Wish I can start over - but what else can I do?

sanzz18

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 20, 2019
Messages
532
Reaction score
185
What state or country do you live in
Connecticut
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have had my Waterbox 220.6 running for about 6-7 weeks now. I wish I can start over and do things differently. I have lost two blue hippo tangs back to back. One from god knows what and the other from what appeared to be popeye. Then I most likely lost my orangeback fairy wrasse from potentially uronema or an injury. Now my powder brown tang (yes I know generally I should have waited for my tang to be more mature before adding tangs) hasn't been eating and appears to be flashing, scratching against the sand. There is no signs of ich so I am suspecting flukes.

Things I wish I did differently:

- Allowing the tank to cycle/cure longer instead of just relying on the basic ammonia cycle being done.
- Quarantined all fish that go into it
- Adding 6 fish in 6 weeks was too frequent for a new tank
- Freshwater dipping

1. What should I do to help my powder brown tang? I cannot catch him to do a freshwater dip to confirm flukes.

2. How do I get to a stable system after not quarantining without having to reboot or catch impossible fish to fallow?

3. Quarantining still worth it for me?
 
Lol wow so way to go full bore into this. You need to get a qt tank going asap and get the powder brown into it. Powder browns are insanely hard to keep any way but putting him in qt will allow you to treat what's going on. Once you figure out what he has you will need to let the tank sit fallow for a while. You can always reboot I am doing it right now. Sucks but worth it in the long run.
 
Lol wow so way to go full bore into this. You need to get a qt tank going asap and get the powder brown into it. Powder browns are insanely hard to keep any way but putting him in qt will allow you to treat what's going on. Once you figure out what he has you will need to let the tank sit fallow for a while. You can always reboot I am doing it right now. Sucks but worth it in the long run.

Lol yeah, like I said in my post, many mistakes. I should know better. Although, like I said, I cannot catch my powder brown for the life of me. Secondly, in order to let me tank go fallow, I have to get all the fish out of there and I really just can't see myself being able to catch all the fish. I do not want to reboot my tank cause I am 100% happy the way my rockscape is and don't know how I would possibly do the bleach method.
 
You wouldn't have to destroy what you made. I have had to restart mine after an outbreak and now my fish are in qt for 60 days while whatever in my dt dies off. If it is an outbreak you will just end up prolonging the outbreak with fish in that tank. I know it's a pain but it's a marathon. Never easy but that's why qt is so important
 
I think the most recent BRS video regarding the use of UV and high flow/low flow and QT is something most people could benefit from and you should watch it. Do it now!

Hug Time Get Over Here GIF by Awkward Daytime TV
 
Fish trap or take a picture of your scape and move the rocks into a plastic bin and catch the fish then replace the rocks.

I don’t know what you mean by bleach but you just let the tank sit fallow for minimum 45 days at 81-82 degrees.

If you have uronema in your tank, then do not purchase chromis, butterflies, or anthias. Non-susceptible fish will probably be fine.

You can buy an UV but it is costly and may be a waste of money as you have a powder brown tang in a newish tank where nothing was QT. I am not sure UV and food will save this. There isn’t a magic cure or an easy way to do this or everyone would do it and the disease forums would be slow.
 
Fish trap or take a picture of your scape and move the rocks into a plastic bin and catch the fish then replace the rocks.

I don’t know what you mean by bleach but you just let the tank sit fallow for minimum 45 days at 81-82 degrees.

If you have uronema in your tank, then do not purchase chromis, butterflies, or anthias. Non-susceptible fish will probably be fine.

You can buy an UV but it is costly and may be a waste of money as you have a powder brown tang in a newish tank where nothing was QT. I am not sure UV and food will save this. There isn’t a magic cure or an easy way to do this or everyone would do it and the disease forums would be slow.
I should point out that my reference to UV was more long term than fixing this situation. If you QT or utilize UV, there are still large gaps of bad things that can happen. Not saying UV is a cure all by any means, but neither is home QT and it looks like QT is a big struggle for setting up for this situation, which is more medical.
 
I have had my Waterbox 220.6 running for about 6-7 weeks now. I wish I can start over and do things differently. I have lost two blue hippo tangs back to back. One from god knows what and the other from what appeared to be popeye. Then I most likely lost my orangeback fairy wrasse from potentially uronema or an injury. Now my powder brown tang (yes I know generally I should have waited for my tang to be more mature before adding tangs) hasn't been eating and appears to be flashing, scratching against the sand. There is no signs of ich so I am suspecting flukes.

Things I wish I did differently:

- Allowing the tank to cycle/cure longer instead of just relying on the basic ammonia cycle being done.
- Quarantined all fish that go into it
- Adding 6 fish in 6 weeks was too frequent for a new tank
- Freshwater dipping

1. What should I do to help my powder brown tang? I cannot catch him to do a freshwater dip to confirm flukes.

2. How do I get to a stable system after not quarantining without having to reboot or catch impossible fish to fallow?

3. Quarantining still worth it for me?

Suggestion for catching the powder brown. Drain your tank until there's pretty much just enough water for it to stay upright. It won't be happy, but catching it will be much easier. It could still be ich, as it doesn't always present with spots. Prazi pro treats flukes, and I believe it is supposed to be reef safe. You'll need need a ton of it to treat a tank that size though, and a good estimatation of how much water is displaced by the rocks.

Answer to question two. If it's ich, it can be managed through good water quality, low stress and good diet, though with Hippos and powder blue/browns it will always be a concern that it will come back with a vengeance. If it's anything else, and cannot remove your fish, to my knowledge you're screwed.

Quarantine is always, always, always worth it! Whatever you got in your tank can be managed or eliminated, and a rigorous quarantine will prevent new diseases, parasites and other nastiness from getting in there.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top