Why in the world will my nitrates not go down?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nymz
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Nymz

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 30, 2016
Messages
38
Reaction score
29
Location
Clearwater, FL
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I’ve had nitrates around the 50ppm range for a few weeks and despite weekly 25% WCs, it’s still at 50. I did a water change today and tested it with a Salifert kit a few hours later… 50ppm. An API nitrate test kit is also showing them around that range also. Phosphates are hardly detectable

Setup is in my signature. I have no fish. I have 6 Trochus snails and 1 blue leg hermit. I have an RODI unit with fresh filters that reads 2ppm before DI and 0ppm after DI. I tested the nitrates of the DI water and its zero. I use regular purple bag IO salt but I dose the new water’s calcium up to 450 each time with Brightwell Calcion.

I half dose my tank with Red Sea AB+ about once a week. I dose Brightwell Phytochrom 1-2x a week. I feed my Blasto frag and new Fungia a little sliver of frozen mysis with a tinyyy amount of Reef Chili 1-2x a week (thawed and then spot fed).

It’s a softie dominated tank. Leathers, zoas and palys, gorgonians and some gracillaria in the display.

Could it be the phyto? Or the small amount I spot feed? I’m at a loss. With that said, would a 50% WC be pushing it? Aside from setting up some kind of refugium I don’t know what to do to bring the levels down.

8990841B-9E9F-411F-8B5E-00066180363E.jpeg
 
If it were my tank, I’d get some fish in there and feed them. I wouldn’t add anything else to the tank other than calcium and alkalinity supplements as needed. 10% water changes per week. Then test nitrates and phosphates once a month and watch the trend. The Hanna HR nitrate checker will help with that.

The 50 nitrates number doesn’t bother me but it also doesn’t make sense that it doesn’t come down with water changes. Hence the Hanna recco.
 
that tank needs to have phosphate and nitrate testing ceased for six months straight if not permanently, only begin that testing once you buy hanna digital gear for both params and once you hit coral growth issues

don't try and head off expected algae/uglies with test kit guess and response/said that because nitrate brand test kit comparison threads show a given sample testing up to 100ppm different on other kits, 3 kits testing the same sample rarely aligns. there's a very very very low chance that's your actual reading, it could be 100 or zero but nitrate isn't impactful. nano reefs are best managed with simple direct cleaning to beat uglies, quality feeding and water changes any % you want

I change 100% weekly for going on two decades, there isn't too much % chance. if you focus on keeping that sandbed clean and the system fed well, and rocks scraped off and cleaned externally when algae comes since that's not coralline live rock, you'll grow those corals into antlers. testing guessing and responding with nitrate and po4 this early gets you starved corals, algae and dinos


fight the urge to test, guide the nano in the macro sense doing core exercises vs hyperfocus on any param. I could antler out those corals in two years only knowing salinity and temp and you can bet not one invasion would ever be present in any pics. you can do that too, change up your reef plan.
 
in a tank that new you want the nitrate to land wherever it lands, and do not mess with it/same for phosphate.

nitrate testing and guess response is this decade's go-to unnecessary action. its causing massive dinos invasions and massive GHA/cyano invasions across the board/recommend you focus on clean food in/export/water changes and external rock cleaning for the win. the largest spread I saw in a common nitrate test kit comparison post was 100 ppm difference from two kits off one water sample...total horse shoeing

my nano reef is 17 years old this month and Ive only known temp and salinity the whole time. now in all fairness after seventeen years in a vase my blastomussa merletti got a weak skeleton and the base broke apart, and it wouldnt have done that in a perfectly alk-controlled large setup with skimming/nice low CO2 incoming air/but that's my price to pay and not once was dinos, algae, or cyano a headache and neither is coral polyp color or growth. only that one coral broke down due to the years I got lazy on changing water and the acids ate it up lol. that was an extended, long term consequence of not focusing on params and I'd prefer that to today's wrecked tank invasions any day of the week



thats handy to know about reduction options but it assumes you have the right starting levels known, and in today's testing environ I can't be sure of that part
 
Last edited:
I would have added fish by now but this month and especially next month are a whirlwind for me. I get married on Jan 14th and will be gone for a week on my honeymoon, I didn’t want to have a QT set up and new fish in a tank when I’m gone for that long.

