Brooklynella?

Jonathan Troutt

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 1, 2018
Messages
970
Reaction score
1,173
Location
Indianapolis, IN
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My two other fish look great. This one clownfish has these spots just on his head and mouth currently. Thoughts?

I have never quarantined fish. I’ve never had an issue. If it is brooklynella or ich can I just treat the fish or do I have to treat whole tank?

21E2A03D-C199-41B0-900C-FBC01C6D3062.jpeg
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
I just went though one of my two clowns having Brooklynella. First treated with formalin, it might of been old didn't work. You can't buy it any more so used Seachem paragaurd, it didn't work. Then read about people having success with fresh water baths for 15min. While in QT I dipped her 5 times once every other day. She was fine, DT was void of clowns for 2 months. Returned her to DT within a week she developed Brooklynella again. Caught her in the DT and fresh water dipped her 4 more times and its been 3 months and she is doing fine. Hope this helps.
 
Yipnive read about success with FW dips. I dip mine last night. I have some of the ruby reef on it way just in case. But spots do look much better. I will be dipping again tomorrow. Thank you for your input.

This disease came from a clown I purchased from a different source than my usual. My local fish store I have been buying fish from for over 10 years I’ve never had a problem with disease or an issue with fish dying. I went somewhere different because they were out. Lesson learned through all of this. Take the time to qt or to treat when new fish come in.

I never had because I don’t really have a spot to set up a quarantine tank.
 
Yeah I hope my
Royal gramma don’t get it I will have to tear apart my tank to get it

If he has brook, it is very likely all the fish in your tank are hosting, without visual symptoms. If you want to be 100% sure you can get rid of it, they should all be moved to QT and treated. Allow DT to be fallow.
 
OK so a quick update here. I am super ticked at this point. I gave a freshwater dip last night for 3 minutes. Made sure temp and PH was the same as my DT. Fish did fine in the dip. Put back in tank. Woke up this morning to what appeared to be a happy clown swimming around just fine not breathing fast. Ate for me this morning. Not acting weird at all. Just got a call from the wife that it had died.

The white spots on the mouth were gone this morning as well. I am having her send me an up close picture of it. But what could of happened. I have never had a fish die on me like this. Let alone two. The other clownfish that died it happened almost the same way except I woke up to it dead. But the night before it was acting perfectly fine as well.
 
The wife is saying that when she pulled it out of the tank it had a cloud of white around it. This is how she pulled it out of the tank. What is that stuff around it’s mouth

8E88A845-ED81-4108-B276-9F8AF8295426.jpeg
 
most of what I was reading last night was saying 3-5 minutes. Which is why I only did a 3 min. There was definitely an improvement in the spots afterword. This morning they were barely noticeable. Plus I only wanted to do it until I got the ruby reef in. I am going to look when I get home but the wife said the fish was no where near the bottom of the tank.

I was under the impression that brooklynella didn't kill this quick.
 
most of what I was reading last night was saying 3-5 minutes. Which is why I only did a 3 min. There was definitely an improvement in the spots afterword. This morning they were barely noticeable. Plus I only wanted to do it until I got the ruby reef in. I am going to look when I get home but the wife said the fish was no where near the bottom of the tank.

I was under the impression that brooklynella didn't kill this quick.
I wouldnt recommend more than a 5 minute freshwater dip. Even with 5 minutes you have to closely monitor for stress.
 
Wel freshwater dip doesn’t matter at this point because I’ve lost the fish.

It only had the couple of spots in the picture and now other signs of distress. What caused the death?
 
Wel freshwater dip doesn’t matter at this point because I’ve lost the fish.

It only had the couple of spots in the picture and now other signs of distress. What caused the death?
To be frank, not quarantining your fish and not being prepared to treat in time caused the death.

Now, most of us have made the same errors, what’s important is that we learn from it. It took me years to remove my head from my rear end and stop dusting fish, hoping that I’d continue to be lucky. I kept wiping out fish and entire tanks and couldn’t keep several (like acanthurus tangs)— so I changed my ways. Life is much better now and my fish live longer and healthier.

The reality is that today almost every fish has ich, brook, velvet, flukes, or internal parasites. In many cases, more than one of these. Corners are cut throughout the distribution system to keep prices down to the point that now we must take quarantine to heart and care for the fish, assuming they’re ill, from the start.

It’s not that hard there’s a plethora of knowledge and help here to help set you on that path.

You do need to treat your fish and run the tank fallow as mentioned, unfortunately. I’d run them through either CP or Copper Power afterward to rid them of residual ich you cannot see and start fresh.

Sorry for your loss, friend.
 
Ok then so a couple questions here. The two fish I have left can I put them both in the same QT tank. You say to run my DT tank fallow, how long and do I need to do anything as far as treating the main tank.

I appreciate the frankness, I have always known I was taking a risk not qt'ing but in threads and several sites that I have read about brook I have seen clownfish far more infected, if that is the proper term, than mine. The Ruby reef will be at my door tomorrow. So 48 hours total time and with a FW dip in between which I have read some people having success treating brook with just freshwater dips.

I am going to find a spot to set up a small qt tank prolly 10 maybe 20 gal is all I have on hand.

I see you are up in carmel. Who do you use as far as local? For fish and corals?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top