What keeps my Parameters Up would really like to figure this out.

DSC_7465.JPG

I am no expert on parameters and coral growth. It does seem there may some limiting factor though. Or perhaps something like a metal polluting. The tank does not look bad, in fact it looks pretty good. But if stony corals can not survive in a three year old tank, that seems concerning. An ICP test may eliminate the metal polluting variable at least.

My other concern would be getting RO/DI water from the LFS. You may trust them and they may be a great shop, but that water is out of your control. I had an LFS give me saltwater instead of RO/DI once and another time one gave me waste water (TDS was over 400!). One of those cases was a new employee. I ended up getting my own RO/DI system. I would at least test every batch bought with a TDS meter (which only costs $20-30).

 
If already have the mag, ca and alk tests. Could preform them on your top off water. If they are not flushing their ro/di regularly could be impacting the membrane.
 
Next time I get water I will ask them to test it, also will look into getting my own RO/DI system. I actually have a TDS Meter I bought off EBay which turned out to be a piece of junk. I'll get one from MD or BRS.
 
I agree your numbers are high. As far as growth goes have you checked your par readings. Looks like you have a Current Orbit type light, may not be enough power. From the pictures your tank looks to be 20-24 inches tall. Orbit lights are not very powerful. Maybe see if a local reef club or your LFS has a par meter to loan/rent.
 
If already have the mag, ca and alk tests. Could preform them on your top off water. If they are not flushing their ro/di regularly could be impacting the membrane.

Will test the ATO in the morning, still have 3 containers of water for it also will test.
 
I agree your numbers are high. As far as growth goes have you checked your par readings. Looks like you have a Current Orbit type light, may not be enough power. From the pictures your tank looks to be 20-24 inches tall. Orbit lights are not very powerful. Maybe see if a local reef club or your LFS has a par meter to loan/rent.

Sorry wrong Pict, that is an older one with the Current. I have 3 Kessil A360WE Tuna Blues for about a month now. Don't have any way of checking PAR at this Time, I have noticed the Mushrooms have gotten bigger since changing the lights. Don't have any LPS/SPS in tank
DSC_7547.JPG
 
Found another TDS Meter & water Tested at 59 PPM.
Interesting enough is ALK= 9, CALC =450 & MAg= 1400 are all within their necessary parameters but that doesn't last more then a cpl days. I can't test the water from the Store for any of the above because it is RO/DI Fresh water
 
I would test the fresh water ro/di for calcium. If it shows anything above zero explains your parameters increasing without dosing.

Test your tap tap water tds, if similar to the 59 would switch to that till save for your own ro/di
 
I would test the fresh water ro/di for calcium. If it shows anything above zero explains your parameters increasing without dosing.

Test your tap tap water tds, if similar to the 59 would switch to that till save for your own ro/di
OK \, will do.
 
I would test the fresh water ro/di for calcium. If it shows anything above zero explains your parameters increasing without dosing.

Test your tap tap water tds, if similar to the 59 would switch to that till save for your own ro/di

RO/DI Cal is like 200. Tap Water TDS = 58
 
RO/DI Cal is like 200. Tap Water TDS = 58

This leads to 2 ideas, they are either not changing their membranes when required or they are not flushing properly and build up is occurring. Or they are using the same source water you have and declorinating it and calling it rodi
 
This leads to 2 ideas, they are either not changing their membranes when required or they are not flushing properly and build up is occurring. Or they are using the same source water you have and declorinating it and calling it rodi

I know that it comes out of a 300gl or bigger tank. I've seen inside the back room where the whole system is setup & from what I can see it's all piped into 1 tank for saltwater & 1 for Fresh. That's the local Store. I can get my saltwater from another store far enough away that I make a run every other month or so. I just have a gut feeling about the trip store being the better one if you know what I mean.
 
ok thanks for all the info


There are units that will handle both chlorine and chloramine. I think BRS covers that in there RODI video. Takes the need to know what your municipality is using or if they switch.

I also think there is an article here suggesting in adding a second DI stage, The idea is that you'll likely replace the DI once your TDS starts to creep up above 1, but by adding the second stage with a new filter, you extend the life spans. The first filter you were going to throw away now becomes a pre filter reducing some 99% of TDS which the second unit then easily polishes off what got by the older first unit. Once you get TDS, that is when you throw way the first filter and move the second filter in it's place adding a new filter in the now open second unit. This will greatly extend the DI usable life span making up for the original extra cost. If that sounds interesting, then an expandable unit will make more sense, as you can add the second DI stage when the initial DI starts letting TDS get by.


EDIT: here is the article - does a better job explaining it that I did

https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/are-you-throwing-away-perfectly-good-di-resin.516/
 
RO/DI Cal is like 200. Tap Water TDS = 58
This leads to 2 ideas, they are either not changing their membranes when required or they are not flushing properly and build up is occurring. Or they are using the same source water you have and declorinating it and calling it rodi

Just realize if you buy livestock from them, that unpure water is likely what they use in their own systems.
 
Just save up your pennies and get an RO unit. Any one will work and almost every single part is universal so expanding or improving it down the road is a piece of cake. I wouldn’t even mess with a DI unit at this point to keep the price down. Easy to add on later. Also don’t forget, you don’t need an aquarium specific RO unit, they’re all the same. Check eBay or Amazon and compare to the other reefing sites, I’ll bet you save a big chunk. As for salt, I’m probably opening Pandora’s box here but I’ve been in the aquarium game for 30 years, 16 of them salt and I simply use whatever salt is on sale. I have used them all and can’t notice any difference at all other than the $$$$. Last batch I got was Kent brand for 34$ for a 200 gallon box with free shipping from DFS. You can’t go wrong with that. I would seriously think twice about all these fancy tests, total up their costs and compare it to a bucket of salt and an RO unit. You already know the water is out of whack, the minutiae of it isn’t going to solve your problem. Good quality water is, for sure!
 
There are units that will handle both chlorine and chloramine. I think BRS covers that in there RODI video. Takes the need to know what your municipality is using or if they switch.

I also think there is an article here suggesting in adding a second DI stage, The idea is that you'll likely replace the DI once your TDS starts to creep up above 1, but by adding the second stage with a new filter, you extend the life spans. The first filter you were going to throw away now becomes a pre filter reducing some 99% of TDS which the second unit then easily polishes off what got by the older first unit. Once you get TDS, that is when you throw way the first filter and move the second filter in it's place adding a new filter in the now open second unit. This will greatly extend the DI usable life span making up for the original extra cost. If that sounds interesting, then an expandable unit will make more sense, as you can add the second DI stage when the initial DI starts letting TDS get by.


EDIT: here is the article - does a better job explaining it that I did

https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/are-you-throwing-away-perfectly-good-di-resin.516/

Thanks for the info
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top