Bta just won’t settle !!

frizzayyyyreef

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 12, 2021
Messages
771
Reaction score
309
Location
new york
What state or country do you live in
New York
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I’ve had this guy for 2 months he just doesn’t wanna settle I think he’s just maybe gotten bigger my clowns feed him non stop….my tanks only 40 gallons should I trade him in for a tiny one? I heard of trying to make a crevice so he can put his foot in but he’s stubborn ….

62CCBBE4-0FF9-4E02-A157-203D5B639893.jpeg 99717AC6-D874-4B7F-944B-2A2F29F5602E.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5199.MOV
    17 MB
I’ve had this guy for 2 months he just doesn’t wanna settle I think he’s just maybe gotten bigger my clowns feed him non stop….my tanks only 40 gallons should I trade him in for a tiny one? I heard of trying to make a crevice so he can put his foot in but he’s stubborn ….

62CCBBE4-0FF9-4E02-A157-203D5B639893.jpeg 99717AC6-D874-4B7F-944B-2A2F29F5602E.jpeg
BTAs love to move lol Itll settle and then maybe move again
 
What’s your lighting? May just be the picture but the nem looks a little faded. Zoas appear to be reaching to light as well.

Potentially, inadequate light is causing it to roam
 
What’s your lighting? May just be the picture but the nem looks a little faded. Zoas appear to be reaching to light as well.

Potentially, inadequate light is causing it to roam
Kessil a360x the new one I have been doing less lighting to try and acclimate my hammer so it has been on the lower side but he’s moving non stop before this …the zoas are reaching until I hit the higher intensity then they shrink back up
 
I just don’t think he’s ever gonna settle and maybe I should get a tiny one I just feel bad for my clowns they love it
 
Kessil a360x the new one I have been doing less lighting to try and acclimate my hammer so it has been on the lower side but he’s moving non stop before this …the zoas are reaching until I hit the higher intensity then they shrink back up
they shouldn't shrink, just be stable and fully extended but not stretched, maybe a case of the light being too high and then too low?
 
if a big ones moving a tiny one will.
I thought maybe a tiny one would find a hole easier since they have smaller foots. I feel like this bta is perfectly healthy he just can’t find a spot to put his foot in so my hypothesis was maybe a smaller one I’d have a better chance
 
Rocks look brand new. How old is the tank? What are your parameters? What is your lighting schedule?
 
they shouldn't shrink, just be stable and fully extended but not stretched, maybe a case of the light being too high and then too low?
That’s how they look when the lights higher any better or still stretching right? This freakin light cost me over 400 bucks lol what the heck
 

Attachments

  • D2FFEBF7-903E-46F4-9DEC-8159E524CCA9.png
    D2FFEBF7-903E-46F4-9DEC-8159E524CCA9.png
    797.5 KB · Views: 45
I thought maybe a tiny one would find a hole easier since they have smaller foots. I feel like this bta is perfectly healthy he just can’t find a spot to put his foot in so my hypothesis was maybe a smaller one I’d have a better chance
they really dont need that big a hole, they dont have bones and are super squishy, its not the fact its big, its the fact it is stressed most likely
 
That’s how they look when the lights higher any better or still stretching right? This freakin light cost me over 400 bucks lol what the heck
because you need to make a better lighting schedule or your params are bad, how old is tank, params and any param shifts?
 
Rocks look brand new. How old is the tank? What are your parameters? What is your lighting schedule?
because you need to make a better lighting schedule or your params are bad, how old is tank, params and any param shifts?
I’ll post them later I have it written down I posted it on here everyone said it was fine just my ph is low 7.6 …tanks 3 months old please don’t say I needed to wait 6 months for a anemone bc even in my old 90 gallon I had put a bta in with my clowns the first week and it survived np I don’t believe he’s moving bc he’s unhappy with flow or lighting I Think he just wants a big hole to stick his foot into that I just can’t give him in this smaller tank
 
Sorry to say but the maturity of the tank is definitely a factor. I currently have 4 nems and their foothold has never been an issue. Two of them are just stuck to the side of a rock and haven't moved in months. Without knowing parameters and lighting schedule we can't help any more though. I run kessil 360's on my tank and am lax on my water changes. However tank is 4 years old now and my nems grow like crazy and never move.

16414001337906638314603616343309.jpg
 
Agreed with tank being too new, I have kept BTA’s for years and they never move for me because I make sure to wait until tank is stable… now they won’t stop multiplying…
Patience is always key in this hobby and if most people ask for tank age is because that’s usually the issue with nems when the tank is too new
 
Agreed with tank being too new, I have kept BTA’s for years and they never move for me because I make sure to wait until tank is stable… now they won’t stop multiplying…
Patience is always key in this hobby and if most people ask for tank age is because that’s usually the issue with nems when the tank is too new
But the nem has doubled in size since I got it the 2nd week in it opens up beautiful and still has its bubble tips I thought it was doing great :/
 
If I take it out I think my clowns will commit suicide
Taking it out isn't necessary at this point. Getting your own accurate tests like salifert should be step 1. If parameters are in order and lighting is good you could try and add some mature rock to stabilize the system. What is your schedule and settings for the kessil?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top