Two dwarf angels in the same tank is asking for trouble with the exception of a large tank where they can each establish a territory. In a 58, that could be a problem and it's possible that could've been an issue with the flame. Your water parameters are good if the starfish is doing well since they need good water quality. Chocolate Chip Starfish are not reef safe and will in time eat those polyps since they eat soft corals, which those are. When I mentioned equipment leeching I was referring to the possibility of magnets rusting or sometimes a seam can split in a piece of equipment or a crack and that can allow toxins to leech into your tank