The stocking plan. Your downfall.

Scott Fellman

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 1, 2016
Messages
395
Reaction score
710
Location
Los Angeles, CA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Did you develop a "stocking plan" for your most recent reef?

I think we have lofty plans to stock our new reef exactly how we want. We get really excited, start adding all of the fishes and corals we planned on...and then, before we realize it...we're full. No more room for new fishes. No more frags. None.

What do you do then?

The simple answer. Get another tank! Because a good stocking plan will simply set you up for frustration! Why? Because, quite simply, you can't have it all.

index.jpg


Doesn't matter if you created a 5-gallon aquarium, or a 500-gallon aquarium. It hits you just the same.

Yup.

Think about it. We spend a lot of time researching all of the fishes and corals we're going to add to our new aquarium, develop sequences for whom is added when- and so forth. And, for the most part, we execute on our plans pretty well. In fact, probably too well.

Vincent Thomas Tank2.jpg


Because what inevitably happens is we look ago our newly-stocked tank, brimming with life, and we're enamored...To the point where we wish we added that one more fish or coral...Wouldn't that new wrasse be so cool? Ohh, can't do it- you opted for a group of Tangs instead....Oh, and those cool Faviids you saw at the LFS yesterday would be so cool..but this is a Tropical Western Atlantic-themed tank, and they're from the Pacific...It would look... weird...with your Chalk Basses and Royal Grammas and Atlantic Blue Tangs...and you're a hardcore biotope geek, Right?

IMG_0212.jpg


So, from the minute we "finish"- or for that matter-start- a new aquarium, we're actually working on the next one! Because everything that we couldn't include in this one, we have to add to the next one. It's not that we don't enjoy or appreciate what we already have. Ot's just that there are so many possibilities out there, right? Some new coral or fish- some new concept- will capture your attention.

Thats what being a fish geek is.


And, of course, that's is the crux of what we call "Multiple Tank Syndrome."

IMG_1829.JPG


It's simply not possible for a serious fish geek to have just one tank. Or, if he or she is stuck with one tank, there is almost certainly a lot of scheming going on, and changes in the setup might happen sooner, rather than later. In other words, we cope.

IMG_1232.JPG


Far be it from me to look on this phenomenon with anything but awe. It infects every fish geek, regardless of the original intentions, budgetary restrictions, space, or impact on spousal relations.

It's how 30 tank fish rooms get built.


Multiple Yank Syndrome. Very real. Very challenging.

And very cool.

If you have this- consider yourself blessed.

Your a genuine, 100% fish geek.

Simple as that.

How have you "coped" or "overcome" this issue? What is a fish geek to do? How do you attend a frag swap when your tank is "full?" Is a reef ever really "full?"

IMG_0114.JPG


Revel in the title of "geek." Relish the affliction. Stay obsessed. Keep scheming. Keep dreaming. Keep building. Get another tank...

And stay wet.



Scott Fellman
 
I just bought a bigger house, although I tend to do my dry aqua-scape based on what I "plan" to add to the tank, yet this philosophy hasn't panned out well. Maybe on this new build I can achieve the stocking a reef with the emperor penguins.
 
I just bought a bigger house, although I tend to do my dry aqua-scape based on what I "plan" to add to the tank, yet this philosophy hasn't panned out well. Maybe on this new build I can achieve the stocking a reef with the emperor penguins.
I believe that could work. :cool:
 
I can't do it T.T my one tank is all I can manage. When it's getting full I'll have to sell frags or corals I like less, to change things up....or just let it be and enjoy (fat chance, though a long-term success would be quite an achievement for me.) Chances are our next apartment move will knock some things out, as it tends to do, and I'll have to rebuild...again....
 
I really like this topic. It's not just about what we put in tanks but it's also about if we're letting things grow. If we let things grow to their full potential size we all have to have huge tanks well for the most part. I guess there are zoos and mushrooms that we don't have to worry about getting too big for any tank.

But really, how many of us plan out for the full size of a scrolling Coral when we are setting up our bio type tanks. Usually we condense their size down by fragging. In my new tank I plan on getting few corals and letting them grow ginormous size. Is that going to happen? I don't know. But I'm going to try.

I'm stuck with a single tank which means I can only have my 125 gallon Aquarium.
 
I really like this topic. It's not just about what we put in tanks but it's also about if we're letting things grow. If we let things grow to their full potential size we all have to have huge tanks well for the most part. I guess there are zoos and mushrooms that we don't have to worry about getting too big for any tank.

