Zoas lost color and some are umbrellering after shock

Danmuges

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
65
Reaction score
7
What state or country do you live in
Australia
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'll be as honest as I can be. I let my salinity get too high due to a faulty salinity checker. I freaked out when I shouldn't have and dropped it too fast causing most of my zoas to either close up or melt. When they finally opened again most had completely lost color and turned brown. 2 months later I noticed my phosphates were high at 0.25 so dropped them with phosphate remover and gfo (probably too fast again) some of my zoas were unaffected and look better than ever but some such as my bbebs, goblin on fire, pink zippers and sunny d's have either browned out or look like an umbrella. Alk, calcium and magnesium have always been stable. Are these problems likely to fix themselves over time?

Alk - 8.0
Mag 1350
Calcium 430
Phos. - .04
Nitrate - 5
Sal - 1.025
 
I'll be as honest as I can be. I let my salinity get too high due to a faulty salinity checker. I freaked out when I shouldn't have and dropped it too fast causing most of my zoas to either close up or melt. When they finally opened again most had completely lost color and turned brown. 2 months later I noticed my phosphates were high at 0.25 so dropped them with phosphate remover and gfo (probably too fast again) some of my zoas were unaffected and look better than ever but some such as my bbebs, goblin on fire, pink zippers and sunny d's have either browned out or look like an umbrella. Alk, calcium and magnesium have always been stable. Are these problems likely to fix themselves over time?

Alk - 8.0
Mag 1350
Calcium 430
Phos. - .04
Nitrate - 5
Sal - 1.025
What test kits are you using and what is age of tank?
Are you using RODI water or tap water from the faucet?
Will back to you in a few short hours. I have a clue here
I’m traveling for work and our jet has no WI-FI. We’re leaving in several minutes
 
What test kits are you using and what is age of tank?
Are you using RODI water or tap water from the faucet?
Will back to you in a few short hours. I have a clue here
I’m traveling for work and our jet has no WI-FI. We’re leaving in several minutes
I'm using rodi with a 0 tds reading. The tank is around 1 and a half years old. And I'm using salifert kits and a Hanna po4 check checker
 
I'll be as honest as I can be. I let my salinity get too high due to a faulty salinity checker. I freaked out when I shouldn't have and dropped it too fast causing most of my zoas to either close up or melt. When they finally opened again most had completely lost color and turned brown. 2 months later I noticed my phosphates were high at 0.25 so dropped them with phosphate remover and gfo (probably too fast again) some of my zoas were unaffected and look better than ever but some such as my bbebs, goblin on fire, pink zippers and sunny d's have either browned out or look like an umbrella. Alk, calcium and magnesium have always been stable. Are these problems likely to fix themselves over time?

Alk - 8.0
Mag 1350
Calcium 430
Phos. - .04
Nitrate - 5
Sal - 1.025
Some zoas will go brown or umbrella from to much light or to much red in the mix. Just guessing. Good luck
 
I'm using rodi with a 0 tds reading. The tank is around 1 and a half years old. And I'm using salifert kits and a Hanna po4 check checker
I fforgot to ask about location as they seem to do best in lower third of tank where there is moderation of flow and lower UV.
Zoas must have iodide, not iodine in their water and under moderate light and water flow. Too much flow may make it hard for the polyps to open. You will know your zoanthids are happy if they open up and are fully extended without seeming to stretch so far upright.. The majority of zoanthids have symbiotic photosynthetic zooxanthellae and are therefore best kept with at least moderate aquarium lighting as mentioned for production of zooxanthele.
Zoanthids require the standard water parameters that are good for keeping just about any of your corals healthy. You’re aiming for water temperature about 78 F, salinity somewhere around 1.025 specific gravity) and normal hardness 8-11 dKH) and a pH around 8.1-8.3.
However, if your polyps were previously open and have recently closed up, this should be taken as a serious sign of a water parameters issue. The first things I would check are ph and salinity. In my experience, zoas will close up if there are swings in salinity.
One disease that seems to disproportionately impacts these corals is something called zoa pox or zoanthid pox. Zoa pox is the name given to the zoanthid disease characterized by tiny growths on the side of the affected zoas. I’m not sure whether the growths/pustules themselves irritate the polyps and cause them to close up, or if the coral is otherwise sickly and closed up (therefore showing the zoa pox), but the bottom line is that if you see zoa pox, you have a sick coral. Also look for vert tiny grey bugs if present. These are precautionery and not suspects. My suspect is parameter related.
Lastly, check for Super tiny spiders or nudibranchs which will take them down in No time. If you see these pests, start looking for eggs which are future pests to cause further problems.
Hope this Helps !!!
 
