What is this? HELP!

[omegasoldier123]

Cannot figure out what this is. Looked everywhere. Came as a bonus coral from an online vendor.

 

[Squishie89]

Could you post what the skeleton/base looks like? I am thinking a type of xenia or anthelia (this seems like a good guess Saltwater Aquarium Corals for Marine Reef Aquariums: Waving Hand - Blue) or glove polyp (Glove Polyp).

 

[Tab28]

To me they like brown star polyps or an organ pipe coral. If you can take picture with polyps retracted. If pipe organ it will have skeleton. If a clove or star polyp it will look like jelly or gum stuck onto a rock.

 

[omegasoldier123]

Here are some shots of it closed

 

[omegasoldier123]

The problem that I am having is that the polyps arent on long stalks and are not big enough to be a Xenia or pipe organ

 

[Tab28]

Looks like star polyps, but never seems tan ones. Not pipe organ. Too short to be anthelia or clove polyps.

 

[omegasoldier123]

Yeah if that's what this is, I've never seen tan ones either and neither has anyone else. That's why I was stumped lol!