What’s the secret to acans?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FishRN
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

FishRN

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 9, 2021
Messages
150
Reaction score
137
Location
Brandon
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
What’s everyone’s secret to acans? There one of the corals that just doesn’t seem to like my tank. Almost everything else flourishes from torches and hammers to zoas even my little acro has tripled in size. My acans however just seem to shrivel up to nothing over a couple of days. I’ve tried low light to medium light with medium flow all the way up to blasting them with both. I just don’t think my tank will support them...
 
I have one, and it ebbs and flows, some days it looks like it's going to pop it expands so much and other days that it just sits there deflated chilling.
I have had it since June and luckily it is given me 5 new heads recently.
I don't know what to tell you, they do seem to be a little temperamental but not real fussy. These are pics of its different phases, the second pic shows the new heads.

20220110_163535.jpg
20220313_103754.jpg
 
Last edited:
That's where I'm at, my tank just doesn't like acan or goni and I've come to make peace with being happy growing everything else.
 
What’s everyone’s secret to acans? There one of the corals that just doesn’t seem to like my tank. Almost everything else flourishes from torches and hammers to zoas even my little acro has tripled in size. My acans however just seem to shrivel up to nothing over a couple of days. I’ve tried low light to medium light with medium flow all the way up to blasting them with both. I just don’t think my tank will support them...
Water may be to clean. While feeding them speeds up growth they take many things from the water. I have some that have made 10 heads in 8 months. My calcium, mag are always on the high side. Alk a steady 9. They can take more light than you think and some love it. Put one in moderate light and feed it at night once a week. See what hsppens.
 
They seem to be one of the easier ones for me. I just kind put them in the middle-ish of the tank so the light and powerheads aren't blasting directly at them and I'm good. But at the same time, I wasn't paying attention the last time I put one in my tank...the epoxy was quickly drying and I was scrambling to find a hole in the rock big enough for the plug only to realize a few days later I stuck it about 2 inches directly in front of an MP10...it's doing just fine. Another one started with 2 big heads and after a few weeks now has 2 or 3 more spawning off the side of it.
Hell, they even do just fine in my invert QT, which, while most everything survives, nothing thrives in there. Most of my corals in QT tend to spend the latter half of their quarantine time mostly closed*, like they're on death's door. But not the acans, they do just fine.
I suppose since acans don't really open and close like so many other corals, maybe they're all days away from death and just not showing any obvious symptoms, but I don't think that's the case. I hope not, I've picked up a giant one with 30+ heads that's due to come out of QT in [checks notes] exactly one weeks.


*Every euphilia I've put in my QT will have being almost competently retracted for the last few weeks, but will open back up within a week of being in the DT. I bought a dendro on a whim that looked like I was killing it. Moved it to the DT yesterday and it was totally open in less than an hour.
 
I think y’all might be right on just leaving them out which sucks because they are one of my favorites. And as far as feed them goes I give the ones that have a feeding response reefroids.
 
I keep all mine in my sand bed and feed them twice a week.and feed them mysis shrimp and brine
 
I agree that they like to be fed. But shriveling up and dying after a couple days means there is something else going on that isn't related to feeding, or to nitrate/phosphate for that matter.
 
That’s where I’m stumped if it was a matter of parameters wouldn’t everything else be suffering. But here they are salinity1.026, pH8.4, nitrate 5, Alk 8.1, cal 480, mag 1260, phosphate 0.1.
 
That’s where I’m stumped if it was a matter of parameters wouldn’t everything else be suffering. But here they are salinity1.026, pH8.4, nitrate 5, Alk 8.1, cal 480, mag 1260, phosphate 0.1.
Sometimes we just don't know why. I have most of my frags doing well with a couple hanging on for dear life, again same tank good parameters yet some thrive with a couple just bailing
 
Mine are hungry little beasts..reef roid paste small direct feeding once a week.just the smallest amount to get them to open mouths and then a bit more. Low and almost middle tank on flatrock. They seem to like same placement n flow as frogspawn for me. Hope you can figure it out.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top