Which one is a better light?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Doop
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Doop

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
43
Reaction score
17
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
02be594f46d51cc2b36134aa640cd7e4.jpg
747a0d4d5d15510ac51863b67c86bd47.jpg

I’m starting out on a budget and am trying to get a light that will work for some soft corals and in the future a bta. I have a 46 gallon that is 36” long 18” deep and 15” across. I purchased a ro/di to start with clean water and now I’m looking for a light in that price range. When I am more knowledgeable with the reef I will upgrade and buy bigger and better, but for now I’m just learning this hobby and need some help. Thank you in advance for your opinions! [emoji245]
 
What do you plan on having in the system?
 
I like the viparspectra better in that range. You maybe able to get a used ocean revive t247 light right here on REEF2REEF for the same price
 
I'd go with the first one.

The current lights are good on shallow tanks, but 18in deep they barely grew anything in my 29g. I had two of them running on the tank.

You may want to check out a cheap t5 fixture, maybe one for plants. Shouldn't run you more then 60-70 for the fixture, then swap out the bulbs.
 
The new current models are better--the ic pro's. I just got the 72" marine ic pro dual. Nothing live in the tank as of yet though. I have a black box on my display refugium. Can only turn on or off and dim. I wanted more with my new tank so went with the latest currents for price and function. We'll see how they do. I have 18" deep.

orbit-marine-chart.png
 
Sure wish lighting was NOT so expensive! I had a choice of 3 or 4 of the black boxes (6' tank) or 2 of the 72" lights. 3 black boxes would be over 300 bucks. 2 currents were 500. Add another 3x45 for the brackets (wide rim tank) and that added up. 1 of the sb lights would have been 500 and I'd need 2. It was a real dilemma when on a budget!
 
I think first choice will be better, I have a orbit ic led on a 55 gallon and I feel I need two(2) to have sufficient light. It's very focused. If I put the light in the middle it doesn't light up the upper 1/3 of the tank. JMO however the light is very easy to program and has cool features. Wouldn't bother with using their pumps either For the price
 
Sure wish lighting was NOT so expensive! I had a choice of 3 or 4 of the black boxes (6' tank) or 2 of the 72" lights. 3 black boxes would be over 300 bucks. 2 currents were 500. Add another 3x45 for the brackets (wide rim tank) and that added up. 1 of the sb lights would have been 500 and I'd need 2. It was a real dilemma when on a budget!

No kidding! A lfs has a bunch of the viparspectra light hanging everywhere and says there the an awesome light for the price. I will say his tanks were full and beautiful. I am looking for a direction to go and it’s a tough decision.
 
Keeping reef aquariums is not a cheap hobby...

With that said, it can be done on a budget. Honestly, if that's the price range you're stuck with i think you're doing yourself a disservice by looking at led fixtures. Sure, those "black boxes" can grow corals, but the disco effect will be ugly and the fixture will leave a lot to be desired. You'd be much better off finding a nice 4 bulb t5 fixture, or mh pendant. These 2 types of lighting have proven themselves for decades and will grow anything you want.
 
@Mccool You are prob. right except those fixtures need either a canopy or to be hung and we have high ceilings, though they are the lowest over the tank. Hubby didn't want to hang from ceiling (at least 6 feet higher than tank if not more). Down the road, we can look into canopies. The canopy that goes with our stand was over 300 bucks. Stand was just over 400. The other consideration is the heat from other types of bulbs. I live in central ca where we are in triple digits for the summer and I don't have a chiller. That was part of my decision equation. And the cost of replacing t5's every 8-12 months. Expensive enough on my 36" AIO. Would be a whole lot more on the 6' tank.

My plan is to see what I end up with for this first year and then decide if we want to change things out. I will say hubby not a fan of the shimmer yet on the internet, people seem to be seeking high shimmer (mimickign natural sunlight). he'd like to send these back, but this is what I can afford right now.

So much goes into not just lighting, but the total set up. At least lighting you can upgrade. I plan to start with easy softies and lps and go from there. Bet I can add to the lighting as well like a 3rd if I can get hold of the brackets.

@Doop figure out what is important to you now and down the road, budget now and later, and just keep researching and finding what is important to you. So much great advice out there and people make good points.
 
Keeping reef aquariums is not a cheap hobby...

With that said, it can be done on a budget. Honestly, if that's the price range you're stuck with i think you're doing yourself a disservice by looking at led fixtures. Sure, those "black boxes" can grow corals, but the disco effect will be ugly and the fixture will leave a lot to be desired. You'd be much better off finding a nice 4 bulb t5 fixture, or mh pendant. These 2 types of lighting have proven themselves for decades and will grow anything you want.