But really, how many of us plan out for the full size of a scrolling Coral when we are setting up our bio type tanks. Usually we condense their size down by fragging. In my new tank I plan on getting few corals and letting them grow ginormous size. Is that going to happen? I don't know. But I'm going to try.

I'm stuck with a single tank which means I can only have my 125 gallon Aquarium.
It's like, no matter HOW BIG our tanks are, there are still so many directions we want to take, right? And it's not just that we want big corals or fishes...it's that we want variety...And then, of course, we want the best possible environment for our animals to grow to maximum size and health...arrghhh...tradeoffs!

-Scott
 
AHHHH, MTS. I got it bad. There are just so many options out there that I like and that don't work together. I would hate to ever go bio type as I would double my tanks again. Temp I can do though with a cold water tank.

It doesn't take much longer to run more then one tank, just more dedication.
 
:cool: I just put enough tanks up that she got annoyed and said that if I cleaned out the basement I could have it for a fishroom. I took it a step further and am making the half bedroom into a laundry room so I can lay claim to almost the entire basement. It'll be the coolest place in the house! Well, actually hot and humid, but you know what I mean.
 
Stuck on one tank, I would love to have more but it would mean I would have to convert the garage and air condition it. That's not going to happen stuck to one 300 gallon system on fixed income. My current goal is to see how long I can keep everything healthy and growing. Living in Lake Havasu city so it would require chillers or an air conditioned room when it hit 120 degrees during the summer. I also like to go visit our children for a week or more at a time, don't want my life tied only to my tanks.
 
Last edited:
I relocated from Michigan to Tennessee last year and went from a sprawling basement fish room to NAADAAA!! I literally filled my garage with fish tanks and fish geek stuff... I've been slowly selling / trading most of it and have it down to a manageable accumulation... Funny how we end up with so much "stuff" in this hobby lol. I had been out of the hobby for a few years and when I got back in, I picked up a Craigslist deal with everything needed... for ONE tank... Now my wife knew I was a serious reefer, but she didn't understand that I immediately started buying QT tanks, frag tanks, desktop nanos. etc... it was just "Honey, I really need these tanks!!" to take care of the other tank... It took her awhile, but she gets it now... I'm down to two tanks now. :) Errrr ummm, 3... always forget about the QT!!!
 
AHHHH, MTS. I got it bad. There are just so many options out there that I like and that don't work together. I would hate to ever go bio type as I would double my tanks again. Temp I can do though with a cold water tank.

It doesn't take much longer to run more then one tank, just more dedication.

Yeah, if you go biotope, you'd cover , say- part of a biotope...then you'd have to do ANOTHER tank to get the other part of it...it's endless!
 
:cool: I just put enough tanks up that she got annoyed and said that if I cleaned out the basement I could have it for a fishroom. I took it a step further and am making the half bedroom into a laundry room so I can lay claim to almost the entire basement. It'll be the coolest place in the house! Well, actually hot and humid, but you know what I mean.
:cool: I just put enough tanks up that she got annoyed and said that if I cleaned out the basement I could have it for a fishroom. I took it a step further and am making the half bedroom into a laundry room so I can lay claim to almost the entire basement. It'll be the coolest place in the house! Well, actually hot and humid, but you know what I mean.
Ahh, sort of "squatting", actually! Love it! :D
 
Stuck on one tank, I would love to have more but it would mean I would have to convert the garage and air condition it. That's not going to happen stuck to one 300 gallon system on fixed income. My current goal is to see how long I can keep everything healthy and growing. Living in Lake Havasu city so it would require chillers or an air conditioned room when it hit 120 degrees during the summer. I also like to go visit our children for a week or more at a time, don't want my life tied only to my tanks.
You're a far healthier individual than many of us here, lol:)
 
I relocated from Michigan to Tennessee last year and went from a sprawling basement fish room to NAADAAA!! I literally filled my garage with fish tanks and fish geek stuff... I've been slowly selling / trading most of it and have it down to a manageable accumulation... Funny how we end up with so much "stuff" in this hobby lol. I had been out of the hobby for a few years and when I got back in, I picked up a Craigslist deal with everything needed... for ONE tank... Now my wife knew I was a serious reefer, but she didn't understand that I immediately started buying QT tanks, frag tanks, desktop nanos. etc... it was just "Honey, I really need these tanks!!" to take care of the other tank... It took her awhile, but she gets it now... I'm down to two tanks now. :) Errrr ummm, 3... always forget about the QT!!!
"Managable accumulation"- I love the sort of vague, "this-number-is-subject-to-change-as-I-find-other-stuff-I want-to-keep" connotation of that wording!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top