You guys were right. He must have some internal issues. Nothings spread to other fish, he’s just getting worse and worse. I am just going to let nature run its course and hopefully snag him before any ammonia spikes. Talked with a FS owner and he said something significant, “If you don’t know what it is, and I am not sure what it is (not ick or brooklynella), and it’s a clownfish, there’s tons of money you could spend trying to save him. But once he’s gotten to that point (he now has torn fins) it’s best to just consider him a goner, but leave him be and remove him asap upon death.” Which is the best advice I could have got. I know it’s “just a fish” but I like to give the utmost care possible for any of the living things I am responsible for and it’s always disappointing to have a loss. It was tough hearing there weren’t many options but sometimes it just gets to that point. Especially with fish. I’m not a softie I just don’t like feeling like I failed on something that relied on me to care for its life, reminds me of ranching cows back in the day, things just happen sometimes. Thanks for all the advice guys and gals! I’m going to stick to one clown for a while and make sure he’s doing fine before adding anything else. And hopefully learn something from this situation.