Thanks for the reply. Appreciate the info. I've been keeping zoas for a while now. This happened in my 6 foot Zoa frag tank. The parameters aren't the issue. They were shocked by the drop in salinity and phosphates so Im wondering if they will regain their full color? My Scrambled eggs have completely lost the green skirt too.
 
I have some sunny d’s that were neon orange and after some issues mainly high phosphate for a while I noticed they lost a lot of their color. Got the phosphate down and are now as bright as ever
 
Thanks for the reply. Appreciate the info. I've been keeping zoas for a while now. This happened in my 6 foot Zoa frag tank. The parameters aren't the issue. They were shocked by the drop in salinity and phosphates so Im wondering if they will regain their full color? My Scrambled eggs have completely lost the green skirt too.
They will come back. Be patient. They'll look good soon
 
Zoas must have iodide, not iodine in their water and under moderate light and water flow.
@vetteguy53081 I would love to know where you think Iodine/ Iodide should be in terms of solid testing numbers. The specific range of not too high and not too low.
 
@vetteguy53081 I would love to know where you think Iodine/ Iodide should be in terms of solid testing numbers. The specific range of not too high and not too low.
Based on experience only. One drop every 2 weeks for a heavily populated 40. I use it at the same proportion for a similarly populated 75. One small drop. Lol. How's that for precision. All I know is all lps and polyps of every kind perk up and you have better polyp extension. Go to the chemistry section and I'm sure they will have numbers and hundreds of conflicting links to click on. I also add One drop of a trace elements product with iodide. All you corals will benefit.
 
Thanks for the reply. Appreciate the info. I've been keeping zoas for a while now. This happened in my 6 foot Zoa frag tank. The parameters aren't the issue. They were shocked by the drop in salinity and phosphates so Im wondering if they will regain their full color? My Scrambled eggs have completely lost the green skirt too.
Gotcha
In my drop off tank when ATO went haywire and I too had a salinity drop, few recovered as I assume they dont take it well. The colony had about 70 heads and about 30 were open again, the rest were little balls that opened slightly in the dark, and remained closed at lights on
 
Gotcha
In my drop off tank when ATO went haywire and I too had a salinity drop, few recovered as I assume they dont take it well. The colony had about 70 heads and about 30 were open again, the rest were little balls that opened slightly in the dark, and remained closed at lights on
How much of a change? I've got a new zoa that won't open after 5 days. Old established tank. All others are great. Maybe just got a dud.
 
How much of a change? I've got a new zoa that won't open after 5 days. Old established tank. All others are great. Maybe just got a dud.
dropped from 1.025 to just under 1.023
 
I noticed in my tanks when I started testing more regular and stopped chasing numbers my tanks did so much better
I think the testing every 3 days just got me more involved in my tank and made me less likely to panic and make big adjustments

I have nutrients issues
I just can’t help myself, I love having fish just as much as I like coral And Iove to overfeed them. Who doesn’t enjoy 50 fish coming to the tank every time you walk begging for food
In my case since I have a big tank abs system I switched to liquid phosphates remover because with gfo I noticed the swings where too big.
Most Corals in general but especially zoas will get used to a wide range of parameters, there simple just isn’t one perfect number. I found it best to just to keep those parameters as stable as possible
I now dose bright-well liquid phosphates remover instead of using gfo because I can dose 10 ml a day and that won’t change my phosphates too much daily


Now to get back to your questions. You already know what you did wrong
Stop panic adjusting your parameters once they are way off. Slow and steady wins the race in this hobby
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top