Great to see more people joining in this discussion. I believe the original debate that was started by Aqua Box, was intended to show the equal importance of a number of areas around the subject of sustainability. I try to support and raise awareness of a number of what I believe to be sustainable choices. Captive Breeding is just one.
I would never wish to see a hobby where 100% of the animals in the trade are captive bred. I think both aquaculture and wild sustainable harvest play vital roles. But I would like to see, a greater awareness and understanding of the role captive breeding can play in the industry and the greater choices that it can provide hobbyists. At the present time, especially in Europe, the awareness and availability of Captive Bred Species is extremely low compared to wild collected animals. One of the reasons for this, I believe, is that a large proportion of retail customers just don`t` see the justification in paying a premium, for what they see as just another fish. The only way I can see to help support captive breeding programs and give wholesalers and retailers the economic confidence to stock captive bred animals, is to make fellow hobbyists understand the choices and what benefits each choice may offer. IMO simply waiting for the prices to come down will inevitably put off investment by breeders and that choice will have gone.
What I beleive compounds the issue is something I commonly come across in the hobby. MYTHS or MISREPRESENTATION OF THE SCIENTIFIC FACTS. I am no expert, I am a novice reef keeper, so what I like to do is read journals, publications and research documents. I then pass on the links to this information to my group members.
There are many myths surrounding Aquaculture of Marine Ornamentals. The most common ones I come across on the negative side, involved in breeding and comparison to the present culture of Poecilia reticulata (Guppy). I am a great lover of the common guppy. IMO one of the best freshwater fish to study in your home aquarium. Infact I still have a few Poecilia wingei (Endlers) in my office. Unfortunately comparing these fish to the current state of Marine Aquaculture is rather misleading. Guppy farming and breeding is a hobby within itself. Cross breeding of Cousins and Aunts and Uncles is carried out specifically and intentionally to produce a particular trait in the offspring. The only area that I am aware of in Marine Aquaculture is Clown Fish, particularly Percula and Ocellaris. Although a pioneering driving force in marine aquaculture this part of the trade has become an entity in itself. Due, maybe, by a lack of financial incentive from retail customers, it seems to have driven the breeding facilities to produce an animal that has no competition from wild caught animals. These markings and colours are only available through aquaculture. Therefore the customer has no option but to pay the market price if he wishes to own one.
The breeding stock of Biota and I believe many other facilities are in fact wild caught specimens. Specifically selected for their overall condition and health. Once the breeding program has reached a certain point. The original breeding stock is released and new stock is acquired.
Another negative subject that comes up is Lack of Immunity to disease. Once again I believe a very misunderstood topic. First of all comparing fish immune systems to that of mammals is very misleading. Fish have a very particular system of immune defense. The vast majority of this immunity is passed on through genetics. It is passed on by their parents through thousands of years of evolution, not simply by being exposed to infection and disease to test out who is the strongest. This aspect of biology is far toO complicated for a novice like myself to disseminate here. Therefore I have included the following link to an excellent article of which I had come across the abstract to. The paper is by
JAQUELINE D. BILLER-TAKAHASHI
and ELISABETH C. URBINAT, Titled
Fish Immunology. The modification and manipulation of the innate immune system:
http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0001-37652014000301484
On the positive side of what I believe to be MYTHS.
Captive Bred Fish show less aggression to conspecifics. In my opinion the nature of these animals has been developed over thousands of years. Mostly designed for the purpose of survival and re production. These aspects surely could not be totally eliminated in just one generation. The same care and understanding for specific species is still extremely important for a hobbyistrs to understand before they commit to housing these animals. This misunderstanding I believe may also be compounded by the generally juvenile age of Captive Bred Fish. Juvenile and adult behaviour in species can be markedly different. especially one an individual comes into prime breeding age.
To conclude, I would like to ask that an effort be made offer a bi partisan spirit to all like minded sustainable aquarists. If we truly want our hobby to continue into the distant future we all need to work together by eliminating the myths on both sides.
Once again thank you Aqua Box in bringing this topic up for discussion. Happy Reefing to you all.