I voted patience, testing and experience. I was tempted to pick knowledge over experience, but I believe that some mistakes, mishaps and conundrums need to be actively problem solved and not just read about beforehand. Knowledge is power in any hobby requiring the care of sensitive animals, but the experienced application of that knowledge is what gets the results.
And patience and testing. Patience is probably #1...so many mistakes and unnecessary deaths can be avoided by being patient, waiting to add a coral at the right time, giving a frag the chance to encrust or adapt to parameters and your biome, salinity and nutrients. Can I honestly care for an acro right now? Should I move that torch or wait to see if it's just a minor irritation? Are you ok with changing parameters slower thab you'd like? The ocean fluctuates in nature but by and large stays within a very set range. Changing that dynamic in a large way in a short time is a bad idea with slow, finicky animals like coral. A lot of coral grows slower than the average plant...meaning sudden changes will shock and ultimately stress your animals.
Finally, regardless of where you fall on the scale of the importance of various trace elements, nutrients and the important macro parameters, you need to at least be aware of where your tank is at on a semi-regular basis. Testing is important if only to ensure you are staying within a stable range, whether it be automated or manually done. Some parameters, when out of whack and unmonitored, can do catastrophic damage in a relatively short time. Can you imagine keeping a high end sps colony without monitoring your alk? It would be unnecessarily difficult and likely impossible without some monitoring, testing, and routine.
I also think it's important to not overreact to testing. This ties into patience and experience. A newer reefer might see high phosphates and panic, whereas an experienced reefer may know the reason why, or have a plan of attack that is measured, safe and effective from previous experience and not let that make them do something rash.