This is a great set up. Maybe I missed it, but what made you decide to go back to dosing versus the CA reactor?
My Alk has stayed steady at 7.8-8 with it, but my calcium has slowly climbed from the low 400’s to a max of 515 with the reactor being the only thing adding either calcium or Alk. If I’m going to have to dose soda ash to continue using the calcium reactor, I might as well just dose everything for control.
The benefit to a calcium reactor is the addition of trace elements that are also in the coral skeletons. I realized though, that while this is better than 2-part, the trace elements only include those used to build the skeleton, not anything that may have been in the tissues of the coral flesh.
With the addition of Triton, Aquaforrest, and ATI essentials, dosing now contains all elements known to be consumed by a living reef, and are continuously supplied in the average uptake of those elements. To me, I know that ATI essentials will contain, within reason, the same concentration of elements from batch to batch.....whereas a refill of calcium reactor media may be different depending on what was in that batch.
Stability is life or death in a Reef, and after running the most stable calcium reactor setup I can, I still haven’t found that stability.
I'm curious as well as to why you are using the maxspect gyre controller versus an gyre interface module to link the gyre/s to your apex?
Cost is a major factor. You can run 2 Gyres on one maxspect controller/power supply, and they are synced seamlessly. I think there are enough adjustments in the macspect controller to handle anything I need, and it’s something I won’t mess with much after the initial setup.
Curious about the CaRx as well, ALK & Cal work hand in hand, not sure how ALK can be stable & Cal can rise. My Masterflex & CaRx is probably my best & easiest addition to my tank.
There are a ton of variables in a tank and calcium reactor setup. pH required to dissolve the different elements...the media used and what elements they contain...what is in your reef taking in those elements.
While calcium and Alk work together, they aren’t 100% of the time in sync.
@Randy Holmes-Farley has studied this and agrees that a proper dosing setup will always be more stable than a calcium reactor.