Walmart distilled water concerns?

justinkdenny

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
116
Reaction score
97
What state or country do you live in
Oklahoma
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I have noticed lately that walmart great value distilled water has an oily look to it when I top off my tank. I videoed it settling at the bottom of the container. Should I be concerned? I have always heard distilled water was safe for reefs.
 

Attachments

  • 20211211_143518.mp4
    7.7 MB
This bottle is full by the way and the oily looking stuff is settling at the bottom.
 
This bottle is full by the way and the oily looking stuff is settling at the bottom.
if it's at the bottom, I think the "salt" is trying to move up into your bottle, creating some density gradient that is visible. That's just my thought tho, since your bottle opening is relatively wide and it is submerged.
 
if it's at the bottom, I think the "salt" is trying to move up into your bottle, creating some density gradient that is visible. That's just my thought tho, since your bottle opening is relatively wide and it is submerged.
Sounds plausible!

Add some of the distilled water to a clear glass container, let it set and see if you get the same oily residue.
 
if it's at the bottom, I think the "salt" is trying to move up into your bottle, creating some density gradient that is visible. That's just my thought tho, since your bottle opening is relatively wide and it is submerged.
The water has no salt in it. It is just walmart distilled water in a bottle.
 
Sounds plausible!

Add some of the distilled water to a clear glass container, let it set and see if you get the same oily residue.
It does. The bottle in the video is just distilled water, no salt.
 
The water has no salt in it. It is just walmart distilled water in a bottle.
the salt solution rising up from the tank....part of osmotic pressure, high concentration moving to lower concentration. technically, it'd just be the salinity - it's like when you first mix syrup with water, you have the "thicker" syrup just sitting, with "lighter" water floating on top

saltwater is "heavier" than Ro/distilled water, thus it lingers at the bottom near the bottle inlet.
 
I wonder if it could be a thermacline (separation between hot and cold water)? Is it always there or soon after adding?
it dissipates when I pour it into the tank but you can visibly see it going into the tank.
 
It does. The bottle in the video is just distilled water, no salt.
If you pour that water into a glass from a freshly opened bottle before it touches the tank and it does that then there is a problem. If not, it's the salt water from the tank as everyone is saying. It wasn't clear to me if you have done that from your previous post. Have you done that?
 
Learn something new everyday.. interesting method for top off... my guess is what other have said.. your seeing the transfer of "ions" from your tank to the bottle.. but I am no way an expert.
It's visible in the container before I add it to the tank also.
 
one way to test, is, put the distilled water in a clear bottle/vase. then with a long pipette or turkey baster, very slowly add your tank water to the bottom of that bottle/vase. you should see similar stratification.

OK, before we gone too far, if you're looking for answers whether or not walmart distilled is contaminated - i don't have an answer. I only think the phenomenon you're seeing is stemmed from concentration gradient.
 
the salt solution rising up from the tank....part of osmotic pressure, high concentration moving to lower concentration. technically, it'd just be the salinity - it's like when you first mix syrup with water, you have the "thicker" syrup just sitting, with "lighter" water floating on top

saltwater is "heavier" than Ro/distilled water, thus it lingers at the bottom near the bottle inlet.
hmmm..... this might be it. I will check it just in a clear bottle before I ever add it to the tank. I was experimenting with a cheap auto top off method for this "budget reef" and that is when I noticed it. I never noticed this oily stuff in my other reef which auto top offs into the back chamber of my aio.
 
one way to test, is, put the distilled water in a clear bottle/vase. then with a long pipette or turkey baster, very slowly add your tank water to the bottom of that bottle/vase. you should see similar stratification.

OK, before we gone too far, if you're looking for answers whether or not walmart distilled is contaminated - i don't have an answer. I only think the phenomenon you're seeing is stemmed from concentration gradient.
I am getting a rodi unit for Christmas anyway but I would hate for this to mess up other reefs if there is some type of additive. My original reef has never really thrived like it should with good stable parameters so I'm always looking for the missing link. ICP test showed a red flag for potassium so maybe that's it too.
 
I'm using Walmart's Parent's Choice Distilled water for babies. Zero TDS. No surface film. Won't be found where drinking water or their purple cap distilled water (now clear cap). It's located usually in the pharmacy section.
 

Attachments

  • PARENTS CHOICE DISTILLED.jpg
    PARENTS CHOICE DISTILLED.jpg
    140.2 KB · Views: 339

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top