Too much base rock?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cjb428
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
I dont think it is too much. You could compact is some. I don't ever clean my back so I can place rocks up to it, but you have to be able to do the sides and front or it looks bad quickly.
You could go higher also. Just don't make it symmetrical.

It is almost impossible to have too much flow.
 
I’m a firm believer in having lots of rock, it makes the system healthier for the fish and corals because of the added surface area for bacteria. In my case my dt is in my bedroom and I don’t have a basement so my dt is packed with rock, if I had a basement I would have less in my dt and probably double what I have now in a big sump down there. The fish have more places to swim through, sleep, seek refuge, chill out etc... My current tank is a 92g, and 30g sump in the stand. I have 13 small to medium size fish and a lot of corals, my bioload is pretty heavy, I feed them 8 to 10 various Hikari cubes a day, and the fish and corals are all thriving which I know wouldn’t be possible if I had even half the rock I have now. Here’s a couple pics to give you an idea, and yes there is rock under all the coral.


563C33C7-A625-4DBD-B066-86EA00CA8ABE.jpeg
65B42854-9446-4C45-9A08-980E34A59682.jpeg


Ok that is amazing looking. I would love to see what it looked like prior to all the awesome coral, just rock.

Also what are you using for flow?
 
Love it, that’s kinda the look I was going for when I purchased all the rock also curious about your light setup.
I already had 3 Kessil160’s on 2 other tanks at the time I setup this one up a few years back and I liked the different looks they gave those tanks not to mention all types of corals grew under them. So when looking into lighting for my current tank I put the 3 160’s on it then bought 2 more 160’s, saving $ by not changing completely, ended up working out great. The 360 in the middle you see now I bought a couple months back since my lfs was blowing them out since the 360x came out. So that’s how I ended up with all the Kessils.
 
Last edited:
Ok that is amazing looking. I would love to see what it looked like prior to all the awesome coral, just rock.

Also what are you using for flow?
The rock before coral was just a bunch of rock piled up making lots of caves and swim through’s. The rock basically goes from all the way up the back to a couple inches from the front pane. I added flat pieces over the course of the 1st year or so to have more flat surface areas for adding frags. For flow I have 3 jebeao pp8’s. It works well as all the acroporas up top get good flow and the lower lps corals get much less like they like.
 
Tank is a 120 gal 5’ L x 18”W x 24” Deep
Sump is 24”x12”x16 refugium, said it was good up too 125 gallon tank

The 20g sump you have should do good with you 112g tank.
Tank is a 120 gal 5’ L x 18”W x 24” Deep
Sump is 24”x12”x16 refugium, said it was good up too 125 gallon tank

The 20g sump should do well with the 112g tank you have. Are you gonna reposition any of the rock?

Still quite a bit of rock for your footprint of the 112g IMHO.

It's all beautiful rock and you could have a good time shaping some of it. :)

Just enjoy and have a good time with it, good sir.
 
I think the amount of rock is OK if that is what you like. I would say that you may want to make sure you can get your glass cleaner between the rock and glass. Your tank would make a killer softie tank.
 
I’m a firm believer in having lots of rock, it makes the system healthier for the fish and corals because of the added surface area for bacteria. In my case my dt is in my bedroom and I don’t have a basement so my dt is packed with rock, if I had a basement I would have less in my dt and probably double what I have now in a big sump down there. The fish have more places to swim through, sleep, seek refuge, chill out etc... My current tank is a 92g, and 30g sump in the stand. I have 13 small to medium size fish and a lot of corals, my bioload is pretty heavy, I feed them 8 to 10 various Hikari cubes a day, and the fish and corals are all thriving which I know wouldn’t be possible if I had even half the rock I have now. Here’s a couple pics to give you an idea, and yes there is rock under all the coral.


563C33C7-A625-4DBD-B066-86EA00CA8ABE.jpeg
65B42854-9446-4C45-9A08-980E34A59682.jpeg

I thought I was the only one with that train of thought regarding more rock more bacteria. Mines is only a 45 gallon but under the coral is plenty of rock.

20190401_135111.jpg
 
If you can, get some shelf rocks. Try to minimize the amount of rocks in the sand, thus allowing most of your rock off the sand. Which equals greater water flow. When I started, I only used LR, and later added cured Dry LR from BRS. My tank never cycled, and has matured quickly.
 
the real I was always told was 1.5 lbs per gallon I have a 32 gal tank with 40 lbs of live rock and two power heads its 3 years old and this a doing fine I happen in the first 6 months no3 whent though the roof but after that things started to balance out 450 cal kh9 no3 are at 5 cant seam to get the lower then that but thing are growing and looking good now
 
I thought I was the only one with that train of thought regarding more rock more bacteria. Mines is only a 45 gallon but under the coral is plenty of rock.

20190401_135111.jpg
If I had the option of say a basement I would probably have a tank full of rock tied in to the dt, after 30+ years of doing this I know it doesn't hurt it only helps the tank inhabitants.
 
I dont think it is too much. You could compact is some. I don't ever clean my back so I can place rocks up to it, but you have to be able to do the sides and front or it looks bad quickly.
You could go higher also. Just don't make it symmetrical.

It is almost impossible to have too much flow.

I made the mistake of reading the "Make sure you leave room to clean the back glass" comments, and in retrospect I wish I had more rock against the back glass, because I never clean it.....
 
Place a couple in the sump and keep in mind you will occasionally get a coral that will be attached to a rock and will need to add that to existing rock
 
I to believe that you can never have too much Rock, I ran my tank as a FOWLR tank for many years with only the rock filtering the water. I have about 140lbs of Rock in a 155 gallon tank, stacked up against the back glass.
 
I’d take 75% of it out

I disagree completely. I think the amount is fine..... I would probably load it all up directly against the back-glass, and stack it more and have it go higher up in the tank at a point or two so it's not so uniform, but that's just my personal preference. Leave lots of sand space in the front, room on the left/right, and have a "Medium and high" option on the rocks for placement options.

I like the amount of rock though.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top