Yellow Tang and Flame Angel breathing hard

Saltwada

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 19, 2019
Messages
145
Reaction score
34
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone!

I recently lost my blue tang to a bad case of ich. the yellow tang had ich bad too, but i used medic from polyp lab and it helped it, but the blue tang not so much. i think it got so bad i could only see the blue tang breathing out of one gill. i do not own a qt tank and i tried to set up a hospital tank for theblue tang, but i think i stressed it out more because it didnt eat and just stayed in a corner. so i dropped it back into my main tank and it died the next morning. now my yellow tang and flame angel have ich i now i need to fallow my tank going forward, but right now dont have the equipment ready yet. and i heard flame angels are gonna die from copper safe medicine. i need help. also my local fish store told me that ich is in every tank and inside all fish cant get rid of it. they said that ich comes around when it goes cold in winter and temp fluctuates. when a fish is stressed and weak its prone to ich, but if its healthy it can fight it off. please shed some light on me because i am so confused. this whole forum is saying u can cure ich, but the fishstore and some of my friends say they dont qt and have not lost a fish in years.
 
Last edited:
Your situation sounds more like velvet than ich. Can you upload pics of your fish?

Ich is NOT in every tank. It's likely in every tank that fish are not properly QTd. A disease free tank is fully possible. It takes some work and diligent treatment of all new additions and proper fallow periods for adding inverts and coral to the tank.
 
First off welcome to R2R!!
I will say that there are two groups of people when it comes to ich, there those that manage ich and those that eradicate it through QT. I myself am in the eradicate camp as it helps me keep more difficult fish without worrying about disease.
Fish can fight ich off and manage it with their immune system, some say feeding them really well and providing a low stress environment is key. The issue with this is it may take time for your fish to fight this off and you may have more losses. Before someone who manages it jumps in I’ll also say with copper you may have the same losses depending on the progression of the parasitic infection.
If you wish to eradicate ich you’ll need a QT setup and copper. I prefer copper power and the Hanna high range copper tester to help me monitor my levels. I would start off by predosing the tank to 1ppm and adding the fish then over the few days ramp up the copper levels to 2.0ppm (therapeutic level is 1.5ppm bare minimum), once this level is achieved you would run copper for 14 days then transfer to a sterile tank or 30 days in the same tank. You would need to leave your DT fishless for 76 days to eradicate ich. Once you accomplish this though you will need to QT any new addition to prevent reinfection of your tank.
I QT because the distribution system these days is so rife with disease that velvet, Brooklynella, and even Uronema are becoming very common and fish far less likely to manage these and survive.
I hope this helped you and please post any questions you may have and we’ll get you going down the right path.
 
I agree you’re likely dealing with velvet. The poly lab product doesn’t work, so your fish need treatment.

Angels do fine in copper, but in such a bad state from velvet or ich for so long with an ineffective treatment they are at a greater risk of succumbing during treatment, but if you want to save them that’s your best option.

A ruby reef rally bath would help with the current infestation, copper would prevent reinfection.

Welcome to R2R by the way, I wish it were under better circumstances!
 
I’m going to +3 and echo what everyone else is saying.

It is definitely possible to be ich-free, QT with copper and a 76 day fallow period will get you there. Adopting a thorough QT protocol for new additions moving forward will keep you there.

I’ve been where you are now more than once in the 8-9ish years I’ve been in the hobby. The first time, I was new to the hobby and resistant to QT, so I thought I would try to manage the parasites, and ultimately got velvet and lost most of my fish.

The second time, I was more open to QT and even started to QT some new fish, but was inexperienced and didn’t treat prophylactically...and after getting hit with velvet AGAIN, I waited a little too long getting everyone out, and again lost most of my fish.

Third time, I was actively QT’ing new fish and much more experienced... but regretfully skipped QT on a sensitive fish. This time, after the first sign of spots I got my butt in gear and made a plan- got everybody out and treated (including my sensitive Typhoid Mary) still had some set-backs...but ended up saving almost all of them, many of which I still have :)

I’ve definitely been much more successful keeping a healthy community of fish since I’ve gotten proactive about QT and prophylactic treatments.
 
I agree you’re likely dealing with velvet. The poly lab product doesn’t work, so your fish need treatment.

