Anemone not eating not sticky!?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I already have a very expensive powerhead and I am gonna upgrade my light really soon. And all my other animals are thriving! And it is only two of my water prams are off and I can easily fix them!
 
Your alk is too high and your lighting is terrible. These are going to kill your anemone. You are already seeing the signs of it dieing but you can't be bothered to get correct water or plan on upgrading your lighting. Please you are not caring for your tank.
 
+1 on taking it back. Your tank is not the right size for your fish, your light wont work for coral, your water is not right and you don't want to get water every water change which would be like 2 gallons every water change. This hobby takes dedication and time and money. Lights are cheap and the fish and coral you have don't deserve to be in such a small unstable environment. Everything in your tank isn't right. Sorry for the harshness but it's the truth.
 
I already am!
You asked for help and didn't like our responses. You keep saying everything is thriving and that your doing the right thing. But you are not doing the right thing. Either put the money into the tank you have or wait til you can do it right and have the knowledge to start. People on this thread really dedicate ourselves to this hobby and hope the best for you.
 
I already am!
I was on your side for most of this but you really are not. You say most of your animals are thriving, do you have corals? Bringing the nem back to the store is probably the only way you can keep it alive. You may lose money, but that hardly compares to an animal losing its life.

I also can’t stress this enough: it seems as though you will upgrade your light, get one of the pricier ones. Kessils are the preferred light for a reason. If you cheap out and get a $40 Corallife LED from petco, you’ll be in this same situation and you’ll be $40 poorer.

Don’t do anything drastic like a 100% water change or try to alter your parameters. Chasing numbers isn’t as important as stability. Shocking the nem will only kill it. Ideally, you will return it to the pet store and upgrade the light. If you have photosensitive animals like corals in the tank, don’t immediately run the light at max capacity.

Reefing is a long road you have to build yourself up for. It may seem like you’ve learned a lot, but there’s a lot more to find out. I’m rooting for you, man. Take this for a bit of comfort: even the most insane and skilled reefers once screwed up by not doing enough planning or research.
 
I already am!
Everything these guys are saying is right and true. As a new reefer it’s hard to understand these things cause you lack the experience that we all have. If you would like to pm me we can talk in private about you your issues.
 
I already am!
Anyways please keep us posted either way on how this turns out because many of us would like the information so we can continue to confirm what we already know reiterating the experience that we all have. If you don’t ever respond we will assume the anemone has not made it
 
Last edited:
I have just ordered a Kessel light or whatever you call it and when I said alkalinity i meant carbonate hardness. Sorry about that I got confused. My carbonate hardness is at 11 I just tested it.
 
Ok guys tell me do you want me to upgrade my tank to a 10 or 15 gallon? Because I think that is the best thing to do. Now that you guys said all of that about my tank I feel TERRIBLE! I am so sorry! I didn't know it was wrong!
 
I apologize if I came off harsh, and I’m further sorry for the advice we’re sharing. About a year ago, I had a 6 month old 13 gallon tank that was doing really well. I tried an anemone, even though I was warned my tank was probably not mature enough yet, even though my clam was thriving (each tank is different). I tried anyway, and almost killed the poor nem. I eventually took him back, because I’d rather it survive, even if not in my tank. I started a 40 breeder, waited another 6 months, and this time I had coralline growing out of control, I had my parameters much more consistently in check, and my new nem is doing great!

In order to get your tank to a place that it’s set up for a nem to thrive, you’re going to have to make a lot of great changes (lights, flow, water parameters, etc). These changes are only going to stress out the anemone further. If it’s already struggling, it just seems fairest to give it the best chance you can now, and try again later.

This is only my $0.02 from my own personal experience, and there might be others on here who disagree, that might believe it has a better chance maturing alongside your tank, and you can weigh those opinions as well. Again, good luck, whatever you decide. I’m hoping for the best for you and your nem :)

Also, I think carbonate hardness is the measure of alkalinity. So they’re interchangeable. You might also see dKh referenced. Same thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top