YOUR OPINION- are fish truly happy in captivity?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ZoWhat
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
A very similar argument is also made about human minds though, we are simply conditioned and respond to positive and negative stimuli.
keanu reeves film GIF

Dayquil or Advil LiquiGel?
 
Last edited:
And by the way...why do people only worry about clownfish being lonely and needing a mate? Doesn't a tailspot blenny have a right to some companionship and dare I say it? Love.

Full disclosure. Have only ever had one clownfish. Seems very well adjusted except for making me turn on Lifetime movie occasionally.
 
Ugh.

No. They are not. Nor are they "truly happy" in the wild. They are fish.

Disney anthropromorphism aside we can't judge a fish's assessment of it's comparative condition let alone it's emotional state of being.

Best we can is provide the best environment we can as responsible hobbyists so animals in our care are healthy and have long as possible life spans.

I don't spend any time comparing my 50% (that's probably optimistic) survival rate to wild survival chances. I hate losing one fish and I don't feel better knowing its odds of living long as it did were higher with me.

As an aside. "Self aware" isn't demonstrating learned behavioral responses to environmental conditions. Those are necessary for species survival. Running away from a predator or hanging out in a prime feeding location doesn't necessarily mean an animal is self aware or making logical reasoned decisions.
I'm not sure folks were saying fish are self aware, but maybe I missed that. I think there's a bit of separation between sentient and self-aware, and a living thing doesn't need to be self-aware to be sentient. I think of self-aware more in the sapient bucket. That said, there was a study done a few years ago where it was determined that the cleaner wrasse is able to pass the mirror self-aware test. Well, that brought on a debate about whether that test is an adequate way to determine self-awareness -- b/c no one wants to have to put a species of fish in the same bucket as apes.
 
b/c no one wants to have to put a species of fish in the same bucket as apes.
Don't think my HOA would approve of an Ape Sanctuary in my backyard... although I could charge admission and start a small profit center.
 
since the subject looks to be really easy to debate, lets add a variant to complicate things: are octopus able to feel joy, since they are know to be highly intelligent creatures? (on a side note, we know Dolphins are able to play with each other for no reason other then as a divertissement, and that they know themselves by individual names and are self aware. Go back 20 years, people would have laughed at you if you said that)
 
And by the way...why do people only worry about clownfish being lonely and needing a mate? Doesn't a tailspot blenny have a right to some companionship and dare I say it? Love.

Full disclosure. Have only ever had one clownfish. Seems very well adjusted except for making me turn on Lifetime movie occasionally.
Well clownfish are one of the few fish that is monogamous, well more or less monogamous. Their are other fish that is recommended to not keep solo like anthias afaik.
I think you can keep clowns solo without a problem, just not totally alone. Most fish seem to not like isolation, must reinforce the captivity or at least somehtings not write here idea.


Don't think my HOA would approve of an Ape Sanctuary in my backyard... although I could charge admission and start a small profit center.

Silverback police! You need a 4000 sq ft enclosure minimum, if your doing a nano stick with a pygmy marmoset!
 
since the subject looks to be really easy to debate, lets add a variant to complicate things: are octopus able to feel joy, since they are know to be highly intelligent creatures? (on a side note, we know Dolphins are able to play with each other for no reason other then as a divertissement, and that they know themselves by individual names and are self aware. Go back 20 years, people would have laughed at you if you said that)

Or even commit suicide if upset enough! If you want to read a wild story and you haven't heard it before .... https://www.republicworld.com/techn...e-after-being-separated-from-its-trainer.html
 
I believe anyone who keeps pets/animals should ask this question, although keeping pets vs keeping animals have enormous differences. Domestication 10,000 plus years ago had nothing to do with pet keeping.

Anyway, more to the topic. I don't think that a fish's conscious awareness is close to ours, not to say they can't have "feelings" but feelings not like humans have.

When we consider captivity, do we also accept that we are captive? After all, we live in houses most of us haven't built. We consume food most of us haven't personally gathered. We rely mostly on "man-made" medications. We stay close to cities/civilization mainly because we are "captive" in a way. There is almost nothing natural about any of these living conditions, yet we continue along as if they were inherent or even instinctive.

I attempt to respect any and all life especially if I make a decision to "keep pets". Any animal we keep, we have a complete 100% responsibility to do everything within our power to allow it a happy, healthy existence. If we cannot do this, we should considerately not indulge.

I do find it personally rewarding to have and care for animals. I also think that anyone who would take the time to share thoughts on a forum like this probably cares a lot about their fish.

-Sean
Nailed it
 
Interesting story, but I am not sure its a proof of high intelligence, as some pets (parrots, dogs, etc) are know to stop eating and self mutilating if its owner leave it.
 
You ask for an opinion. You have mine FWIW.
?? Did you mean to direct that to me or the OP? I didn't ask for an opinion, I was sharing some of the science behind the thinking regarding fish being sentient.
 
?? Did you mean to direct that to me or the OP? I didn't ask for an opinion, I was sharing some of the science behind the thinking regarding fish being sentient.
Sorry. I thought you were the OP. I skimmed the "articles" you linked. I continue to think fish aren't capable of the emotion of "Happiness".
 
I agree with the idea that fish are safe in captivity but some things can't be measured easily. Do fishes feel better with other fishes near them? Do fishes get bothered by certain corals? Does seeing our giant bodies every day accumulate stress in their brains?
 
I've owned dogs my entire life and consider them family members. I've never considered a fish as a pet. I take excellent care of mine but I have other outlets to fill that need with my dogs. I just enjoy the reefing hobby as a whole. Then there's the fact that I'm on the water 150 days a year fishing so that might have something to do with not having some sort of emotional attachment. Are they happy or sad? Who knows...
 
Are fish truly happy in captivity?

The problem is how do you define happy. Low cortisol? High oxytocin? Relationships between these? Low feeding competition? Lack of social or sexual conflict or the standing of a fish in a socio sexual setting (i.e. middle ranked are often less stressed than high or low ranked individuals in a social species). Certainly the error of fish keepers not understanding mechanisms/causes of stress and aggression leads many fish to be constantly stressed in captivity (be that the aggressor or the aggresse).


The other issue is many may assume that what they would like as a fish is the same as what is ideal for a non-stressful life as the fish. Anthropomorphism leads many of us to assume how a fish is feeling, even though the majority of reef keepers are not able to tell other than when the fish is showing extreme signs of distress. And that bring up another question. What does it mean to "feel" something?
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top