What is this black spot on my Kenya Tree?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rover
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Rover

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 23, 2018
Messages
126
Reaction score
161
Location
New Brunswick, Canada
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This Coral is one of the few corals I still have from an old tank I shut down prior to my move over a year ago. In November I did frag three small pieces off, and didn't notice any unusual markings on it. I noticed some darker spots a week or so ago, but on looking again today at night when the coral was closed up they seemed much more worrisome, almost like a parasite.
Can anyone identify what these are, and if there is a course of action I should take?

First three photos are afflicted areas. All of them look like a 'hole' in the coral, with a black growth in the center. It doesn't seem to be moving or alive, and out of concern of spreading it I haven't manually tried to mess with it yet. Figured I'd get some advice before potentially making it worse.

Last photo is from Mid-november, shortly after it was fragged.


80972023_813932005790222_7453664761499090944_n.jpg


81260914_776490866203154_5752485076625522688_n.jpg


81517918_471465553786625_1123152137090498560_n.jpg


81604066_586570668573514_2584526557829660672_n.jpg
 
Mat be work bu keep an eye on it for movement or growth
 
I'll admit I'm not 100% sure on what you said, but I will definitely be watching it for growth or any signs of change!
I really hate spell correct. " May be worm but keep an eye on it for movement or growth "
 
I really hate spell correct. " May be worm but keep an eye on it for movement or growth "

Gotcha!

They don't seem to be moving, but they are 'changing', if that makes sense. The largest one seemed to almost 'open' a bit. Its really hard to get a good photo unfortunately to show what I mean. Are there example pictures of these worms, or a name, so I can look them up?
 
Well, they were getting larger so I decided to take some action.

Through the expert surgical use of a turkey baster and some suction, I 'pulled' out most of the black stuff. It seemed very much like a... growth? It was soft and came apart after some manipulation, and looked for all the world like the normal polyps, just black. After doing this, it began to regrow in some of the same places however. I'm at a bit of a loss with what it is, however the coral certainly doesn't look 'happy' in those areas. It left a hole in the coral that penetrated a decent distance into the body, where the black piece was situated.

If anyone has an idea, or can request something done to help them figure out what it is, please let me know.
 
I've had this on mine a few times. I'm guessing its some sort of bacterial rot or something, it seems to be similar to cyano but black. I pulled it off and made sure the coral had good flow. Mine has bounced back from it. I just make sure to keep on testing the water and perform regular H20 changes.
 
I had a sinularia that had something similar happen. Started as a little black spot and stated to spread. I believe it happened because I had Cyanobacteria and algae on it. When it started to spread I knew it was some type of infection so I cut off all the black parts. It bounced back easily and is now healthy and happy a year later.

These kind of corals seem to be pretty resilient so yours will probably heal up.
 
Glad to hear!

This Coral is one of the only things I have from my first saltwater tank before my move earlier this year. I had to completely shut-down due to a landlord issue, and when I was able to restart my tank this coral is one of the few I recovered from the local reef store to use again. :) I've already fragged it so it will live on, but it'd be nice to save the mother tree!

I'll stay on top of getting off all the black spots as they come up, and hopefully that will help and it'll bounce back.
 

Above is a video of when I did the deep cleaning. Not seen is the time spent picking carefully with dental picks to get every bit of the black I could fine.

Does this video, or the below two pictures, help anyone identify what exactly it is for sure?


I'll report back in if it grows back.
 
I have the same on my Kenya tree, on some of the post they say it could be Cyanobacteria so I am going to use chemiclean today,I will let you know the outcome
 

Above is a video of when I did the deep cleaning. Not seen is the time spent picking carefully with dental picks to get every bit of the black I could fine.

Does this video, or the below two pictures, help anyone identify what exactly it is for sure?


I'll report back in if it grows back.
Any update on this? Asking because I'm seeing similar growths on my new sinularia (which it came with when I purchased it)
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top