Why are all my hammer corals bailing out

  • Thread starter Thread starter MoH
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Hi there.
I have taken care of various Euphelia (Hammers, Torches, Frogspawns, Octospawns, etc) over the years, and it alway baffles me when any do a bailout.
What I mean is there could be a dozen doing well and for some unknown reason one decides to bail.
In my expereince once bailing out starts there is nothing to stop it at the head level.
If your hammer is a branching type, one head may bail while the rest do well.

They will adapt to pretty well any Nitrate or Phophate Level. Better higher than too low.
I've had successful thriving, growing Euphelia in Nitrate as high as 30+ and Phosphates close to 0.4+ppm.

Salinity Swings are also bad. Salinity too low or high isn't good either. Get into range 1.025-1.027 slowly.

Most important other than treating for bacteria if you suspect that, is keep things Stable. Flow and lighting on the Lower side.
I've saved a not healthy Euphelia dipping in Proper Concentration of API Melafix. Not sure if the Melafix did it or just the fact that I removed the coral and rinsed it (then put back right away)

AGAIN!! Keep things as stable as posible and don't chase some number a person throw out.
Check you Alk, Calcium, and Magnesium levels to ensure in range.
A reasonable extra 10%-20% water change can't hurt since that will bring up your trace elements.

If folks say Chemi Clean helps, well I actually did that recently. This week (for a minor Cyano annoyance) and it certainly cleared up water, and Eurphelia did perk up as well. Lower lighting during chemiclean treatment since water will clear up so lighting will penetrate water more.
 
Last edited:
I had this happen with my hammer and nothing else was affected. I eventually lost the head but after about a week I could see new growth in the skeleton and it eventually grew back bigger than it was before. Never did figure out what was wrong with it but fortunately it hasn’t done it again.
 
The only time I've had this happen I lost head after head of frogspawn and the only remedy was cutting off a head that looked iffy as soon as it looked a little like it might have an issue. I went from about 25 heads to about 10 but with aggressively cutting them out and tossing them I saved almost half of the colony and no other euphyllia ever had any issues. I'm no expert, but with euphyllia I don't try to save them, I try to keep the others healthy by chucking the ones that are sick.
 
I am going through this same thing right now. Just posted very similar experience here.


I am wondering if any of your corals were new. I have been battling this for like 2 weeks or so. I need to get some cipro.
 
I believe the cause of my bailout was high nitrates. Tank was doing great for about one year and I had stopped testing thinking the tank was on auto pilot and all would continue to go well. Bailout started with Duncans, hammers and Torch. I tested Nitrates and they had climbed to over 80. I did a good cleaning which included blowing off and under rocks. Then a 40% water change two weekends in a row. (Big change is better then many small ones) No more losses after that. I left the “dead” skeletons in the tank and was surprised that the hammers grew new heads.
 

Attachments

  • A4CA2D5C-862C-49E5-916B-C2CD2E6840F9.jpeg
    A4CA2D5C-862C-49E5-916B-C2CD2E6840F9.jpeg
    249.6 KB · Views: 68
  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    220 KB · Views: 62
I believe the cause of my bailout was high nitrates. Tank was doing great for about one year and I had stopped testing thinking the tank was on auto pilot and all would continue to go well. Bailout started with Duncans, hammers and Torch. I tested Nitrates and they had climbed to over 80. I did a good cleaning which included blowing off and under rocks. Then a 40% water change two weekends in a row. (Big change is better then many small ones) No more losses after that. I left the “dead” skeletons in the tank and was surprised that the hammers grew new heads.
Glad to hear you were able to recover, my nitrates are at 10, but I can't keep any phosphates. I don't see Brown Jelly, but sure seems like what others are experiencing.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top