What is happening to my acan?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gatling
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Gatling

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 12, 2018
Messages
147
Reaction score
117
Location
Toronto
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi all,
My acan has be doing very well for a few months but I've been noticing the base of the acan is receding..? I'll show you before and now photos.

Calcium and magnesium are on par.

Here is it a few weeks ago:
IMG_20190203_135827.jpg


And here it is this morning (notice the base on the left head):
IMG_20190206_095414.jpg
 
Eek! I hope someone comes along that knows about acans. What are your water parameters?
 
Eek! I hope someone comes along that knows about acans. What are your water parameters?
Calcium at 415 ppm
Mag at 1250 ppm
SG at 1.024
Temp at 81/82
PH at 8

I have an AI Prime as well, but nothing new has really changed except my two clown fish I introduced around 5 days ago. The Acan has been doing great for so long!

I'd like to add that the colour of the Acan hasn't changed. It is still very vibrant. So I don't think its dying.. but the base of it looks like it has a coral version of gingivitis!
 
Here's an update: the colour is still fine but it is shrinking.. what would cause this? It isn't in direct flow.

IMG_20190207_091811.jpg
 
Since you got it have you started dosing/feeding anything different to the tank. It's sure headed downhill fast as the skeletal structure is wasting away.
 
Calcium at 415 ppm
Mag at 1250 ppm
SG at 1.024
Temp at 81/82
PH at 8

I have an AI Prime as well, but nothing new has really changed except my two clown fish I introduced around 5 days ago. The Acan has been doing great for so long!

I'd like to add that the colour of the Acan hasn't changed. It is still very vibrant. So I don't think its dying.. but the base of it looks like it has a coral version of gingivitis!
Unfortunately the color intensity will stay pretty good. It will just gradually disappear. I hate that you’re losing it. I had the same thing happen to one of mine. I have quite a few but one of them wasted away. I never figured out why. :(
 
I don't dose but I checked my magnesium and calcium and they're on par. Should I still dose? All my other corals are somewhat happy. :((
 
Oh I do use reef roids once a week. The acan takes it and loves it!

If the skeleton is wasting away, it would be a calcium issue right? Maybe I'll check that again
 
Best I can think of is to keep parameters stable. Better to lose one coral than a bunch trying to save one.

A large water change could be a good option.
 
Any acan I put in my tank does the same thing. While "harder" to keep corals thrive(goniopora, any SPS). When I started in a biocube acans thrived and grew like crazy. Moved to a larger tank with T5 lighting, and I cannot keep them alive.

I have no idea why either, they just waste away just like yours is doing. Feeding once a day, change lighting, change flow, parameters spot on, does not matter. I have since given up on this coral.

I certainly hope yours recovers, but from my experience this coral is a goner.
 
I wonder if its getting too much light. I'm covering up a bit of the tank's top to shade the acan. Hopefully this will help. Otherwise I have no clue... I love this acan so much but I haven't seen it all puffy in months :(
 
The first photo that you posted, is that when you first got it? Personally it looks doomed in the first photo also.

How old is the tank?
Agreed. It was not good in the first pic.
 
I don't dose but I checked my magnesium and calcium and they're on par. Should I still dose? All my other corals are somewhat happy. :((

What do you mean by somewhat happy? That doesn't sound reassuring either.
 
Oh I do use reef roids once a week. The acan takes it and loves it!

If the skeleton is wasting away, it would be a calcium issue right? Maybe I'll check that again

The skeleton is not actually changing, the tissue is retracting and was already significantly retracted when the acan was acquired. It was not in good shape at the start. No skeleton should be visible on a healthy acan. The chances of this one recovering are pretty slim IMO but not outside the realm of possibility.

Did you dip the frag when you got it? Can you post pictures of your other corals/full tank shot? What fish are in your tank? What kind of lighting? What is your alkalinity and is it stable?
 
I had one of mine do the same, I didn't do anything it was like that for weeks and before I knew it it bounce back. Hope yours does the same.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top