What's the best Salinity checker?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bam123
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Ecotech Marine
Jump to Last
Looking to add a comparator to my Milwaukee digital. Would it make sense to go with the Vee Gee as a manual checker? Otherwise the pinpoint salinity monitor looks intriguing just to keep on the side of my stand. Of course wouldn't be checking my new saltwater with that.
 
Ecoscape Reef Rock
t5Nitro said:
Looking to add a comparator to my Milwaukee digital. Would it make sense to go with the Vee Gee as a manual checker? Otherwise the pinpoint salinity monitor looks intriguing just to keep on the side of my stand. Of course wouldn't be checking my new saltwater with that.
Click to expand...
I am a huge VeeGee fan. I have two. Yes, they are overpriced but this is such a fundamental piece of equipment to the hobby IMO. Rarely needs recalibration.
 
ScottB said:
I am a huge VeeGee fan. I have two. Yes, they are overpriced but this is such a fundamental piece of equipment to the hobby IMO. Rarely needs recalibration.
Click to expand...
Seems the most reasonable as I already have a digital Milwaukee. I almost would rather somehow sell and trade the Milwaukee for the pinpoint salinity monitor for my tank, and then have the manual vee gee for new saltwater and periodic tank checks. I don't have anything to compare my Milwaukee to though to see if mine is actually off. The Milwaukee I check 3x in a row and the numbers are usually the same, if anything it'll read low on the first measure and then consistent the next few times.
 
Deltec
As an eBay Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an eBay Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
BRS
Hanna pen. Easiest to use by far. I know how many scoops make 1.025 for my mix water so if the hanna looks off I calibrate it. It floats and has temp too. I take it fishing some times and log temp and salinity in good fishing holes
 
I have many devices. I have a sybon refractometer which ive never had a problem with. I also have the tropic marine floating hydrometer which is great but annoying to use. 2 different swing arm hydrometers which i dont trust, the milwalkee digital refractometer which is not accurate enough imo. I also have a 40 year old hach conductivity meter but it doesn't read high enough to measure seawater but works great. Ive had the pinpoint salinity meter which feels cheap. My next investment is a scientific conductivity meter that can read 53 Ms/c.
 
Top Shelf Aquatics
yongwooi said:
Go with Hanna salinity checker. You will love it
Click to expand...
I heard the Hanna salinity checker has to be calibrated every time before use. Do you calibrate it each time before use or does it hold the calibration?
 
t5Nitro said:
Seems the most reasonable as I already have a digital Milwaukee. I almost would rather somehow sell and trade the Milwaukee for the pinpoint salinity monitor for my tank, and then have the manual vee gee for new saltwater and periodic tank checks. I don't have anything to compare my Milwaukee to though to see if mine is actually off. The Milwaukee I check 3x in a row and the numbers are usually the same, if anything it'll read low on the first measure and then consistent the next few times.
Click to expand...
Why can't the Pinpoint Salinity Monitor be used on new saltwater? Looking to buy a salinity checker and almost pulled the trigger on this until I saw this thread. Twice I heard you can't use this on new salt mixtures.
 
Avast
I think consistency is more important than accuracy unless your operating at the limits of salinity range. I could be wrong, but is there anything that will not do well in a reef tank just the same with a salinity of say 1.024 vs 1.026 so long as you are consistent? Even the lowest end refractometer will accurately match one salinity to another.
 
gerajn01 said:
Why can't the Pinpoint Salinity Monitor be used on new saltwater? Looking to buy a salinity checker and almost pulled the trigger on this until I saw this thread. Twice I heard you can't use this on new salt mixtures.
Click to expand...

Not sure what you mean by "pinpoint checker"? If you are referring to the Hanna conductivity checker, it can be used on new and tank salt water, but you need to keep it calibrated or it will give a wrong reading.
 
BRS
Gablami said:
It’s hard to find a refractometer that takes accuracy to a 4th decimal point. Some might feel like there’s a big enough difference between 1.0269 and 1.0260. Aim small miss small.

But that said, I also think the pinpoint salinity probe is awesome. It worked really well for me. And when the switch got finicky, the company replaced the entire device for me without issues.

I think it’s good to have two different methods to check salinity. Conductivity and refractometer, just to double check each other. If you have redundancy, you don’t need to get the most expensive model (kind of like dual return pumps).
Click to expand...
This is a good point. But - one problem is if you have '2' - and they are disparate how do you know which one to trust? I.e. - you need 3 measurements. Is there really a proven benefit to measuring salinity to 4 digits? Is it possible to keep salinity to such a tight range? To me - the best way to check your meters (of any kind) - is a known reference solution.

For example in my tank - I know how much salt I need to add to my Brute can to get a specific gravity of 1.026. So - I add the same amount of salt each time. If it is 1.025 vs 1.026 - I don't care. I'm only changing a slight amount of water - so I personally don't care. I guess I'm curious how 'off' the OP's refractometer is. I have never had to adjust mine. I remember a thread - where someone mentioned that if the hinge on the refractometer is dirty/corroded (not oiled) - that it will give disparate results. I make sure my glass piece moves freely each time.
 
AI Nero 5

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%

  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%

  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%

  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
See comments…

New Posts

Dinkins Aquatic Gardens
TCK Corals
Top Shelf Aquatics
Tidal Gardens
Deltec
Chewy.com
World Wide Corals
Nutramar Foods
New Posts
Back
Top