Can someone tell me what these are?

skinnycow7

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 2, 2016
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So today my sister found these little guys growing on one of our rocks. We have absolutely no idea what they are. We think they're some sort of coral but we haven't ventured into that part of the saltwater world yet so we're not sure. There are 5 of them and they turn and can fold in on themselves. Our flame angel likes to try to eat them as well so what can I do about that?

20160302_215051-1.jpg
 
Here's another angle. For the longest time we barely any growth in our tank, and then I got a protein skimmer. Now our tank is exploding with growth and we don't know what half of the stuff is. It makes me happy but I want to be able to take care of whatever grows, I don't want it to die because I don't know how to care for it.

20160302_222328.jpg
 
Looks like a small zoanthid or palythoa. Most likely came on the live rock. Not harmful to the reef. Don't try to get rid of them and definitely don't boil the rock (not that you would do that anyways also google palytoxin). These are part of the zoanthid family an can be grouped under LPS. They are not SPS corals.

Good luck
thenanoreef
 
Can the palytoxin harm the fish?? All of my fish were fine until these showed up. First my flame angel started acting funny and now all of them are. I've checked the levels and the temperature and everything is normal I have no clue what else could be wrong. I haven't put anything new in my tank in over 3 months
 
Make sure you wear gloves and eye protection if you try to mess with these! They are VERY TOXIC!!! Wash your hands well afterwards and avoid touching any cuts on yourself when handling.

Happy Reefing!
 
Interesting the reaction some have with these. I unfortunately have a tank full of them and have taken scissors and just started cutting and ripping them off rocks several times without any reaction at all (no personal protective equipment). However, I have never boiled them as the owner of the most serious reaction I've read did, and his entire family was ill, including the dogs!
 
Ok first things first:

yes these particular objects are a species zoas/palys and can be considered desirable corals and can be kept or removed depending on your plans for the reef.

No- zoas/palys are not categorized as LPS as they are not stony corals
No- your fish are not reacting to palytoxin, if that's the case there would be thousands of reef tanks out there with no fish

Palytoxin is something to be cautious around when handling and cutting zoas/palys, however simple precautions of latex gloves and eye protection and proper care of the workstation and any removed zoas/palys will mitigate those risks.

Yes there are stories out there of accidents with palytoxin, but there are thousands of reef tanks that have the same corals without issues and while is good to have knowledge about them, the fear mongering is not necessary.
 
Ok first things first:

yes these particular objects are a species zoas/palys and can be considered desirable corals and can be kept or removed depending on your plans for the reef.

No- zoas/palys are not categorized as LPS as they are not stony corals
No- your fish are not reacting to palytoxin, if that's the case there would be thousands of reef tanks out there with no fish

Palytoxin is something to be cautious around when handling and cutting zoas/palys, however simple precautions of latex gloves and eye protection and proper care of the workstation and any removed zoas/palys will mitigate those risks.

Yes there are stories out there of accidents with palytoxin, but there are thousands of reef tanks that have the same corals without issues and while is good to have knowledge about them, the fear mongering is not necessary.
Thank you for the information. I don't understand what happened to my fish then. My flame died and I have no clue how to help the rest of them. I haven't changed any part of my routine, literally the only thing different is the coral. My mini carpet anemone is even acting weird. Usually he's open and his colors are awesome but ever since the fish started acting weird he just stays folded up. He's still alive I've gotten close to him just to see if he'll move and he does but I don't know what's wrong. My four striped damsel has like spaz attacks and is breathing really fast. I have a bubbler, the filter adds air as well as the protein skimmer, and I have two power heads so I know there's oxygen in the tank. Do you have any suggestions on what to do?
 
Ok first things first:

yes these particular objects are a species zoas/palys and can be considered desirable corals and can be kept or removed depending on your plans for the reef.

No- zoas/palys are not categorized as LPS as they are not stony corals
No- your fish are not reacting to palytoxin, if that's the case there would be thousands of reef tanks out there with no fish

Palytoxin is something to be cautious around when handling and cutting zoas/palys, however simple precautions of latex gloves and eye protection and proper care of the workstation and any removed zoas/palys will mitigate those risks.

Yes there are stories out there of accidents with palytoxin, but there are thousands of reef tanks that have the same corals without issues and while is good to have knowledge about them, the fear mongering is not necessary.
Thank you for the information. I don't understand what happened to my fish then. My flame died and I have no clue how to help the rest of them. I haven't changed any part of my routine, literally the only thing different is the coral. My mini carpet anemone is even acting weird. Usually he's open and his colors are awesome but ever since the fish started acting weird he just stays folded up. He's still alive I've gotten close to him just to see if he'll move and he does but I don't know what's wrong. My four striped damsel has like spaz attacks and is breathing really fast. I have a bubbler, the filter adds air as well as the protein skimmer, and I have two power heads so I know there's oxygen in the tank. Do you have any suggestions on what to do?
 
Do you happen to know your water parameters? If you can provide the chemistry on the tank it may be helpful in determing the cause of the issues.

If it was me, I would start doing large water changes to help reset the tank parameters and see if that improves the health of your animals
 
Do you happen to know your water parameters? If you can provide the chemistry on the tank it may be helpful in determing the cause of the issues.

If it was me, I would start doing large water changes to help reset the tank parameters and see if that improves the health of your animals
Temp:78-79
Nitrates:>20
Nitrites:0
Ammonia:0
Salinity:1.027
 
Almost does sound as though there's something toxic in your water - I'm no pro though, so please take my opinion with a healthy grain of sea-salt.

I'd be tempted to run a water change in that situation.

~Bruce
 
Yeah I would start doing some large water changes and observe for improvements. A small bag of activated carbon would help pull any contaminants out of the water as well.
 
Yeah I would start doing some large water changes and observe for improvements. A small bag of activated carbon would help pull any contaminants out of the water as well.
Do I just put it in the tank? Or in the filter or something? I already have some in the filter. Should I clean the filter out as well? I just replaced the bag of carbon not even a month ago.
 
Activated carbon usually has a pretty short life in aquariums and is usually rendered useless after a month especially. I would go ahead a replace the carbon in your filter and start doing some water changes. The water changes are the priority as they tend to remove a broader spectrum of compounds, faster.
 
In my opinion your salinity is a tad high but not enough to do what you're describing. A few questions. How mature is the tank? How big is the tank? How many fish and what kind? Is there coral in there and if so, how are they? A couple things that came to mind, 1) Are you using a new bag of salt? and 2) could there be an issue with stray voltage or a leeching piece of equipment
 
In my opinion your salinity is a tad high but not enough to do what you're describing. A few questions. How mature is the tank? How big is the tank? How many fish and what kind? Is there coral in there and if so, how are they? A couple things that came to mind, 1) Are you using a new bag of salt? and 2) could there be an issue with stray voltage or a leeching piece of equipment
Yeah I thought it was high too but I didn't really put too much thought into it since .001 above the range. My tank is around 6 months old, I now have 6 fish (four damsels, a coral beauty angel, and a tomato clown) in a 58 gallon tank with a mini carpet, a chocolate chip starfish, and those polyps (which I'm debating on removing or not). I have the same giant bucket of salt I had when I set the tank up (about to buy a new one). I don't believe anything is malfunctioning. I did a 25% water change 3 days ago and cleaned all of my equipment and nothing seemed off.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top