Angels do fine in copper, but in such a bad state from velvet or ich for so long with an ineffective treatment they are at a greater risk of succumbing during treatment, but if you want to save them that’s your best option.

A ruby reef rally bath would help with the current infestation, copper would prevent reinfection.

Welcome to R2R by the way, I wish it were under better circumstances!

Thanks for the feedback I’m gonna take all of your advice and do the fallow tank thing. But should I use copper safe?
 
I’m going to +3 and echo what everyone else is saying.

It is definitely possible to be ich-free, QT with copper and a 76 day fallow period will get you there. Adopting a thorough QT protocol for new additions moving forward will keep you there.

I’ve been where you are now more than once in the 8-9ish years I’ve been in the hobby. The first time, I was new to the hobby and resistant to QT, so I thought I would try to manage the parasites, and ultimately got velvet and lost most of my fish.

The second time, I was more open to QT and even started to QT some new fish, but was inexperienced and didn’t treat prophylactically...and after getting hit with velvet AGAIN, I waited a little too long getting everyone out, and again lost most of my fish.

Third time, I was actively QT’ing new fish and much more experienced... but regretfully skipped QT on a sensitive fish. This time, after the first sign of spots I got my butt in gear and made a plan- got everybody out and treated (including my sensitive Typhoid Mary) still had some set-backs...but ended up saving almost all of them, many of which I still have :)

I’ve definitely been much more successful keeping a healthy community of fish since I’ve gotten proactive about QT and prophylactic treatments.

Aw wow that’s good t
 
I’m going to +3 and echo what everyone else is saying.

It is definitely possible to be ich-free, QT with copper and a 76 day fallow period will get you there. Adopting a thorough QT protocol for new additions moving forward will keep you there.

I’ve been where you are now more than once in the 8-9ish years I’ve been in the hobby. The first time, I was new to the hobby and resistant to QT, so I thought I would try to manage the parasites, and ultimately got velvet and lost most of my fish.

The second time, I was more open to QT and even started to QT some new fish, but was inexperienced and didn’t treat prophylactically...and after getting hit with velvet AGAIN, I waited a little too long getting everyone out, and again lost most of my fish.

Third time, I was actively QT’ing new fish and much more experienced... but regretfully skipped QT on a sensitive fish. This time, after the first sign of spots I got my butt in gear and made a plan- got everybody out and treated (including my sensitive Typhoid Mary) still had some set-backs...but ended up saving almost all of them, many of which I still have :)

I’ve definitely been much more successful keeping a healthy community of fish since I’ve gotten proactive about QT and prophylactic treatments.

That’s awesome! Can you share with me a way to q t? People keep showing me different stuff but it’s all a little different what I do t understand is how to keep a qt tank cycles or low levels of ammo is without doing so many water changes
 
That’s awesome! Can you share with me a way to q t? People keep showing me different stuff but it’s all a little different what I do t understand is how to keep a qt tank cycles or low levels of ammo is without doing so many water changes
Read these, pictures of your fish will really help the people above with diagnosing what your fish actually have.

Biospira is a good product to use for controlling ammonia while in qt along with using an ammonia alert badge to monitor it. Prime is a product that can neutralize ammonia temporarily but don't ever use it with copper as it will be toxic to your fish.

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/my-current-qt-process.483371/

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/fallow-periods-going-fishless.190324/
 
Last edited:
That’s awesome! Can you share with me a way to q t? People keep showing me different stuff but it’s all a little different what I do t understand is how to keep a qt tank cycles or low levels of ammo is without doing so many water changes


This may be helpful
How to Quarantine
https://r.tapatalk.com/shareLink?sh...hreads/How-to-Quarantine.189815/&share_type=t

I use a smaller QT since I’m only treating one fish at a time, but it can certainly be scaled up in an emergency situation such as yours.

Most important- will be aeration and ammonia control. When you are using medications like copper, you need to have plenty of exchanged oxygen. For every medicine you need to add, the oxygen depletion in the tank increases. I’ve found an appropriately sized powerhead(s)aimed at the surface, paired with and air-stone and HOB filter work nicely to keep the tank oxygenated and flowing sufficiently.

For ammonia control, like stated above BioSpira or other “bacteria in a bottle” products are very helpful. Avoid Prime or other chemical neutralizers since they react poorly with copper. Besides adding bacteria, water changes are your friend. I try to do one at least every week... and as needed if the water starts to appear cloudy or my alert badge shows even a smidgen of green.

