Wanna See Something Gross (and maybe help me fix it...)?

kkgaskin90

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 8, 2013
Messages
740
Reaction score
116
Location
Mobile, AL
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This has been a battle for a while now. I believe it is white slime bacteria from carbon dosing. A few weeks ago (2) I switched from vodka to vinegar. Last weekend we shut down and cleaned every pipe, line, overflow, and pump thoroughly. The tank was finally clear as well. The tank is still clear, as is the overflow. I noticed my return wasn't as much volume as it should be, so I recorded the inevitable. I'm open to any suggestions - so tired of fighting this stuff.

Anyone got a tissue in 3...2...
*I added awful music to cover my foul language at the sight of all this junk. Might wanna watch on mute*
 
I'm the wife, husband doesn't clean much less use febreze. It's not a household cleaner thing. Hardwood flooring around the tank that I mop with a natural soap, and pretty much everything else I use vinegar. Plus it's been ongoing for months, not a one time thing. 99% sure this is from carbon dosing.
 
I carbon dose but have never experienced anything close to this. That's disgusting. I can tell if I'm overdosing if I have to clean this glass every one to two days. Normally needs cleaning every 3 to 4 days. Plus when my carbon dosing is correct my NO3 and Po4 are stable where I want them. All three in harmony with each other. How much are you dosing to what volume of water?
 
I carbon dose but have never experienced anything close to this. That's disgusting. I can tell if I'm overdosing if I have to clean this glass every one to two days. Normally needs cleaning every 3 to 4 days. Plus when my carbon dosing is correct my NO3 and Po4 are stable where I want them. All three in harmony with each other. How much are you dosing to what volume of water?

I've never tweaked it since I started and found my "happy place", so that may be it. It's currently 48 ml vinegar in a 75g display + 20g sump
 
Back off on the carbon dosing. I can make my tank do the same thing. Your skimmer will pull that stuff out. Try backing the carbon dosing down 50%. If that doesn't start helping in a few days back it down some more. Also make sure your skimmer is working good.
 
I'm the wife, husband doesn't clean much less use febreze. ....


lol!

That has to be put in your signature.

I'm the wife, husband doesn't clean much less use febreze. It's not a household cleaner thing. Hardwood flooring around the tank that I mop with a natural soap, and pretty much everything else I use vinegar. Plus it's been ongoing for months, not a one time thing. 99% sure this is from carbon dosing.

I would say 100% sure it's from carbon dosing. My return pump does that every time it starts up. Not that much but a good amount of chunks come flying out several times a day as I shut my return off to feed. It gets worse as I up my vinegar dosing and gets better as I reduce it.
 
I've never tweaked it since I started and found my "happy place", so that may be it. It's currently 48 ml vinegar in a 75g display + 20g sump

What is your NO3 & PO4?
I would recommend to stop dosing for a week. Then start back at a much lower rate and try to split it up between a morning and evening dose.
I have a 120 gallon tank with a 34 gallon sump for an approximate net of 100 gallons. I dose 2.5 ml in the morning and 2.5 ml in the evening for a total of 5 ml per day.
 
0.2 and <0.03, respectively. Salifert tests.

It is currently split over 12 hours. I will try that, thanks.

And that's 5 ml of vinegar?
 
It is vinegar based. I have a light bio-load at the moment because my tank is fallow do to a marine velvet outbreak. I learned the hard way to QT all of my fish purchases and will probably do the same for coral in the future. I am feeding the corals twice a week and adding some nitrate http://brightwellaquatics.com/products/neonitro.php and phosphate http://brightwellaquatics.com/products/neophos.php to keep the biologic going and everything in equilibrium. Even before I went fallow I was only dosing 3 to 3.5 ml morning and night.
 
I get this crap in my bio pellet reactor ever since I changed to a reef octopus recerc reactor I never used to get it before that but now it clogs the screen in the reactor and fills the pipe of the recerc pump
 
I had it so stripped the full system and cleaned it all away removed my reactors one for carbon and the other for phosphate remover and haven't yet refitted them after 6 months clear but the cause of mine was air fresheners and the son spraying deodorant in the room next to the tank he stopped doing it in that room and as I say we're still clear of it after 6 months but I nearly quit the tank over it.
 
Gross... if it's bacterial, maybe chemiclean? Perhaps you could test it in a separate container to see if this stuff is killed by chemiclean before doing a full tank treatment?
 
It is vinegar based. I have a light bio-load at the moment because my tank is fallow do to a marine velvet outbreak. I learned the hard way to QT all of my fish purchases and will probably do the same for coral in the future. I am feeding the corals twice a week and adding some nitrate http://brightwellaquatics.com/products/neonitro.php and phosphate http://brightwellaquatics.com/products/neophos.php to keep the biologic going and everything in equilibrium. Even before I went fallow I was only dosing 3 to 3.5 ml morning and night.

Sorry to hear that. I learned the same lesson the hard way. But since quarantining everything when it comes in I haven't had any issues whatsoever. Best of luck!
 
Gross... if it's bacterial, maybe chemiclean? Perhaps you could test it in a separate container to see if this stuff is killed by chemiclean before doing a full tank treatment?

That's a thought. What would you expect it to look like when it's dead? I'd have to do 2 containers, one with and one without, so I could compare.
 
I had a similar issue when vodka dosing. It would also build up a thick slime on and high flow areas protected from the fish and inverts such as inside of tubing and my skimmer. I cut back the amount I was dosing and it went away over time.
 
Some people get unsightly bacteria from carbon dosing, and most do not. I'm not sure why exactly, but it may depend on what species are already in the tank before dosing, and exactly where the organic is dosed (I dosed just upstream of a large rock filled refugium so there was lots of surface area for bacteria there).
 
Some people get unsightly bacteria from carbon dosing, and most do not. I'm not sure why exactly, but it may depend on what species are already in the tank before dosing, and exactly where the organic is dosed (I dosed just upstream of a large rock filled refugium so there was lots of surface area for bacteria there).

Do you run macro as well? Same fuge or do you have a separate, rock only fuge for bacterial colonization?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top