Thoughts on this sloppy rockscape? (Repost)

[Steven777]

I made a similar post before but figured it would be better to make a new one since my plan didn't work out (turned out tank is too small for all the rock). I got rid of one of the big rock the result is below... Do you think it looks decent?

 

[Peach02]

Personally I would do 1 without the big rock in the middle to have two islands

 

[Shep]

Personally I would do 1 without the big rock in the middle to have two islands

That would look nice, I am personally not a fan of scapes that look like a wall/line from the front. You could also do the to islands but put a connecting piece to kind of make an arch/cave