Titration Test Question

FlyPenFly

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 25, 2013
Messages
743
Reaction score
338
Location
San Diego, CA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Using the Red Sea Ca and Mg tests, I notice that the color change happens within 1-5 seconds but if I let it rest for a minute it’ll revert back to a purple color rather than the navy blue. Are you supposed to take the measurement right when it turns navy blue or do you let it rest a minute and make sure it doesn’t turn back purple?
 
Excellent question. I'm only going to address the Ca test in this response (it is late, and I am very tired). The Ca test uses a hydroxide to precipitate the Mg and then titrates the remaining Ca. Problem is, some Ca also gets precipitated as calcium hydroxide (kalk). When the test gets to the endpoint, the solution gets to this state where the equilibrium changes, and now because the titrant has bound up all the Ca in solution, the precipitated kalk wants to re-dissolve. But, this takes a little bit of time to happen. Because of this, the Ca test should not be considered complete until the change to the pure blue color persists for a few minutes.

While we're talking about this, there were a couple of clever oceanographic chemists (Pate and Robinson) back in the 1950s who published a paper about how to get better accuracy and precision out of this test with a simple change to the method. The improved method requires you to already have a reasonably accurate idea of what your Ca level is. The idea is this: instead of adding the hydroxide first, you add about 90-95% of the amount of titrant necessary to get to the endpoint first. Only then do you add the hydroxide to precipitate the Mg. What happens if you do this is that the titrant binds to the Ca more stongly than the hydroxide wants to, so much much less Ca gets precipitated as kalk. This gives a much more accurate and precise Ca reading.

If you don't know what your Ca reading is, then do a "pilot" test the normal way, adding the hydroxide first, and then do a second reading using the "95% titrant first" trick.
 
Last edited:
So re-reading the instructions, here's what they say for the Mg but there's no similar not for Ca.

Note: Shortly after the blue end color is achieved the liquid in the vial will turn from blue
to violet. Do not continue adding titrant. If you have used more than 0.8ml of titrant you
may have missed the end point and should redo the test.Note the amount of titrant used
(according to the initial and final position of the plunger not the liquid surface) and use the
table on the instruction card to calculate the level of magnesium in the water sample.

This seems to indicate that the reading, at least for Mg, is to be taken immediately when it turns to the dark blue, not to wait until it turns back then making it blue again.

https://5w56d28u4co20frgwagf5y18-wp...age-Manual_GB_DE_FR_SE_NL_SP_PT_JP_CH_17A.pdf
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top