I agree it’s not a cheap hobby and I have no intention on being “cheap” I am just starting out and am buying everything at once and upgrading as I go along. I hear about t5 lighting all the time but I don’t know where to buy the 4 bulb fixture and bulbs, or even what bulbs for that matter. Are these fixture just an on and off or is there a ramp timer? I google t5 fixture and Home Depot shows up with them. Are all fixtures the same just need certain watt bulbs?
 
I know on my t5's there is no ramp. There is on and off on a timer. I have moonlight as there are a couple rows of blue led's in the hood. There are various bulb choices out there and doing a mix of white, blue, acintic (??) blues, pink, purple. You can do a search on amazon for t5 coral bulbs under pet supplies to get an idea. Also check with various online vendors like brs, marine depot, etc. as they offer various lighting choices and you can see the fixtures. Better than the regular home depot fixtures.
 
You need a t5HO (high output) fixture to run the reef style bulbs. If it's HO your good
 
Susan, you are right. A lot of the MH and T5 fixtures require either a canopy or ceiling mounting. In the past you could buy a number of fixtures that would sit on the tank with mounting feet, but since led's came along the choices have dwindled. But look in the for sale section here or elsewhere, I see nice fixtures sell for super cheap now that people are migrating to led.

Doop, home depot actually does sell the t5ho lights now. Their bulbs won't work very well but if you have a canopy, I suppose the fixture would work fine. I'd suggest looking for a saltwater specific used fixture though. 24" bulbs will be 24 watts and 36" will be 39 watts, no way to change that really. They don't ramp up and down like led's, but you'll be able to control 2 bulbs separately from the other 2 to create a bit of a sunrise/sunset effect.

Best of luck
 
Whatever direction you go, try to find something modular that you can build off of instead of replacing (and wasting money) if and when you upgrade or make changes. Something like the Kessil A160WE or AI Prime are smaller, less expensive, form factors that can work really well. You can start with a couple and integrate more as you go without the need to purchase a completely new fixture. You could also go with the Kessil A360WE, Radion XR15, or AI Hydra 26 if you were willing to increase the budget (and a better choice if you think a larger tank is in your near future). The various black boxes are a good alternative if the others are out of your price range but aesthetically, they look like cheap lights if you don't have a canopy (I had SBReef Basic Boxes and their fixture leaves a lot to be desired in the looks department but you get a decent light for the money).

Alternatively, the T5s are just workhorses and it looks like the bulbs are lasting a lot longer than most of us believed was true. BRS recently did a video that demonstrated they provide adequate intensity and spectrum beyond 12 months (simulated eight hour photo-periods) and are continuing to run them to see just how long they will last (two years doesnt look to be out of question).
 
Last edited:
Whatever direction you go, try to find something modular that you can build off of instead of replacing (and wasting) money if and when you upgrade or make changes. Something like the Kessil A160WE or AI Prime are smaller, less expensive, form factors that can work really well. You can start with a couple and integrate more as you go without the need to purchase a completely new fixture. You could also go with the Kessil A360WE, Radion XR15, or AI Hydra 26 if you were willing to increase the budget (and a better choice if you think a larger tank is in your near future). The various black boxes are a good alternative if the others are out of your price range but aesthetically, they look like cheap lights if you don't have a canopy (I had SBReef Basic Boxes and their fixture leaves a lot to be desired in the looks department but you get a decent light for the money).

Alternatively, the T5s are just workhorses and it looks like the bulbs are lasting a lot longer than most of us believed was true. BRS recently did a video that demonstrated they provide adequate intensity and spectrum beyond 12 months (simulated eight hour photo-periods) and are continuing to run them to see just how long they will last (two years doesnt look to be out of question).

I agree with all of this, but I've never seen any of those lights in the price range the OP is in. Maybe a prime, but with the mount it will probably be closer to $175. And it will only light half of tank, best case.

I also agree with the t5 comment. Changing bulbs every 6-8 months is a complete waste of money. When I had t5's, i changed every 18 months without issue.
 
T5's require bulb replacement. Depending on budgets that is something which is overlooked. Something to consider never the less. LED's on the other hand you have choices. Sounds like you know what you want to keep so I would suggest looking at buying used. You can buy some higher quality units that people are selling because they are upgrading to the latest gen of existing or completely changing them out. You may spend a bit more than what you are looking at but you get a higher quality product.

You can also examine what you listed, shop around a bit more, and see what else is offered or in the range and buy that. Or, if you have any basic DIY skills you can build your own. Some will question the cost savings but there are enough high quality LED or multi channel chips for 50 bucks it is a valid route to go down. Just depends on how you value your time, your skills, and goals.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top