You’ll want to have some antibiotics on hand as well, since secondary infections are very common during parasite outbreaks. Kanaplex, Metroplex, and Furan-2 work well together and are safe to use with copper. Another good one to have on hand is Sulfaplex or API Triple Sulfa.

Acriflavine is very useful as well... Ruby Reef Rally is great for use as an antiseptic/ anti-parasitic bath (in a separate container) to provide more “immediate relief”.

The QT will also need a heater and thermometer to monitor temperature, and an ammonia alert badge since ammonia test kits don’t work with copper. PVC pieces make good hiding places for fish, and you can add a small container of sand for sand-sifters or sand sleeping wrasse.

You do not need a light on your QT as long as the room has enough ambient lighting to be able to observe the fish. If you are using a light, I’d suggest keeping it turned on as little as possible to reduce algae growth/bacterial blooms and keep the water clear.
 
Thanks for the feedback I’m gonna take all of your advice and do the fallow tank thing. But should I use copper safe?
Copper Power is better, just because it's consistent in its' potency. CopperSafe has had quality control issues in our experience.
 
This may be helpful
How to Quarantine
https://r.tapatalk.com/shareLink?share_fid=1020&share_tid=189815&url=https://www.reef2reef.com/index.php?threads/How-to-Quarantine.189815/&share_type=t

I use a smaller QT since I’m only treating one fish at a time, but it can certainly be scaled up in an emergency situation such as yours.

Most important- will be aeration and ammonia control. When you are using medications like copper, you need to have plenty of exchanged oxygen. For every medicine you need to add, the oxygen depletion in the tank increases. I’ve found an appropriately sized powerhead(s)aimed at the surface, paired with and air-stone and HOB filter work nicely to keep the tank oxygenated and flowing sufficiently.

For ammonia control, like stated above BioSpira or other “bacteria in a bottle” products are very helpful. Avoid Prime or other chemical neutralizers since they react poorly with copper. Besides adding bacteria, water changes are your friend. I try to do one at least every week... and as needed if the water starts to appear cloudy or my alert badge shows even a smidgen of green.

You’ll want to have some antibiotics on hand as well, since secondary infections are very common during parasite outbreaks. Kanaplex, Metroplex, and Furan-2 work well together and are safe to use with copper. Another good one to have on hand is Sulfaplex or API Triple Sulfa.

Acriflavine is very useful as well... Ruby Reef Rally is great for use as an antiseptic/ anti-parasitic bath (in a separate container) to provide more “immediate relief”.

The QT will also need a heater and thermometer to monitor temperature, and an ammonia alert badge since ammonia test kits don’t work with copper. PVC pieces make good hiding places for fish, and you can add a small container of sand for sand-sifters or sand sleeping wrasse.

You do not need a light on your QT as long as the room has enough ambient lighting to be able to observe the fish. If you are using a light, I’d suggest keeping it turned on as little as possible to reduce algae growth/bacterial blooms and keep the water clear.
wow thanks for the advice on this! i love this site already. so does the bio spira act fast and make ammonia drop fast? should i add media like matrix to help
 
wow thanks for the advice on this! i love this site already. so does the bio spira act fast and make ammonia drop fast? should i add media like matrix to help
You don't want too much "rock-like" or porous material because it might absorb the copper and cause the levels to fluctuate. I usually just add a regular sponge to my filter (obviously no carbon or chemical media that will remove the copper) for the bacteria to colonize. Some people add the bacteria to the sponge directly first by soaking it in a separate container, but I'll be honest I just dump it in the tank. If you do see ammonia creeping up, after doing a water-change- you can add more, it's good to have an extra bottle or two on hand.
 
You don't want too much "rock-like" or porous material because it might absorb the copper and cause the levels to fluctuate. I usually just add a regular sponge to my filter (obviously no carbon or chemical media that will remove the copper) for the bacteria to colonize. Some people add the bacteria to the sponge directly first by soaking it in a separate container, but I'll be honest I just dump it in the tank. If you do see ammonia creeping up, after doing a water-change- you can add more, it's good to have an extra bottle or two on hand.

Oh ic so using seache matrix isnt good? I was told it’s good to use
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top