Which do you prefer, bare bottom, sand bed, or deep sand bed?

  • Thread starter Thread starter skinz78
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Which do you prefer, bare bottom, shallow sand bed, or deep sand bed?

  • bare bottom

    Votes: 45 28.1%
  • shallow sand bed

    Votes: 82 51.3%
  • deep sand bed

    Votes: 33 20.6%

  • Total voters
    160
Very interesting thread. I had never thought about have my fuge bb, but think I might go that way in the next build. Also might try out the 1/2-3/4" thick bed so that I can siphon clean during WC and still have the look of sand, which I prefer to the bb. The only bb tank I have ever seen that I really liked had the entire bottom COVERED in ricoridas. It was really cool, but I guess that technically isn't "bare bottom" :)
 
i want to try bare bottom but smear a little silicone on the bottom and put sand on it, anyone done this?

My old friend did this. Some where there is a DIY on it, I dont even member what site it was on. He put sand in a bucket added clear silicone and had a cement mixer and then put it on the bottom. I was torn it looked semi ok IMO. He did have to do it twice because the first time he added to much silicone and it looked like crap.
 
Shallow sandbed with the option of a remote deep bed somewhere else. I just am not a fan of barebottom tanks. The sand makes it look so much more natural.
 
BB looks too unnatural and sterile. Good for a frag tank but for a reed I enjoy the full experience. Such as Amano style reefs. Also gives me the chance to deal with a variety of animals and organisms that inhabit the sand (creating various depths of sand for different species.)
 
All have their place.

I had a BB system that I loved. I like the look of a sand bed in general, and a shallow sand bed better than a DSB but it depends on the direction of the system.

I'm not putting sand sifting Gobys in a BB tank. I'm not putting a Haddons anemone in a BB tank (again) but it can be done. I'm not keeping sand in a really high flow tank (60-70 turnovers per hr) because it tends to get blown off the bottom, bury corals, and get in my hardware.

I've become a fan of biotope tanks and try to design the system around the types of inhabitants I plan to keep.
 
All 3 of my tanks have a 2-3 inch sandbed; one tank has an S. haddoni, the other has an M. doreensis (( both are sandbed dwelling anemones )) and the 3rd tank has a shrimp/goby pair.
 
I run sand in the front, and BB in the back. Party up front, all business in the rear. Looks kind of funny but it works for me. I couldnt imagine servicing a sand bed in the back of my tank.
 
I run sand in the front, and BB in the back. Party up front, all business in the rear. Looks kind of funny but it works for me. I couldnt imagine servicing a sand bed in the back of my tank.

+1-I've been doing that too and it works great. Just stay away from cucumbers as they'll move the sand to the back of the tank.
 
I run sand in the front, and BB in the back. Party up front, all business in the rear. Looks kind of funny but it works for me. I couldnt imagine servicing a sand bed in the back of my tank.

Ahh good idea, I'll have to try that on the next tank I set up!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top