Thanks for the input Trex, I appreciate your upfront honesty. Unfortunately the BTA is from LiveAquaria, so no returns there (even if I could find him, which I can't at the moment; he's only 1 1/2" across, super tiny). Not sure about the LFS I got the LTA from, but I'd rather not give up so easily. I shall consider myself warned however, and you are welcome to say I told you so if it doesn't work out

. What is it about a 1 year old tank that's different from a 2 month old tank (mine is 2 months, not 1, though I doubt that matters a whole lot in your assessment)? Since the LTA is not a coraline algae grazer I figured the only difference must be in tank parameter stability, which can be fixed with careful monitoring and frequent water changes, no?
Anyway, to answer your questions, I am not sure what light the LTA was under when I bought him (2 weeks ago), it was fairly bright, but he was hiding in a flower pot when I bought him so maybe this particular specimen just likes caves?
Water parameters, as measured with a CoraLife Hydrometer and API ReefMaster Test Kit:
T: 75 deg F
Sg: 1.0235
Calcium: 420 ppm
dkH: 11
pH: 8.2
Nitrates: 10 ppm
Phosphates: 0
I know nitrates are supposed to be as low as possible for anemones and I'm going to do a few partial water changes tomorrow to lower it. I am willing to invest in some absorbing filters or a macroalgae refugium if needed to keep them low. For now I think my earlier overfeeding may be to blame and I want to see how my levels do after scaling way back on the fish food

.
This morning I removed all the rubble and shells in the vicinity of the LTA, so we'll see if he likes it more now. FYI the sand goes below the level of visibility in the tank and I estimate it to be about 2" deep. I can pick up some more sand from the LFS today if you think it still needs to be deeper.