I'm new here, but been a member of the other big reef site for a while. Here are the key differences I've seen so far.
- Having Randy on staff is a big plus for you guys. There are a lot of people on both sites that are great with Chem and great at helping with Chem related issues, but let's call a spade a spade here. Randy is flat out one of the best in the business. I don't think he misses a thread and continuously answers everything from the most basic (which could have been read in a sticky) to in depth Triton analysis.
- The encouragement from the staff to get involved. There are posts everywhere, encouraging users to create content. Be it through contests, requests like this one, or just general, "Hey guys post this".
- Xenforo. Absolutely one of my favorite things about this website. Xenforo can be as involved or uninvolved as the user wants it to be and every user can customize the content/look/layout to their liking. Why should I need quote a post and type "+1" when the ability to hit the like button has been around for over 5 years now. A few of the other forums I mod run it, and it's just all around great software.
- If/when I become a supporter I feel like my money would be going somewhere, towards something where I would see tangible benefits, beyond just operating costs. Be it hiring more staff, helping obtain more prizes for contests, helping pool money to become a "sponsor" on other vendor website...etc.
- The contests. Sure you guys could run contests and just give out free crap everywhere, but you go beyond that. Yes I know I'm going to need to go like a facebook page somewhere, whoopidy do. Outside of that though, most of the contests are driven to steer content. IE..."you get a bonus entry in the contest for creating a new thread on the forums".
- Lastly, there is more then one way to skin a deer. Sure we all need the basic tools to accomplish said task, but I've found the general user base here to be a little more accepting and a little less black and white with how people handle their tanks.
Again this is just from my perspective as I don't mean any ill will or negativity to those where I came from, as I truly learned a lot there. I think both sites are great, but I really like what is going on here and plan to stick around and help it grow (mostly from the clowns and nem closet).