Why don't most aquarium setups have a canopy/lid?

CustomAquariums makes canopies for their tanks, open top so they don’t retain heat/moisture. I am awaiting my tank stand canopy order from them. I wanted a canopy because my tank is in my office and the light spill/glare bothers me when I’m working
 
Evaporation is good thing.

Yes, you need to top off, but, small sacrifice, great benefit.
I've been trying to limit evaporation so I don't have to top off as much (small tank with no auto top off).
What's the benefit of more evaporation?
 
I've been trying to limit evaporation so I don't have to top off as much (small tank with no auto top off).
What's the benefit of more evaporation?
Greater gas exchange, evaporative cooling, and if you are like me and use kalk it means you can dose more kalk.
 
Because my wife said stop bringing that dam ladder in the house. And she also noticed a slight rise when I ran a chiller. Whoops
 
Hello everyone!

I'm new to this hobby and have been reading up heavily. I have a while to go before committing but I have one question: why don't most reef setups have a canopy or lid, with lights integrated? It seems like it would solve the evaporation issue especially in dry heated homes, and also prevent something from falling into the tank. For example, I'm leaning towards Cade Reef 1200 S2 as my first tank and surprised to find that outside of third party lids, there seem to be not many options.
Its a matter of tank design and preference. Other than a dropoff tank I had and a 93g cube- Every tank ive had had a canopy including current one. Ive Never had problems with access or maintenance or adding and removing coral. Maintenance will be how hard You make it with a canopy.

1675901851227.png
 
Its a matter of tank design and preference. Other than a dropoff tank I had and a 93g cube- Every tank ive had had a canopy including current one. Ive Never had problems with access or maintenance or adding and removing coral. Maintenance will be how hard You make it with a canopy.

1675901851227.png
That is a beautiful set up!!!
 
It's due to the modern LED lighting that has taken hold in the hobby over the last 10 years. Before LED lights were a thing most Reef systems did indeed have a canopy or lid. The hobby follows trends and the manufacturers have pushed led lights relentlessly even though older forms of lighting were generally better for your corals.

I too would much rather have a tank with a sealed lid but getting enough light for SPS corals was preventing me from going that route. But if your only want to grow soft corals and lps a freshwater tank with T5 fluorescents under the hood, converted to have a sump would work just fine. My next tank will likely be a converted Juwel rio 450, not sure if you can get those in the USA though.

juwel.jpg
Ten years ago there is no way I would have a canopy. MH, t-5’s or PC put out way too much heat, so unless you ran a chiller, evaporation was the main cooling method.
 
I use light diffuser panels, no jumpers here.
Custom made or purchased somewhere? I have had too many losses to the magic carpet ride and have decided I need to add something. My issue is, my setup and what is hanging on the back is different than the next person's. That is why I am asking if you made it or bought it somewhere? Any info is appreciated
 
Floating canopys look really clean and reduce light spill. I love them!

But I would never use something to decrease gas exchange like a glass lid or fully enclosed thing. Plus LED's need good air flow. However you can have a non floating one that still has good air flow and so on... and some people have those too. They are just more custom.

Most tanks that are packages (red sea, IM, CADE, waterbox, etc) are rimless hence they don't bother with canopy's.
 
Evaporation is good thing.

Yes, you need to top off, but, small sacrifice, great benefit.
Curious, is that because it's a faster way to regulate the conditions in the water tank? If the home has low humidity (typical of northern locations during winter) the evaporative loss to the ambient has minimal effect on tank conditions, no?
Ten years ago there is no way I would have a canopy. MH, t-5’s or PC put out way too much heat, so unless you ran a chiller, evaporation was the main cooling method.
Yeah, especially now with high efficiency DC pumps and LED lighting heat input may primarily come from the ambient. I can do some calcs but a typical DC pumps barely raises the heat input (0.5F per hour of operation) which would be balanced out by the ambient room temperature.
 
For me it's the Wife Approval Factor. A nice stand and canopy that matches the furniture in the living room was a great selling point. Stand and canopy contain almost all sound from the tank. A 9" canopy let's me reach the sandbed. Computer fans ventilate the canopy.
 
I have a mesh top (DD diy kit wasn’t that hard to build) for one reason. Flying fish. We have 4xXR15 and I added the diffusers around a month ago - they reduce the light spill nicely. We did toy with the idea of an hood but decided against it. It’s a nice clean setup. The black mesh top is invisible from a seated position as it is recessed down slightly and the frame sits flat on the edge glass. It’s very low profile and does the job nicely. Not too pricy either.
 
Purchased from Lowe’s, easy to cut with a fine blade jigsaw around any opening.

20230208_221750.jpg


20230208_221756.jpg
Unless there's some kind of screen I can't see it seem like light diffuser wouldn't work for small fish. Also being a "light diffuser it will block any light coming in at an angle.
 
Years ago I had a hood with MH lights. Access was difficult. Had to buy an expensive and energy wasting chiller. Didn't get enough evaporation for my kalkwasser top off water to keep alkalinity up. I do like the look of many hoods but some just make it all look too massive for my taste. Don't really like the light fixtures exposed so I did mine as pictured.
 

Attachments

  • CEB6DE8D-6E1B-4E08-BAF8-CA84ACAB790A.jpeg
    CEB6DE8D-6E1B-4E08-BAF8-CA84ACAB790A.jpeg
    165.9 KB · Views: 60
I want to put meshtop.

My tank's top is 8 ft by 2 ft in 3 equal parts (2 cross braces) but inner exact dimensions will be smaller ...

Any recommendations for buying (or DIY) mesh top? What vendors or places to buy ready made or DIY materials?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top