Actually... related question: could super high mag be p*ssing off my euphyllias? I have other corals that are perfectly happy and growing - acans, mushrooms, monti cap, and more. But my euphyllia have been getting slowly less and less happy over the past few months - both hammer and frogspawn.
Why is my Magnesium over1600?
- Thread starter LardLad
- Start date
- Tagged users None
OP
OP
LardLad
Active Member
- Joined
- Oct 29, 2019
- Messages
- 431
- Reaction score
- 339
- What state or country do you live in
- Kentucky
Particle...great points.
I'm wondering similar things. In fact this is kind of how this all came up. My tank is vibrant and thriving my fish look plump and amazing my clean up crew is Super Active and my corals are fat and sassy....
.... except for I have repeatedly murdered GSP and can't seem to keep it alive. They look great when they come home from the lfs but now are retracted and the tips turn black then die in a couple of weeks. My water params her perfect and stable temp and salinity are perfect. So I was trying to rule out iodine and magnesium when I discovered the problem......
I think I might call Red Sea this week and pick some brains.
I'm wondering similar things. In fact this is kind of how this all came up. My tank is vibrant and thriving my fish look plump and amazing my clean up crew is Super Active and my corals are fat and sassy....
.... except for I have repeatedly murdered GSP and can't seem to keep it alive. They look great when they come home from the lfs but now are retracted and the tips turn black then die in a couple of weeks. My water params her perfect and stable temp and salinity are perfect. So I was trying to rule out iodine and magnesium when I discovered the problem......
I think I might call Red Sea this week and pick some brains.
Greg P
Valuable Member
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2019
- Messages
- 2,038
- Reaction score
- 1,798
- Location
- Burnaby BC
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
1 thing could be how much of your container you are using per mix and how the minerals etc in the container have settled/dispersed after production/during shipping ...
One thing I've learned about ALL salt mixes is that most need to be thoroughly mixed if you're not going to use the whole container in one go. During shipping with vibration and such, heavier stuff can/will settle lower in the bucket/bag. This I've found is evident when the top of a bucket is very powdery.
If you are having inconsistency issues with whatever you use and are not planning on using the whole container in 1 go, roll the bucket for 5 mins to mix it well - do whatever you need to mix well that bag of salt - before you open it.
I've been using IO Regular for over 7 years and, ya, I've had a couple batches that were well over 1600 Mg, but it's not very common. Over 40 buckets used so far and mostly they are within a reasonable range.
One thing I've learned about ALL salt mixes is that most need to be thoroughly mixed if you're not going to use the whole container in one go. During shipping with vibration and such, heavier stuff can/will settle lower in the bucket/bag. This I've found is evident when the top of a bucket is very powdery.
If you are having inconsistency issues with whatever you use and are not planning on using the whole container in 1 go, roll the bucket for 5 mins to mix it well - do whatever you need to mix well that bag of salt - before you open it.
I've been using IO Regular for over 7 years and, ya, I've had a couple batches that were well over 1600 Mg, but it's not very common. Over 40 buckets used so far and mostly they are within a reasonable range.
Greg P
Valuable Member
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2019
- Messages
- 2,038
- Reaction score
- 1,798
- Location
- Burnaby BC
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
You're welcome.
My tank has a large amount of SPS, so I test my newly mixed salt water before adding to my tank. I prefer to know what swings will happen ahead of time and deal with them accordingly.
FYI, high Mag is not a big issue. If you have corals, it will 'eventually' drop on it's own.
If you really want to drop it with water changes, consider a bucket of Red Sea Blue Bucket.
Params are listed on the bucket.
Take the frustratingly inconvenient bag out of the bucket, open it into the bucket, and roll it around the floor to mix it well before use. Or try to mix the bag somehow without opening it.
Be aware the lid has no gasket so it will most likely leak on your floor
And test your new water before you add it to your tank. Nothing like knowing what's going into your DT
