• Thank you for visiting the R2R Marketplace! Please consider becoming a Supporting Member today! In addition to all the perks of becoming a supporting member, this notice will also be automatically removed! Click here for more details and Happy Reefing!

The "Paying For a Wreck" Chalice Sale

BrooksReef

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 15, 2010
Messages
469
Reaction score
6
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi all.

Recently I was selling some frags of Purple Urkle to help pay for a wreck I was recently in. Unfortunately the damage is worse than anticipated, and much more costly. :choler:

I'm going to be selling the following colonies:

OME - 8 eyes - $200+shipping

Purple Urkle - 16-18 eyes - $400+shipping

Bazooka Joe WM - 3 eyes - $120+shipping

Frag Farmer WM - 9 eyes - $130+shipping


Pictures (in same order as above):

OME:
6100d356.jpg



**PURPLE URKLE PICTURE IS NOT WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE NOW. IT IS ESSENTIALLY JUST THE ROUNDED PART. CAN SEND MORE PICTURES UPON REQUEST***
e1204423.jpg


Bazooka Joe: Picture to come


FF WM:
05e6216a.jpg
 
Both Watermelon's pending payment.

Purple Urkle and OME still available.
 
Have not received payment for the WM's yet.

They are still up for sale.
 
Got my Purple Urkle frags in this morning.

Good size, great price. I hope it heals and colors up.


Under MH
2-1.jpg

3-1.jpg
 
I kind of remember an ID thread where you werent sure what a chalice was and now it's being sold as the purple urkle because the lady you bought it from thinks thats what she bought it as on eBay ? Same pics and everything. Lineage doesn't seem solid on that piece sorry.https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/lps-id-forum/80864-anyone-know-chalice.html

Thanks for the info Billy.


Brooks, if you weren't sure whether your Purple Urkle is the real one, selling it as a Purple Urkle is Dishonest. I question the lineage to your other watermelon chalices.
 
Cuong,

The woman who sold it to me told me she bought it as a Purple Urkle chalice. Just because it was sold on eBay, does not make it a fake. I'm sorry to hear that you're doubting the lineage of my other chalices as well. Though, it isn't your place to do so.

I have not, by any means, attempted to sell something as a "fake." If the information I collected from the seller was incorrect, I do apologize. If it looks exactly like the "real" thing in my tank, I'm leaning towards it being the "real" thing.

If you care to take this further, please feel free to message me again.

I'd ask that a Moderator please close this thread.
 
https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/lps-id-forum/80864-anyone-know-chalice-2.html

This is what you wrote in your post month and a half ago, "this frag was purchased (according to the seller) almost 2 years ago I believe? Might be the same one, maybe not!
Whatever it is or isn't, I'm enjoying it in the tank! Its quite the display piece!


That tells me you are not sure it's the real Purple Urkle. Also there were many post on the same thread stating that it doesn't seem like the real Purple Urkle. With all that info, you still decided to sell it as the Purple Urkle just because it looks like it. I'm not saying its not a nice Chalice, but this is not a Purple Urkle and you should not sell it as such.
 
Brooks I bought this from you as a purple urkle. Its pretty clear that you knew there was a good chance it wasn't and many people advised you not to sell it as such. Its pretty disappointing you would do this.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top