What is this in my dry rock?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JCOLE
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

JCOLE

Grower of the Small Polyps
View Badges
Joined
Mar 12, 2018
Messages
4,158
Reaction score
11,216
Location
Charlotte, NC
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I just receieved some dry rock in for a new build I am working on. I have used a lot of dry rock and never noticed this before. I found what appeared to be Quartz on a piece and another round shiny piece that resembles quartz as well.

Does anyone know what this is?

20220308_195430.jpg
20220309_081127.jpg
20220309_081937.jpg
20220309_082024.jpg
 
Sorry I couldn’t help myself
 
pic 1 is an old dried out sponge.

The other 2 appear to be either snail shells or possibly tool marks. Hard to tell...
 
I don’t know what that is but when I read the thread title that’s the first thing I thought
 
The C could be the mark of the beast

you’re doomed with that rock
 
Most dry rock I have seen that is mined in south Florida contains those crystals. Agatized coral is the state rock after all.
 
Those are so circular, I'm guessing it's a from a diamond drill (coring) bit, maybe with some sort of pilot tip.
It could have been used to make the rock easier to split, or maybe there was a (now broken off) part above that spot that someone was trying to drill frag plug holes into.
 
No idea about the first one but the second looks like hard acrylic tubing. Is this natural rock or is it manufactured? I'd wonder if it's actually man-made concrete rock and pieces of acrylic tubing or plastic were used to hold pieces together while it was setting? It looks a little too perfectly round to be natural. The first image could just be pieces of crystalline rock or quartz that were added to the concrete while setting to give it a bit of structure.
 
No idea about the first one but the second looks like hard acrylic tubing. Is this natural rock or is it manufactured? I'd wonder if it's actually man-made concrete rock and pieces of acrylic tubing or plastic were used to hold pieces together while it was setting? It looks a little too perfectly round to be natural. The first image could just be pieces of crystalline rock or quartz that were added to the concrete while setting to give it a bit of structure.
If it’s mined rock like Marco, it has nothing to do with concrete.
 
If it’s mined rock like Marco, it has nothing to do with concrete.
Just wondering if it IS mined rock or if its man-made? OP didn't specify.
Isn't some of the rock sold by Carribsea artificial/man-made, and other suppliers as well?
 
Also, It appears to be natural mined rock.

From their site.

  • 100% natural aragonite rock is great for decorating aquariums, conserving natural reefs, coral farming, culturing rocks and growing live coral.
This natural, porous aragonite rock is filled with naturally-formed holes that not only look great in your set-up, but help maintain aquarium health by acting as a biological filter. Plus, the porous surface is the perfect environment for denitrifying marine bacteria to grow, which work to decrease your tank’s nitrate levels over time. The unique shape means every rock is one-of-a-kind, and also makes it easy to stack when growing live corals or adding to coral-based environments. Plus, the rock has been soaked in a deep water well to prevent leaching in your aquarium.
 
Also, I will take some macro pictures tomorrow.
 
I just receieved some dry rock in for a new build I am working on. I have used a lot of dry rock and never noticed this before. I found what appeared to be Quartz on a piece and another round shiny piece that resembles quartz as well.

Does anyone know what this is?

20220308_195430.jpg
20220309_081127.jpg
20220309_081937.jpg
20220309_082024.jpg
I also have what looks like quartz to me, in my dry rock.
 
And in my previous build I had this nodule which I was concerned was metal, so I took it out of my tank. I threw it outside, which is why one pic has a spider on it.

D68EF023-0BB7-4396-B516-CB5B063778E9.jpeg 17E44D4B-6A8A-4B97-B6C5-773F2A01BC88.jpeg
 
I started washing the rocks and I noticed one rock has this orange/rust colored substance on it. Any ideas what it could be?

20220319_170235.jpg
20220319_170232.jpg
20220319_170221.jpg
 
I started washing the rocks and I noticed one rock has this orange/rust colored substance on it. Any ideas what it could be?

20220319_170235.jpg
20220319_170232.jpg
20220319_170221.jpg
Glad I’m not the only one paranoid about the rocks. I also had something like this. I ended up knocking it out, even thought it was probably fine.
 
Glad I’m not the only one paranoid about the rocks. I also had something like this. I ended up knocking it out, even thought it was probably fine.

You're right and its probably nothing to worry about. I read a couple things were others were saying it was mineral deposits, etc and it should be fine.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top