia and silica are often overstated. At pH7, ~0.5% of ammonia/ammonium exists as ammonia that will readily permeate. The rejection rate for ammonium is still pretty reasonable. For a TFC membrane, the silicate rejection rate is generally >92%.

Copper levels are also generally nowhere near the MCL. I used to work in a lab performing AA on municipal waters and never encountered a sample that exceeded (or got close to) the MCL. I would suspect some sort of electrochemistry going on within the pipes of a particular household if copper was approaching the MCL.

Unless there are specific known issues with the tap water, most people are paying for DI to mostly removed Na+ and Cl- which are them immediately added back when making up the saltwater.

I have life insurance, but I think it pretty unlikely that I will die in the next 12 months. Everyone should decide for themselves their risk tolerance. :)

Why assume a pH of 7? My tap water runs in at well above 9.

Also, I know ammonia is getting through the RO because once I accidentally let the Di deplete, and my limewater stank of ammonia.

I agree that copper is usually not near 1.3 ppm. Often it is substantial. How much is too much?

Silicate rejection is generally higher than for silica/silicic acid (the dominate form at pH below 9.8), which can be below 90.

http://www.purewaterproducts.com/articles/ro-rejection-rates
 
I have life insurance, but I think it pretty unlikely that I will die in the next 12 months. Everyone should decide for themselves their risk tolerance. :)

Why assume a pH of 7? My tap water runs in at well above 9.

Also, I know ammonia is getting through the RO because once I accidentally let the Di deplete, and my limewater stank of ammonia.

I agree that copper is usually not near 1.3 ppm. Often it is substantial. How much is too much?

Silicate rejection is generally higher than for silica/silicic acid (the dominate form at pH below 9.8), which can be below 90.

http://www.purewaterproducts.com/articles/ro-rejection-rates

I count chloramines and a pH of 9 as "a specific known issue" with the tap water. Obviously, not everyone can safely forgo using DI resins, but the vast majority of people probably can.

Seawater contains about 90 ppb copper. My most recent water report indicates 77 ppb in my tap. After RO, the copper is negligible compared to natural levels.
 
Last edited:
I count chloramines and a pH of 9 as "a specific known issue" with the tap water. Obviously, not everyone can safely forgo using DI resins, but the vast majority of people probably can.

Seawater contains about 90 ppb copper. My most recent water report indicates 77 ppb in my tap. After RO, the copper is negligible compared to natural levels.

I have often said that ro only is probably adequate for many people. The issue is knowing if you are one of them or not. [emoji3]
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top