Thoughts & Troubleshoot recent ICP test

tenurepro

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 17, 2017
Messages
845
Reaction score
1,310
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi All,
I would like to hear your thoughts on the results of a recent ICP test. I have a SPS dominant redsea reefer 250 (~65 gal total volume). The tank is looking reall good (see video link at the bottom), but the result revealed a two elements are off the charts...
Sulphur is a 2287 mg/l (vs. 900 mg/l setpoint)
Iodine is 147 ug/l (vs 60 ug/l setpoint)

Po4 is higher than expected too, but that is on purpose, so not a concern here!

Ok, i am currently using the regular instant ocean for salt; and i try to maintain salinity at 35 ppt. I was trying out the new seachem vibrant sea salt; i used up a full big container (220 gal?) before switching back to Instant Ocean in December. I do 15 L water changes every week. I run seachem matrix carbon (a small amount in a phosban reactor). I have 50X waterflow in the tank and i use radion xr15 lights.

I dose:
kalkwasser in the ATO, which is sufficient for maintaining calcium in my system
a little redsea foundation buffer B for alkalinity (around 9.9 dkh)
Redsea foundation buffer c for Magnesium.
Seachem flourish phosphorus

Several months ago, i played around with dosing redsea coral colors and potassium nitrate to improve SPS colors, but i discontinued that after getting a major Dino bloom. I managed to get over my dino issues by dosing seachem flourish phosphorous to maintain po4 levels above 0.1 ppm, along with 5 to 10 ppm nitrates.

I feed 2 or 3 times a day, either frozen mysis, NLS pellets, or a homemade mix of shrimps/fish/squid/oysters ground up in the food processor, then frozen. I also a bit of nori twice a week; the nori i use is from my sushi kit... not from the LFS.

ok, so for iodine, perhaps the high levels are from dosing a bit too much a few month ago, or feeding fresh seafood?

The elevated sulphur is perplexing however. Could it be some preservative in the nori i use from my sushi kit ? Should i be concerned about the high levels ? My tank is looking really good right now so i am hesitant to change, but if high sulphur can have some negative long term consequences, then perhaps i need to do something to keep it down.


Screen Shot 2018-02-01 at 11.57.00 PM.jpg

Screen Shot 2018-02-01 at 11.57.09 PM.jpg

Screen Shot 2018-02-01 at 11.57.17 PM.jpg

link to video of my tank, about 2 weeks ago
 
The sulfur is sulfate in seawater. It is the third most abundant ion in seawater normally (by weight), and to make it rise that much would take massive amounts of an additive. Pounds.

Unless you have used Epsom salts only for huge magnesium boosts, it is either

1. Test error/reporting error (it's so off, I'd ask Triton to double check somehow that it isn't just a typo)

or

2. A problem with your starting salt mix.

I'm not sure why your iodine is higher, but I'd just not dose any. It's not a big deal.
 
The sulfur is sulfate in seawater. It is the third most abundant ion in seawater normally (by weight), and to make it rise that much would take massive amounts of an additive. Pounds.

Unless you have used Epsom salts only for huge magnesium boosts, it is either

1. Test error/reporting error (it's so off, I'd ask Triton to double check somehow that it isn't just a typo)

or

2. A problem with your starting salt mix.

I'm not sure why your iodine is higher, but I'd just not dose any. It's not a big deal.
Thanks Randy. Lets assume that high sulfate is real - would i expect to see some detrimental effects in my tank? Thanks again for your help!
 
Thanks Randy. Lets assume that high sulfate is real - would i expect to see some detrimental effects in my tank? Thanks again for your help!

We really have little data on the effects of elevated or reduced sulfate (it isn't really used by most tank creatures, it just provides the "environment" like chloride does), but yours is reported to be way higher than I have ever seen before.
 
You're welcome.

let us know if you find out what is going on. :)

Will do. Hey, is there a simple way to go from Sodium 10340 mg/l to salinity ? I thought my salinity was ‘ideal’ at 35 ppt (via refractometer) but the ICP test is showing that sodium is in the lower end of normal
 
My sulphate was sitting where it should be but took a 100 point rise once i started adding mag additive (seachem reef advantage Mag) that is supposed to be both mag sulphate & sodium chloride - If yours is not a dud reading maybe its coming from the red sea buffer. Used most of a 1kg bottle for it to do that for me.
re the salinity is also this about - https://monrecifamoi.saulme.fr/salinite/elements_compute_salinity.php

Don't they hold onto one of the vials for a limited time so you can get a retest done?
 
Last edited:
thanks for the calculator; i got 35 ppt, which is what i read on my refractometer, so thats good
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top