As for testing, today I waited about 4 hours after the WC.

Honestly I wouldn’t normally worry about the nitrates but some of my coral just don’t look great right now, particularly the fungia and ironically, the Xenia which is just disappearing more and more daily. Some look fine and are growing. But I’m mostly worried about that plate, the Koji Woda nepthea and my Cristata torch. I’ve hundreds wrapped up in those guys and don’t want anything to happen to them, lol.
 
the first thing you should do is physical, not chemical, lower your light intensity down 20% and sustain that for a month before making any changes, your feeding plan is good

we always aim for brightest lights we like to see, corals do well in far more subdued lighting and they bleach less that way.


make sure you aren't running whites, those can lighten and bleach out some new corals before they get going, do blues/people run windex blue on reefs for a reason

go this 10K look if your corals seem fine/it's easier to see for sure but if you think they're lightening you need blues not whites in the led combo and reduce overall power 20% and hold. increase feed, increase export % changed each week and sustain that two months then reevaluate.

any action you take needs to be physical and something that doesnt harm a full running reef not showing any issues.


lighting modulation down and blues/no whites harms no reef at all

increased feed and water change frequency, work and calories burned on your part, repeat work importing and exporting for weeks / won't hurt any running tank in fact that's how we boost up coral health for a photo shoot on a magazine run when offered. its like an exercise program


do the reverse of sedentary if you want + coral mass. its not chemistry its physical, because that reef is small enough you can control all the water column with changes. if it was 600 gallons and you couldnt easily do stepped up work, you could try chemical boosting/balancing of what's dissolved in the water.
 
some fish nitrogen will help, you got a couple clowns or something you can add?
 
Seeing as parameters are not changing after water changes with new water . 2 things come to mind
1) either a faulty test kit
2) high nitrates in the water source
No matter what you try . If the source water is 0ppm nitrates changing 25% of the water will decrease nitrates by maximum 25%

The solution to pollution is dilution ….
 
It’s a bit puzzling, but here is my take. It looks like a small tank without a sump and no skimmer I suppose. Is it internal filter in right corner? If so do you have any media there?
You are basically adding nutrients with all your supplements and feeding, but it seems to me that you don’t have well established method to export them. Tank seem to be sparsely populated and your coral is probably not absorbing all the nutrients, so they are decomposed by bacteria to Nitrates and you don’t have enough denitrifying bacteria yet to convert it to nitrogen.
I would hold on supplements and feeding and if possible add skimmer. Internal filters are often also Nitrate factory if you don’t change media often.
Refugium is better suited to decrease phosphates rather then nitrates.
 
the first thing you should do is physical, not chemical, lower your light intensity down 20% and sustain that for a month before making any changes, your feeding plan is good

we always aim for brightest lights we like to see, corals do well in far more subdued lighting and they bleach less that way.

Sure, I can do that. FWIW it’s a Radion Pro Gen 6 with a diffuser. With my current settings, my entire tank sits around 100-120 PAR (measured with an Apogee SQ-420).

It looks like a small tank without a sump and no skimmer I suppose. Is it internal filter in right corner? If so do you have any media there?
You are basically adding nutrients with all your supplements and feeding, but it seems to me that you don’t have well established method to export them. Tank seem to be sparsely populated and your coral is probably not absorbing all the nutrients, so they are decomposed by bacteria to Nitrates and you don’t have enough denitrifying bacteria yet to convert it to nitrogen.
I would hold on supplements and feeding and if possible add skimmer. Internal filters are often also Nitrate factory if you don’t change media often.
Refugium is better suited to decrease phosphates rather then nitrates.

This is right along with my thinking. I have a skimmer I picked out earlier this week but just hadn’t pulled the trigger. I think you just convinced me to pick it up and give it a try. :winking-face:

As for your questions, that’s actually a UV sterilizer. I had some cloudy water problems a few weeks back (pretty sure it was related to me dosing kalk via ATO) and I’ve just been running it since. My back chambers have a filter basket with floss, carbon and filter media. The second chamber has lots of live rock in the remaining space.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top